4 ms·
Environmentalism and Western Capitalism don't seem at all compatible: either we kill the environment or we kill capitalism ...
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
Environmentalism and Western Capitalism don't seem at all compatible: either we kill the environment or we kill capitalism ...
- CamperBob2 8y agoBecause the Communists were just so darned kind and gentle to their environment.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoWhat's that got to do with it? There are more than just 2 possible financial/political systems. Any particular communists you have in mind, there are few extent groups, kibbutz dwellers appear to be reasonably environmentally conscious.
- CamperBob2 8y agoWhat's that got to do with it? You first. What does capitalism have to do with it? You're the one who brought an unrelated sociopolitical agenda to the thread, it seems. kibbutz dwellers appear to be reasonably environmentally conscious. Says someone with their own 3 GHz personal computer that was decidedly not built by kibbutz-dwellers.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoYes, I'm part of the problem. Unfortunately I can't unilaterally move us away from Western Capitalism. Why does the dominant financial ideology relate? Because it prefers profit above everything, so externalised costs aren't considered if they'll provide a return on capital -- impoverish your workers, fine if that leads to profit; wreck the environment, fine if that leads to private financial profit. Changing to a more communist ideology, eg all workers owning the companies they work in, restricting ownership that massively exceeds needs, democratising the benefits of automation. These sorts of things might restrict technological development, but if they can help to save the environment, and reduce the massive wealth inequalities (some of which hark back to feudalism) then that's good. The FOSS movement seems to have made good advances despite being communistic, perhaps not as great as private software development, but certainly not without progress. The main problem is that capitalism calls out to greed, which everyone feels and falls to. Communism calls to selflessness, which requires us to rise above our base natures.
- anticodon 8y agoI think communism had much less impact on the environment. For one thing, there were exactly zero disposable products. And everything was recycled. We brought the milk/soda bottles back to shop for maybe 10% of the price. Paper and metal was recycled also. We had to gather metal and old newspapers and magazines and bring them to school at least once a year. There were much less garbage. No plastic bags and bottles everywhere.
- rixed 8y agoThat's actually quite related to the problem at hand actually, which is the problem of externalities (as stated a bit above in the thread). The problem of externalities, ie of costs that are unaccounted for, is a side product of an economic system that fragment economic interest into many small actors, and where, as a consequence, the larger picture is only partially taken into account, leaving void areas (unsolvable, unfulfilled needs) and cracks (externalities). It can be argued that another economic system would do better, but claiming it has nothing to do with it just reveals how taboo it is to challenge the dominant view, even in our times when that dominant view is really not threatened at all in principle nor in practice. Interesting.