58 ms·
Motel 6 to Pay $12M after Improperly Giving Guest Lists to ICE
- shawnz 8y ago> "Motel 6's actions tore families apart and violated the privacy rights of tens of thousands of Washingtonians," What? I'm pretty sure ICE's actions were what tore those families apart. Why aren't they being punished for illegally requesting the data without a warrant? Maybe the Motel 6 employees who wrongfully gave the data felt pressured, given that ICE is a government agency just like the DOJ?
- dboshardy 8y agoWhy not both?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Why aren't they being punished for illegally requesting the data without a warrant? It's generally not illegal for ICE (or government more generally) to request information without a warrant (not having a warrant or other compulsory basis just means people are not legally compelled to acquiesce to the request), and the state consumer protection law at issue neither purports to, nor could it Constitutionally, apply to federal law enforcement agencies.
- gpvos 8y ago> the state consumer protection law at issue neither purports to, nor could it Constitutionally, apply to federal law enforcement agencies. That baffles me. When a federal agent is in a state, they should be bound to the laws of that state. And additionally, it should be illegal for any government agent, federal, state, or local, to ask someone to do something illegal. How could that constitutionally be otherwise?
- mey 8y agoHow was it illegal for ICE to request the data? It certainly wasn't ethical, but what is right and what is legal are not the same thing. Hell it sounds like the only law broken according to the article was a Washington State consumer protection law. Hence the settlement is against Motel 6 and not against ICE.
- shawnz 8y agoPerhaps it's not illegal by the letter of the law, but it certainly seems like a major injustice to me. Could it be considered entrapment if Motel 6 was pressured into giving ICE the information?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Could it be considered entrapment if Motel 6 was pressured into giving ICE the information? No, because ICE agents are not agents of the State of Washington, and the prosecution was by the State for violations of State law. ICE agents are, in terms of entrapment, no different than ISIS agents would be in this case. EDIT: Also no, because entrapment is a criminal defense, and this was a civil consumer protection case.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago"ICE agents are, in terms of entrapment, no different than ISIS agents would be in this case." ICE agents have some degree of lawful authority legally vested in them at some level of American governance, so it stands to reason that individuals can make the claim they felt 'required by some law' to do as that agency apparently behoved of them. Especially if ICE were making statements along the lines of 'you're legally required to do this or that', then there's an issue here.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Especially if ICE were making statements along the lines of 'you're legally required to do this or that', then there's an issue here. If they were—which no account of this case I’ve seen has suggested—there is certainly an ethical issue, but not an issue that should negate Motel 6’s liability under the state law at issue here. In fact, if it's employees were not aware of the prohibition on turning the material over without a warrant, and this were susceptible to social engineering indicating that they should do so, that would seem squarely to be Motel 6’s responsibility.
- rhizome 8y agoThis is not the first time law enforcement has gone for motel records, nor even local cops being friendly with the night attendant. Motel 6 should be (or should have been) telling their employees that they aren't required to hand out any information without a court order or warrant.
- FireBeyond 8y agoMore than "aren't required", but under Washington state consumer data protection laws, "are prohibited from".
- sonnyblarney 8y ago" I'm pretty sure ICE's actions were what tore those families apart." No, crossing the border illegally is the 'root cause' - not ICE. ICE's shenanigans are an artifact of that. But yes, it seems weird that a private entity is in trouble for doing what a government agency 'required' of them. These grey areas really need to be sorted out, it seems the laws are still unclear. I think there are probably a ton of ways to sort the border out if there weren't so many extreme voices on all of this.
- ancorevard 8y ago"I'm pretty sure ICE's actions were what tore those families apart." ICE only enforce the laws that already exists. So only two possible parties are at fault here: 1. Congress, if the current laws are bad. 2. Parents, if they are in violation of the law.
- shawnz 8y agoRequesting Motel 6 to break the law is clearly far outside the scope of enforcing the laws that already exist.
- mikeash 8y agoIf only that were so. There’s no law requiring ICE to target Hispanics, hassle people speaking Spanish in public, or hold US citizens for months. In fact, the law says they can’t. This doesn’t seem to stop them.
- Matticus_Rex 8y agoIf you sign up to enforce evil laws, you're voluntarily choosing to do evil. Multiple parties can all be at fault at the same time.
- shard972 8y agoHow are border/immigration laws evil?
- patrickg_zill 8y agoThe person who should ultimately be blamed is the person who is illegally in the US. Why blame the cops for the arrest of a criminal?
- cortesoft 8y agoSo I assume you blame Rosa Parks for not sitting at the back of the bus? It was illegal to do what she did, so therefore she was a criminal. Not saying that has to be the case here, but just because something is against the law doesn't mean breaking it is morally bad.
