7 ms·
that $5 a day adds up The article isn't advocating that you buy a coffee every single day. It's saying a. focus on larger issues and b. it's okay to do a littl
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
that $5 a day adds up
The article isn't advocating that you buy a coffee every single day. It's saying a. focus on larger issues and b. it's okay to do a little self care and a little self indulgence.
I sometimes bought myself a fucking coffee of some sort at Starbuck's back when I was homeless. I needed the caffeine to help treat health issues. It let me plug in for an hour and get some electricity for my tablet, plus spend an hour on the internet because I was wi-fi dependent. It helped me feel like a human being and not just go fucking kill myself.
I was working on my larger problems, like getting healthier, paying down debt and developing a better earned income. I eventually got off the street.
I still don't have a lot of money. I still have to make judicious purchasing decisions. I still sometimes find that the best answer is splurging on taking care of myself.
Sometimes, taking care of yourself in some way is the best investment you can make. Sometimes, that means buying an overpriced coffee.
- hopler 8y agoYou got a lot for your $5. At the other end of the spectrum are chronically bankrupt people maxed out on credit card debt who buy a takeout $6 giant candy coffee whenever they go anywhere and don't even bother to finish drinking it before they have to throw it away because they are walking into a restaurant. This story is based on true events.
- jodrellblank 8y agoSounds like that person has fewer risks of losing all their savings in a freak accident, and lives with more luxuries. Is that not .. an understandable way to live?
- degrews 8y ago> The article isn't advocating that you buy a coffee every single day. It's saying a. focus on larger issues and b. it's okay to do a little self care and a little self indulgence. I agree. But I don't think the people making the argument for spending less money on coffee are arguing against those two things. They are not talking about never going to a Starbucks. As you point out, there are circumstances where buying a latte can provide a lot of value. But those situations don't account for most of the money being spent on $5+ lattes. In most cases, it's people in poor financial health, who are not saving enough, and who spend a significant amount on minor luxuries which don't actually contribute meaningfully to their lives. They do it just out of habit. It feels like a sacrifice to stop, but only because it requires giving up a habit. All habits are hard to give up.
- DoreenMichele 8y ago“The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to buy $5 lattes unless they have already socked away 15% of their income into a retirement account, have at least 6 months of salary in a savings safety fund, and generally live about 10% below their means or can manage to articulately justify it to internet strangers as somehow having gotten a lot out of it while homeless.” ― Anatole France's great, great, great grandchild I've seen pieces that indicate that poor people spend on average like $90 per month on lottery tickets and other forms of gambling. If they invested that instead, they would have a meaningful nest egg. I think that's a brilliant thing to point out. So, certainly, it can be reasonable to suggest that sometimes poor people can make better choices than they are currently making and it can, in fact, meaningfully improve their lives. But most such arguments really boil down to "The beatings shall continue until morale improves." because we simply don't approve of poor people having any bright spots in their dreadful, miserable lives. It's generally disingenuous to act like if poor people just give up a few small luxuries, they, too, can invest their way to being millionaires. This is generally not true. I see it as malicious behavior to act like poor people can save and invest their way to wealth with a little self discipline, like giving up their coffee. Doing so is the rare exception. It is not how most rich people got rich by any stretch of the imagination.
- glitchc 8y agoThank you for this.
