8 ms·
U.K. unveils plan to penalize Facebook and Google for harmful online content
- equalunique 8y ago1984 is set in London
- nkkollaw 8y agoIndeed.
- setquk 8y agoWell at least we're leading in something in the UK still: craziness.
- csmattryder 8y agoI suppose it's easier to "ban the internet" rather than fix the societal issues that have lead to people integrating with the sort of communities that share harmful content - that requires serious effort. Having said that, Facebook et al. are US-based corporations, they'll take as much notice of this as me whinging about privacy violations. We've also got that porn-pass coming in soon, apparently. Both of these government internet plans are completely routed with the use of a VPN.
- arethuza 8y agoThey may be US-based corporations but they will have wholly owned subsidiaries here in the UK - looking at Companies House (where you can see their audited accounts) in 2017 Facebook UK had a turnover of a billion pounds, probably a good bit higher by now: https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/06331310 https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/06331310
- csmattryder 8y agoWhen a House Select Committee can get Zuckerberg or Pichai in front of them to demand answers to their Cambridge Analytica questions, then I'll concede that the law can take on these corporations. Last I noticed, best they've had is some third-party contractor for Facebook, and they had to get the serjeant-at-arms to pin him down at his hotel. If it hits the fan and they go to take profits, nothing stopping them pulling an Amazon and taking the cash out to a subsidiary abroad.
- ben_w 8y agoRight now, Brexit is consuming over 100% of the sustainable effort of the UK government. If the UK government decided Facebook was no longer welcome, it would not be able to operate in London. On the other hand, if the UK government was functioning correctly, it also wouldn’t need to be that heavy-handed.
- pjc50 8y agoWell above 100% of the sustainable effort. It's being run like a failed software project, with important decisions running on until 10pm. All kinds of normal leave has been cancelled; MPs are being wheeled out of hospital or missing the funerals of their parents for this.
- jamespo 8y agoI'm sure you can think of lots of ways a government can coerce a company if they really want to
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> When a House Select Committee can get Zuckerberg or Pichai in front of them to demand answers to their Cambridge Analytica questions, then I'll concede that the law can take on these corporations The UK has broad extradition rights with the United States. If Parliament wanted to get nasty, they could.
- arethuza 8y agoIn a world where the UK might be struggling to find international friends I don't think anyone would be daft enough to try and extradite a leading citizen of the US. The chances of the US agreeing to any such extradition are even smaller.
- rjf72 8y agoA more optimistic view is that if nations hit on the centralized bodies hard enough, it may end inadvertently end up driving the creation and adoption of truly decentralized internet options. Consider how crack downs on things such as Kazaa are what ultimately helped spur on the creation and rapid adoption of things such as torrents. The UK porn ban in particular has some major potential. All it's effectively doing is creating a huge vacuum in the market for a decentralized PornHub. The irony of the world is that progress often requires egregious action to finally drive counter-action. We should've long since been moving towards a decentralized internet, but 'meh, why? what we have works.' is typical. Until it doesn't work. And so for that, cheers to the UK!
- pjc50 8y ago> We've also got that porn-pass coming in soon, apparently The implementation of this was delayed because they couldn't make it work, which is something of a hallmark of this government. I suspect something similar will happen to anti-Facebook legislation.
- sametmax 8y agoBesides, I'm pretty sure banning is only gonna make those community feels like they are being persecuted for being right and itching the man. They then will proceed to find another place that is less easy to control to carry on with their message, and will have a renewed feeling of legitimacy and urgency. What's even worse is that it may very well be used to censor even more things in the future, as people with a new toy tend to make use of it. In the end, removing space to debate about hot topics like those will make the angry people feel like loosing even more respect (a big motivator in their initial believe), while preventing anybody else to build a sane approach to it (you need to be exposed to hate to be a functional member of an imperfect society).