- lamarpye 8y agoYour comment seems to be saying that this is the case here. Otherwise, why invoke Rosa Parks if there is no connection. I am sure I can find a long list of murderers and rapists that ICE has deported from the country, does opposing ICE mean supporting murderers and rapists?
- patrickg_zill 8y agoIf you believe that illegal aliens are coming to the US for the express purpose of civil disobedience (I think that is a fair summary of what Rosa Parks was doing), please show evidence of this.
- ihm 8y agoPeople are coming here because they think they can find a better life. What is the argument for trying to stop that? Also, the phrase "illegal alien" is extremely dehumanizing. These are just people.
- billner 8y agoEveryone in the world wants a better life. The reason for stopping it is the same reason all countries south of the US also have immigration laws.
- fucking_tragedy 8y ago> What? I'm pretty sure ICE's actions were what tore those families apart. Why aren't they being punished for illegally requesting the data without a warrant? Motel 6 violated Washington law by giving information away without a warrant. ICE can ask nicely for data from anyone, but you only have to comply if they have a warrant or subpoena.
- pnutjam 8y agoGood, hopefully this deters others
- matt4077 8y agoI, too, hope this will deter other companies from illegally handing over the customers‘ data for frivolous fishing expeditions by law enforcement.
- throwaway287391 8y agoIs GP getting downvoted because we're assuming this isn't what they meant?
- matt4077 8y agoThat was my reading of it, but on second thought it’s almost perfectly ambiguous. There’s a certain glibness about it that fits better with the malevolent interpretation. Plus hoping for a fine to serve as an example seems just too obvious to merit writing it down? It’s almost a work of art. Or maybe a Rorschach test. Will the internet interpret your statements in the best or worst possible light?
- throwawaymanbot 8y agoincredible.. just incredible. Its like the last days of the Soviet Union here.
- bradlys 8y agoWhy would ICE run "latino-sounding" names through and not just all names through whatever ICE database they're cross-referencing? Did they get a 10,000 page print out instead of a spreadsheet file? (why not Scan + OCR + cross reference with database - would be way faster) Just seems like ICE employees are only targeting latinos... intentionally. And that's the most bothering part of this to me. We're cool with Swedes overstaying their welcome...
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThe article is misleading and there's no indication there was any intent to target Latinos, rather, as a result of the handover, Latinos ended up being targeted i.e. if Latinos are more likely on ICE's target list (entirely plausible) than this is going to happen after cross referencing. Edit: re-reading now and it indicates ICE was highlighting Latino names specifically.
- bradlys 8y agoFrom the article: > "According to our interviews with employees at Motel 6," he told NPR's Scott Simon, "ICE agents would circle the names that looked Latino-sounding and ran those names through a database and then would detain individuals based on those random checks." Seems pretty intentional targeting to me.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoYes, I re-read that and that definitely implies some kind of filtering, my bad.
- KorematsuFred 8y agoWell anyone who has dealt with ICE, Border Patrol this does not even remotely surprise me. I had a French-American friend who went to France without his daughter's American passport. When he returned back the Agent did not even ask to see the little girls passport. Had this guy been Latino he would be called a child smuggler.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nostromo 8y agoThis is... strange. When the federal government comes asking for your help, I think it's pretty normal for people to provide that help. In a just world, if the government asks for something inappropriately, then the party at fault is the government. (In other words, Washington should sue ICE, not Motel 6.) If we want companies to require a subpoena to share information with the federal government (and personally I do want that) then we should set that standard in law. And we should enforce it fairly, not based on the hot political topic of the day. (How much information does the CIA and FBI vacuum up from Washington telcos in a day in violation of this law, and why isn't anyone held to task? Maybe because they have better lawyers than Motel 6.) Helping the federal government do its job and then getting sued by the state seems like mom getting mad at you for doing what dad asked you to.
- matt4077 8y agoThey are fined for improperly handing over data. It seems we have already set that standard in law.
- lixtra 8y agoSo who from the federal government is charged for their part of the crime?
- Scoundreller 8y agoIts taxpayers of course.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- matt4077 8y agoSorry, I only now got OP‘s intention. I believe it’s somewhat defensible to task only one side here with protecting the data. They have that data all the time, and it’s therefore more practical for them to explore the legality of such requests. They are also the party entrusted with that data by the customer, and therefore have a fiduciary duty. It also aligns with the idea of those profiting from data to accept liability for its protection. There’s probably also a federal/state law angle here that I’m unqualified to opine on. Also: this is civil law, and therefore nobody was or will be charged (just a pet peeve).
