4 ms·
I have come across fair share of blog posts on how horrendous this is getting in the current age of big data and app economy. This behaviour is warranted by how
by ignoramous 8y ago
I have come across fair share of blog posts on how horrendous this is getting in the current age of big data and app economy. This behaviour is warranted by how VCs, PEs, and potential acquirers value a company... by number of users an app tracks. Boils down to battle for eye-balls all the way down because ads are guaranteed revenue stream that scales in-propotion to number-of-users * user-engagement, I guess.
I think everyone agrees there's a market for a simple-to-use solution.
Folks at https://GuardianApp.com https://GuardianApp.com are doing just that for iOS. For Android, apps like NoRootFirewall, NetGuard, Glasswire exist and other solutions like XPrivacyLua require root, or flashing LineageOS/ChromeheadOS and/or de-googling the phone voids the warranty. Most of the 2 Billion Android user-base wouldn't go anywhere near these.
A stop-gap then might be to provide a zero-touch / firction-free Firewall/VPN app that's "free" and one that's anti-surveillance and anti-censorship, but is also transparent, in that it enables end-user to inspect the traffic flowing in and out of their devices.
The challenge is no one wants to pay the internet provider and a random VPN app for a censorship-free / surveillance-free internet but they might gladly pay the internet provider extra premium if they offered the same experience. I know my dad wants this, but he wouldn't pay two entities for the same service.
May be what https://puri.sm https://puri.sm is doing is the eventual end-game, but I think they're trying too hard. May be its time for an Android phone-manufacturer to launch a privacy focused phone. OnePlus reached its heights by placing itself as a Nexus/Pixel killer offering vanilla Android experience... so may be there's a market for privacy focused phone too, or may be https://e.foundation https://e.foundation might pull this miracle off and become mainstream enough to matter.
Eventually, though, governments have to step in and bring forth regulations that prevents relentless surveillance of the end-user, similar to how wire-tapping phone-calls is illegal.
- paulcarroty 8y ago> May be its time for an Android phone-manufacturer to launch a privacy focused phone. LOL, they don't need it. Privacy focused phone doesn't generate money from user data. There's two ways: dumbphone or Apple.
- tokyodude 8y agosee post above yours. Apple is not protecting your privacy. in fact they are explicitly disallowing your privacy to be protected.
- move-on-by 8y agoDoesn’t apple disallow these types of apps? AdGuard has to discontinue their VPN based ad blocker due to Apple’s chance of policy [0]. I’m not sure why guardian app is any different? Looks like MalwareBytes had the same issue, which would be more inline with GuardianApp’s stated goal of being a firewall. I don’t see how this app will be allowed. 0: https://adguard.com/en/blog/adguard-pro-discontinued/ https://adguard.com/en/blog/adguard-pro-discontinued/
- tokyodude 8y agothat doesn't sound like Apple is protecting my privacy like they claim . it sounds the exact opposite of protecting privacy
- givinguflac 8y agoPersonally I disagree, from the perspective of an average user. While you and I are able to tell the difference between an adblocker and a nefarious vpn collecting all my data under the guise of adblocking. For the average user, they have absolutely no idea and don’t care, which is why disallowing vpn-based Adblock makes sense to me from an average user privacy standpoint.
- tokyodude 8y agoBy that arguement Apple should disallow all Appa. Any app could be a scan.
- angott 8y agoThose ad-blocking local VPNs lead to terrible battery life. And nobody can know what they are doing behind the scenes. I agree with Apple blocking them. I just wish they had a public API for developers to offer apps that block the resolution of DNS names, just like they allow ad-blockers in Safari. They already have it, but it is restricted to supervised devices used inside organizations: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/networkextension/content_filter_providers https://developer.apple.com/documentation/networkextension/c...
- SomeHacker44 8y agoI want the features these things offer without the requirement to use a VPN. That gives too much trust to the VPN operator. All of this can operate on device at the OS/IP stack layer. I use Little Snitch on the Mac and it works great.
- ignoramous 8y ago> All of this can operate on device at the OS/IP stack layer. I think, on Android, with root you could do a lot more and not have to use VPNs at all. > That gives too much trust to the VPN operator. Local VPN apps like NetGuard are open-source, btw. And server VPNs like ProtonVPN have no-logs policy. I'm curious, what other guarantees are you looking for?
- SomeHacker44 8y agoGuarantees? None. I don't want all my traffic routed through some random VPN company's servers. Small companies are probably also judgement-proof, as even if they really harmed you, what could you gain by suing them? Why would I want to use a VPN to enforce access controls my OS can do just as well?
- ignoramous 8y agoI don't think little-snitch can tackle anti-censorship or can really prevent ISPs from snooping up on you? VPNs like Orbot might be required then.