- HNthrow22 8y ago>> "Besides, I'm pretty sure banning is only gonna make those community feels like they are being persecuted for being right and itching the man. >>They then will proceed to find another place that is less easy to control to carry on with their message, and will have a renewed feeling of legitimacy and urgency." You left out the most important part, by forcing them to 'another place' you cut off their entire supply of fresh young, disenfranchised lonely young men to indoctrinate and recruit into their hateful belief system. Yes they will claim they're persecuted and play that up but by denying them the platform they'll also lose relevance, reach and impact. This is just a small step in the right direction. Despite warnings from many we've let the internet became a hate indoctrination tool under the guise of free speech. Only now that multiple shooters motivations can be directly connected to 'internet indoctrination' is action being taken. This is long overdue and truthfully just a good first step, closing this pandoras box will require a concerted global effort and even that may still prove to be unsuccessful.
- sametmax 8y agoThe problem with this logic is that the exact same arguments are used by totalitarian systems to shut down the opposition. And like with this comment, they are sure they are the good guys and are doing what's right. What's more, we had plenty of hatred before internet. They managed to recruit enough people way before we had internet or even television. The fact is, this "solution" is just hiding a symptom, which not only gives a false sense of security, but makes treating the disease even harder. And of course, it's a slippery slope.
- john_minsk 8y agoThe act is illegal. Should we penalize police for not being able to stop this action? How is the information about the act illegal?
- gnode 8y agoExpecting police to prevent all crime is fantastical. Police generally serve to enable punishment, deterrence and incapacitation of criminals. Furthermore, there is a distinction in motivation between propaganda and journalism, but the information itself is unaware of this. If a terrorist beheads someone, then sends a video of it to a journalist who publishes it, is the journalist simply reporting the news, or are they aiding terrorism? Certainly, the video may influence the audience, and cause fear, as the terrorist desires. How we can, or even whether we should solve issues like this is a polarising topic.
- kmlx 8y agoso what about websites that only deal in "harmful" content?
- rootlocus 8y agonothing compares to the traffic social media receives.
- kmlx 8y agothis is the end result of news titles such as "facebook elected trump", "facebook caused genocide", "facebook is at fault in New Zealand", "facebook caused Brexit".
- Thermolabile 8y agoGood! Despite the Brexit fiasco, the UK is getting this issue correct. Our Congress will NEVER regulate the Silicon Valley billionaires because they have been completely bought.
- verroq 8y ago>targets a wide array of web content, including child exploitation, false news, terrorist activity and extreme violence Ah the good old Four Horsemen of the Infocalypse.
- ben_w 8y agoIf false news is incapable of causing harm, then surely no amount of false news telling people “it is a problem” could possibly be a problem that causes anyone any harm?
- XCabbage 8y ago"If [strawman] then [you are wrong because your strawman is stupid]" is not a persuasive argument.
- ben_w 8y agoI have seen a lot of people mock the idea that “fake news” is a problem. I might be accidentally nut picking, but it’s no straw man.
- XCabbage 8y agoAnd I would be among those mocking the idea, but that's because I think: 1. The supposed harms of particular lies are frequently overblown. 2. The outright lies that have the most potential to do damage to society are those that get peddled by the mainstream media and believed by huge swathes of society, but the conventional "fake news" narrative of progressives focuses instead on obscure dedicated fake news sites run by Russians. 3. The proposed cures for this supposed evil of "fake news" all involve giving large institutions the role of determining what is true and censoring all dissent. That is a recipe for a society whose beliefs are far more divorced from truth than the one we currently live in, not less. None of that is equivalent to the claim that literally no harm is ever done by lies in the news. I don't think anyone believes that, and I think you're badly misreading those of us who are contemptuous of the "fake news" narrative if that's the interpretation of our views you've walked away with.
- doctorstupid 8y agoWhen you don't like what you see in the mirror, it's easiest to just blame the mirror.
- mhandley 8y agoBut if repeatedly looking in the mirror actually causes you to become more vain, or develop body dysmorphic disorder, then the mirror itself might not be entirely healthy. Cause and effect in societal matters are complex; there are usually no simple fixes, but that doesn't mean we should never try. Whether this particular attempt will be successful, I doubt though.