- jaclaz 8y agoOnly as a data point for comparison, here in Italy (due to a Law originally established in the '70's for counter-terrorism purposes) when you check in (in a hotel, B&B and similar[0]) you need a valid document and you are registered (name, surname, date and place of birth, current address and type and number of document) and this info is sent (nowadays electronically) to the Police within 24 hours. [0] a recent extension to the Law now requires the same also for the "short rentals" which then include also all AirBnb and similar
- tptacek 8y agoYeah, we're ostensibly not big on that kind of surveillance here.
- idlewords 8y agoWe run it unregulated in the private sector instead.
- throwawaysea 8y agoThis is also true in a few other European countries I’ve been to
- patrickg_zill 8y ago"ICE agents would circle the names that looked Latino-sounding and ran those names through a database and then would detain individuals based on those random checks." This was in no way unreasonable. If you were looking for people who were Asian you would focus more on last names of Li, Park Ajinomori rather than Berkowitz or Adams.
- alistairSH 8y agoBut they're looking for illegal immigrants, not Latinos. There's a certain amount of overlap between the groups, but they are not the same set.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> But they're looking for illegal immigrants, not Latinos. They're supposed to be looking for illegal immigrants, but that doesn't mean that's what they are doing.
- lamarpye 8y agoWhat were they doing then? I would love to hear your theory.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoThere is a greater mathematical correlation between Latino surnames and illegal aliens who are staying in Motel 6's than there is between say, Japanese surnames and illegal aliens staying in Motel 6's. Do you deny this?
- zelon88 8y agoThe government told Motel 6 to comply with a request and then the government sues Motel 6 for complying with the request. Sounds like par for the course to me!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- linuxdude314 8y agoI'm really surprised at the amount of people defending the actions of ICE and Motel 6 in this instance. ICE has clearly demonstrated tactics that are anti-immigrant (legal or otherwise). How quick some are to forget the importance of immigration in the startup community!
- toomuchtodo 8y agoYou can support immigration in the startup community but not support illegal immigration. Of course ICE is going to target illegal immigrants; it’s part of their mandate. This doesn’t excuse ICE exceeding their authority, which requires a patch via legislation. China, India, Canada, and Mexico (countries with large populations and those that border the US) would all give me the boot if I tried to illegally immigrate there (and rightfully so). Sovereignty and the rule of law are important.
- wl 8y agoThis settlement seems grossly inappropriate. It seems very likely that this practice, which lead to deportations, caused far more than $12 million in damages.
- wybiral 8y agoPutting aside the fact that companies can definitely challenge these requests... What tech stack is ICE storing and managing all of this data with that companies keep handing over to them?
- stevespang 8y ago$12 million fine for just being good citizens . . . .
- speedgeek 8y ago$12M plus roughly a few hundred since I will never ever stay in a Motel 6 or invest in anything Blackstone Group ever again. Even if they leave every freaking light on.
- paxy 8y agoI can't believe the number of people who are defending Motel 6 here. Anyone who works for a mid-large sized company in certain departments will know that government agencies and police departments are always asking for stuff. It is not illegal for them to do so. The correct answer to 99% of these requests is "this is confidential/proprietary information" or "come back with a warrant". There is zero excuse to do anything illegal because someone official-sounding asked you to do it.
- nullc 8y agoIt is the norm in many industries to cooperate with any law enforcement request received. In some, doing so is the only way to avoid being named a defendant in your customer's unlawful actions (or being hit with fines for violating an endless list of regulations that are violated by everyone in your industry and effectively impossible to not violate). So you may be seeing some amount of guilty consciences here...
- anon4lol 8y agoSelling you minute by minute geolocation from your phone: Acceptable. Credit card companies and retail companies selling your purchasing history: Acceptable. States selling license data and even your license photo: Acceptable. Municipalities selling property tax information to anyone: Acceptable. Unicorn companies monitoring your every move and everything you do on the internet: Acceptable. Motel 6 employees giving registration information to law enforcement for free: NOT OK.
- test6554 8y agoI can see a day where every guest of every hotel in every country is photographed and submitted to the government for things like warrants and visa status. It could happen seamlessly at check in rather than randomly pulling records in bulk after the fact.
- arcticbull 8y agoSomething similar happens in China already. Any place you stay as a visitor (whether a hotel or a guest house) your passport is scanned and submitted to the police. If you don't check in within 24 hours, they may come looking for you.
- SamReidHughes 8y ago> Motel 6 also has signed a legally binding commitment to no longer share guest information without a warrant at any of its locations nationwide That’s convenient. They’ve made other agreements with police departments to provide guest information at particular locations. This sounds like a way to prevent being subject to such shenanigans.