5 ms·
Most people use the word socialism incorrectly. They look at social democracy which is just markets with redistribution and safety nets, and they say “socialis
by EGreg 8y ago
Most people use the word socialism incorrectly.
They look at social democracy which is just markets with redistribution and safety nets, and they say “socialism”.
Any welfare programs that help the poor - they say “socialism”.
They look at cities and countries engaging in State Capitalism and call it socialism.
Socialism is collective ownership of the Means of Production.
Examples of textbook socialism include:
Communes and Kibbutzes
Co-operative housing
Credit Unions
Employee owned corporations
Open source projects
And you can have democratic governance of larger structures, which MAY be called socialism:
The public stock market (capitalism and socialism can coexist).
- gcb0 8y agoand then there's the definition from countries too close to nazi germany and/or the ussr at some point in its history: a term they will politely but enfaticaly deny, always.
- FranzFerdiNaN 8y agoNazi Germany was of course an example of national-socialism, which was a branch of fascism, not socialism. The name is very difficult for people to understand (although loads of people willfully misunderstand it), but saying it was socialism is like saying the Democratic People's Republic of Koreais an example of why democracy or republicanism is terrible.
- black-tea 8y agoYou start with a set of things and you map them to a smaller set of categories. The more you learn about things, the bigger your set of categories becomes, until eventually you find the sets are equal. Far too much effort is wasted arguing along the way.
- kebman 8y agoIf you look at the Nazi program, up to 50% is clearly Socialist in nature, while the rest is Nationalist and Nationalist-Socialist. Thus it's fair to say that there are more similarities between Socialism and Nazism, than differences. Critics use the fact that Hitler "cooperated" with the big companies, rather than fully nationalizing them, as a way to claim that he wasn't Socialist, however that is misleading. While Socialists would send the Kulaks to their deaths in the Gulags, Hitler kept his business leaders alive as long as they cooperated. Thus Russia threw away expertice, while Hitler kept it. This lead to great economical advances in Germany, though at a terrible human cost. Meanwhile the more traditional Socialist approach in Russia didn't really lead to much ecnomical progress at all, while having a comparably terrible human cost.
- smcl 8y agoIf you think Nazis had anything to do with Socialism, I suggest you read up on what the Nazis did to the Socialists in Germany ...
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agoThey send the competition to the camps, but at the same time for example made it really tough to evict people from flats for landlords. Nationalistic socialism was a socialism too. They even had the enormous debts and mismanagment (Mefo-Wechsel), that in addition with racism and a non-fertilizer agriculture made the "Expansion" in all directions necessary to avoid collapse.
- goto11 8y agoThe "great economical advances" of Nazi Germany were just Nazi propaganda.
- xtk 8y agoThat is what is taught in school, and I always thought it was right. But many Italian facists started as socialists and they certainly learned the methods: - Individualism is squashed in both systems. The citizen solely exists for the state and is to be exploited as a worker or cannon fodder. - Both systems had worker holiday cities for propaganda and constant reeducation. - Both systems had many youth organizations for indoctrination. - Both systems had nationalized radio. - Both systems sent their opponents into Gulags/camps. - In both systems, if you pretended to be a follower, you'd be taken care of (that arguably is the socialist aspect of national socialism). National socialism did not actually nationalize companies, but they were certainly under control of the state. The point is that while the ideologies were different, the outcome was not completely dissimilar (even antisemitism with purges was there under Stalin). National socialism had an overtly murderous ideology, while the marxist one pretended to do one thing and did quite another.
- Retric 8y agoThose are effective means of population control. Propaganda and indoctrination for example where used by every country in WWII because they where efficient methods independent of ideology. At most you can look at efficient surface similarities and say this ideology does not prohibit these actions.
- cbarker20 8y agoIsn't that what people are doing here: Looking for significant overlaps? Consider the NSDAP KdF program and mentally replace the swastika with a hammer and sickle: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strength_Through_Joy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strength_Through_Joy Obviously NS is not 100% equal to abstract pure socialism, I think we can assume that everyone here knows that.
- hevi_jos 8y agoFascism was socialism by itself. The creator of Fascism was Mr Mussolini, himself a member of the communist party in Italy. It was only that Mussolini wanted to create a socialist movement independent of the International Socialist , the Komintern, which was controlled(and financed) by Soviet Russia, following the interests of that country. So he created a socialist movement with the interest of Italians first, nationalistic. Hitler then copied the movement in Germany. To say that nazis were not socialistic(and socialized the means of production) is like saying that Trosky was not communist because he was assassinated by Stalin. Of course they were the worst enemies between each other, but there were not big differences in the way they planned the economy. In the civil war in Spain, in the left side there were independent anarchist and socialistic leaders and they were killed by Stalin, not Franco.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gcb0 8y agothe amount of people confusing fascism with actual socialism, not just the empty political rethoric used by the nazis in this thread makes me lose all hope in humanity. facism has aspects based on syndicalism, a subset of the socialism true, but its far from the defining characteristics of a true social equalization. syndicalism (and then facism) is based on categories within a society. the best definition, used in a trotsky speach, is that facism is "socialism for the upper and middle classes". if you apreaciate the sweet irony you can clearly see why facism can never truly be seen as socialism. if you miss the irony, you should just call yourself alt-rigth.
- vnot2 8y agoWhere do you see the confusion? People are pointing out that opportunistic former "communists" created fascism by tweaking the methods and ideology for personal gain and power. Actual socialism has never, and will never, be implemented. People are not idealistic enough (most people just want to avoid work) and it is always the wrong people who grab power.
- antipropaganda 8y agoMost people also use the word capitalism incorrectly. The capitalism-socialism dichotomy is largely an invention of Marxists. Many who oppose socialism do so because they prefer a society where individual justice is not overshadowed by "collective justice". The idea is that people are expected to work for their benefits, save up money to form capital and then invest that capital to create a safety net for themselves. Most people on the conservative side are not opposed to helping people who can't help themselves or giving people who did their best but fell on hard times, a break, through bankruptcy. If a country has a large amount of natural resources like Norway, it can be somewhat successful in dispensing with individual excellence. For example, Qatar has the highest per capita income in the world. However, this may not be sustainable since natural resource eventually run out. For example : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Nauru#Modern-day_Nauru https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Nauru#Modern-day_Na... Norway used its oil profits to create a sovereign wealth fund and invested it in stocks. What is the system called when dispensable income is used to form capital which is then invested in other ventures to create additional revenue streams ? I would call it capitalism. If all countries where Norwegian money is invested decided to become socialist and seized their property, Norway will not be upheld as a socialist success, would it ?
- Gravityloss 8y ago> If a country has a large amount of natural resources like Norway, it can be somewhat successful in dispensing with individual excellence. I'm not sure what is meant by this? I would assume that the more resources the government or the community has, the more they can support people's talents. You can invest more in education and arts. > Norway used its oil profits to create a sovereign wealth fund and invested it in stocks. What is the system called when dispensable income is used to form capital which is then invested in other ventures to create additional revenue streams ? I would call it capitalism. True, that's a good point, it's state level capitalism. If instead the oil money went into tax cuts, what would one call that policy then? Antisocialism?
- kwhitefoot 8y ago> If instead the oil money went into tax cuts, what would one call that policy then? Antisocialism? Perfect!
- NPC32419419 8y agoThis is the definition from Encyclopædia Britannica (1911): Socialism is that policy or theory which aims at securing by the action of the central democratic authority a better distribution, and in due subordination thereunto a better production, of wealth than now prevails.