- jstanley 8y agoIf the mirror is harmful, you can stop using it. You don't need to cripple mirrors for everyone else.
- rootlocus 8y agoIf people knew when to stop, we wouldn't have addiction problems. If people knew what was bad for them and could stop, well, that would be a very different world.
- doctorstupid 8y agoWho is to say that society has a body dysmorphic disorder? Are governments such trusted doctors? Should a government control a society's self-image with an airbrush? If one doesn't believe that individuals are responsible enough to govern their own communications, then perhaps so. But I believe that the best society-doctor is society itself, and given past and current efforts, am skeptical of the sincerity of governments when they do pull our their airbrushes. Mass-murder-selfies are obviously evil, but what about mentioning factory air pollution? I know of one government which will readily airbrush over such online blemishes, and if these two seem ridiculously far apart, remember that wedges start thin. The latter example raises what I believe to be the main point of government airbrushing - to better its own mirror-image, rather than for the health of society. Speaking of censorship, why has my comment been grayed out?
- pmlnr 8y agoAre these regulation dangerous? Yes, they are. They can easily be bent to censor, to cover up nearly anything. But are these regulation useful? Yes, they are. When I was a teenager online - early 2000s - extreme violence was hidden behind obscure websites, not even indexed by search engines. I had friends who had "shocking videos" - think videos of actual killings - and I really tried to stay as far as I could. In the past few years articles and publications regularly emerge that these topics and videos are now basically mainstream. After deep diving into instagram, tumblr, or twitter, to see if these claims are real, I'm going to say, they are, and this is very far from healthy. We need some regulations; I'm only afraid they will be an overshoot, for what the chances are too high.
- piker 8y ago[edited for tone] The proposition that something requiring a "deep dive" is now "mainstream" seems internally inconsistent. Also the proposition that offensive content being available on the internet following such a deep dive is "very far from healthy" needs a citation.
- pmlnr 8y ago"deep diving" - my term for stepping out of the "AI" preferred content social media would normally show to me. Check trending topics, follow them deep down into popular groups, hashtags, etc. > > and this is very far from healthy. > Citation needed. I still believe in that bright future pre-cyberpunk science fiction was promising us. Citation enough?
- Zenst 8y agoAre we entering an age when we will in effect end up with geo-fenced content filtering firewalls built on the back of that lovely catch-all `political correctness`. Look at the great firewall of China, how was that perceived initially and how is that perceived today. For some the perspective is still the same, for others, they see a more upfront way compared to how we are in effect seeing Governments implement comparable systems by forcing that filtering and content blocking/restrictions upon private companies. Whilst we are all for free speech and openness, we see governments all around the World curtailing those area's on the back of laws and regulations that are born out of a small minority and edge-cases. After all - seeing sites blocked on the net because 0.01% of the content falls foul of some law or regulation and that being classed as fine. Yet transpose that same mentality onto people and cries of discrimination and racism jump right out at you. Are we seeing the majority of people being sleep-walked into being firewalled upon what content they can see and what they can say akin to the great firewall of China? Sadly, I think we are.
- TorKlingberg 8y agoThe current debate about tech industry / social media regulation is really frustrating to me, both on HN and elsewhere. First, there are a lot of people calling for regulation without thinking through the consequences. I see a lot of right-wingers and even libertarians thinking regulation will force tech companies to allow more racist etc content. That is not going to happen. Regulations will make social media companies be even stricter on "extremist content", whether of the Islamist or white racist variety. Second, people here refuse to engage with the arguments of those proposing regulations. There are real problems that we will not be able to brush off. On the internet, "think of the children" has long been a sarcastic phrase. In reality, faced with a choose between allowing for example pro-ana content that encourage teenagers to starve themselves to death, and annoying 25-year-olds who want a free internet, most people will choose regulation.
- nkkollaw 8y agoWhatever pro-ana content is, there have been books about starving yourself, building bombs, committing genocides and whatnot since printing was invented. It is not the platform's or the internet's responsibility if a minuscule percentage of teenagers starve themselves to death because they watch a video. If a teenager isn't equipped enough to be able to not starve himself to death because someone on the internet tells him to do so, it is the parents' fault, and the parents' responsibility to keep that teenager off the internet and into a psychiatrist or psychologist office.
- gnode 8y ago> it is the parents' fault, and the parents' responsibility The idea that parents should have such sole responsibility over their children is one extreme of a spectrum of opinion. UK government policy tends to be on the other end of that spectrum, with the opinion that children are the state's responsibility, with forced adoption being used much more readily than the rest of Europe, for example. It's also hard to reconcile the idea of childrens' mental health being the sole responsibility of parents with the causes of childhood mental health problems very commonly being abusive and neglectful parenting.
- mschuster91 8y agoCan we all please stop electing politicians that understand nothing about the Internet? This runs in the same vein as the "terrorism filters" that the EU plans to introduce after the "upload filters". They want to revert public discourse to the "old" model with newspapers as moderating gatekeepers and to kill independent (and free) venues. This is not about terrorism, porn or "national security", this is about re-entering the Middle Ages. And the problem is that thanks to the ultimatively arrogant "disruption" culture the big tech companies are in a defensive position now and not an offensive one.
- throw2016 8y agoThere is always 'censorship' in operation. Either overtly when things are not allowed or covertly where some things are simply not aired, people not given visas, opportunities, blacklisted and generally isolated. The problem is when people take an absolute and utopian position pretending these are actually not in effect when they always have. Perfect examples are hate speech and incitement to violence and even things like nudity and pornography. Most countries have laws against this. For instance most islamic extremism videos and content are already banned and taken down rapidly, preachers and other known purveyors of hate are not given visas and are not allowed to air their views. That's clear cut and no one has a problem with it. Since most ideologies and religions have an extreme element they will propagate extreme views and incite hate, and the question then becomes if you are comfortable having social media full of people openly spreading hate against religions, race, sex or any other subgroup. And its here we must explicitly beware of double standards and some people supporting some kinds of extremism opportunistically and muddying the waters under the pretext of free speech because it doesn't threaten them personally.
- papermill 8y agoThe UK does it and the media spins it as "penalizing social media for harmful online content". China does it and the same media spins it as "oppressing, tyrannizing and controlling the people". Just like when germany passed censorship laws, the media praised it and russia copied the german censorship laws and the media spun it as "tyrant oppressing and controlling the russian people". So is romeo and juliet going to be banned suicide because it "encourages" suicide? What about suicide/euthanasia documentaries which support doctor-assisted end of life programs? What about books like ( bible, koran, mein kampf, etc ) that encourages violence? Is project gutenberg going to be shut down? What about all the media companies who supported wars in iraq, libya and the middle east? Are they going to be shut down? Are they going to be shut down for encouraging violence? We have government agencies that spread fake news and disinformation. Is that going to be banned? What about PR firms whose business is spreading fake news and disinformation? And what is children accessing inappropriate material? A christian or muslim parent thinks that lgbt material is inappropriate. Does that mean we have to scrub the internet of lgbt material? An atheist might be religious material as inappropriate for children. Do we ban religious material from the internet? Whenever politicians use "children" as an excuse to justify more laws and regulations, it's rarely about protecting children. These people don't care about children. They care about power and control. Once agin, the UK is at the forefront of censorship.
- feintruled 8y agoWeird how Zuckerberg is actually pushing for this kind of action: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/30/mark-zuckerberg-calls-for-tighter-internet-regulations-we-need-a-more-active-role-for-governments.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/30/mark-zuckerberg-calls-for-ti... Makes me smell a rat. Perhaps a world in which Facebook can delete whatever posts they choose at the drop of a hat citing vague 'issues' is one they actively want?