- nugget 8y ago>It is not how most rich people got rich by any stretch of the imagination. Have you read the Millionaire Next Door? I suppose it depends how you define "rich" these days, but the data in that book seems to indicate that most US dollar millionaire households are dual middle income workers who live below their means for decades and actively save and invest the difference.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMost poor people are poor because they have special needs and/or are responsible for others with such. They can't reliably work a full time job or doing so comes at a real cost and they are constantly working at just being able to show up at all. From what I have read, most rich people are business people. They got there by growing a thing of value. They own the local gas station or, these days, they got into YC and got VC money plus assistance figuring out how to grow a business. There is also the standard trope of "He got rich the old fashioned way: He inherited it." As a teen, I expected to be part of a two-career couple. I didn't know I had an undiagnosed genetic disorder. I didn't expect to have two special-needs children. I didn't expect my husband's career to be antithetical to me developing a career of my own. An awful lot of things have to go right for two people to both work consistently for decades while living below their means, including marrying someone who is on the same page with you in that regard. My ex and I not being on the same page about money was a major bone of contention in the marriage. Money is usually one of the top two issues in bad marriages. Then divorce tends to do an excellent job of seriously damaging one's finances, even if they were in good shape beforehand. I have two adult sons that still live with me. I keep saying "If we each earned X amount per month, our financial problems would be solved! We could sock away money like crazy, buy a house, etc!" So far, we haven't figured out how to get all three of us working full time and hitting X amount per month. Not everyone is able bodied. Not everyone has marketable skills. Sexism, racism and so forth are alive and well and have very real impacts on the lives of a lot of poor people. Etc. It's really rather insulting to probably most of the world to act like all you have to do is marry the right person and both of you have long and successful careers and both of you be on the same page about money and live below your means. It's not that hard! While the divorce rate in the US hovers around 50 percent. Historically, yes, if you got a job and kept your nose clean and yadda, your job provided you with retirement and medical coverage, etc. A lot of people these days are working for the gig economy with no benefits and making pathetic amounts of money. I'm always interested in learning what actually works and how things actually get done. But most of the arguments here amount to victim blaming, and don't confuse me with the facts. So it might be time for me step away from this discussion. I'm really finding the subtext of a lot of it quite infuriating.
- thaumaturgy 8y agoThere was an illustrative article on this topic a few years ago [1]: "It’s not like the sacrifice will result in improved circumstances; the thing holding me back isn’t that I blow five bucks at Wendy’s. It’s that now that I have proven that I am a Poor Person that is all that I am or ever will be. It is not worth it to me to live a bleak life devoid of small pleasures so that one day I can make a single large purchase. I will never have large pleasures to hold on to." (I really recommend reading the whole thing, for those that have never lived that situation long-term.) There's additionally a more recent study on the cognitive effects of long-term poverty [2], which essentially finds that poverty skews prioritization in financial decision-making and produces long-term decision-making stress which amounts to a massive ongoing cognitive load. Attitudes like ~ineedasername's are just fucking infuriating, especially when posted in response to an article in which the entire point was that saving money on coffee is not a habit which in isolation will make a huge difference in anyone's financial future. It's only about one step removed from victim blaming. Impoverished people aren't poor because they occasionally buy coffee. They're poor because there's an economic system currently in place which is slurping as much wealth away from as many people as possible to feed it to just a few. [1]: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/11/your-brain-on-poverty-why-poor-people-seem-to-make-bad-decisions/281780/?single_page=true https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/11/your-br... [2]: http://review.chicagobooth.edu/behavioral-science/2018/article/how-poverty-changes-your-mind-set http://review.chicagobooth.edu/behavioral-science/2018/artic...
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI imagine a lot of people saying "Just give up your $5 coffee and you, too, can be a millionaire someday!" are trying to be realistic without being wrist-slashingly depressing about life. But it amounts to left-handedly saying "The big problems in your life/ the world that make your $5 coffee An Issue for your budget? Yeah, honey, you can give up on solving those. Justice just ain't a thing."
- benj111 8y ago"entire point was that saving money on coffee is not a habit which in isolation will make a huge difference in anyone's financial future" As ineedausername said. It isn't meant literally, its about a mindset. Its about pointing out that mindlessly spending $5 everyday adds up to $xxx,xxx. If its still worth it for you then great, but make that decision consciously. I'm not even sure the advice is aimed at poor people, rather middle income people that spend their entire wage (plus) each month.
- knicholes 8y agoWhich health issue does coffee treat?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoCoffee (caffeine) is a stimulant. It's helpful for a lot of things that are routinely treated with stimulants. In my case, that generally means respiratory issues and allergies. People who drink a lot of coffee are probably self-medicating for something or other, possibly without realizing it. My coffee consumption always goes up when I'm exposed to more allergens. When it goes down, it's because I'm feeling better, not because I have self discipline.
- gjs278 8y agoyou can get caffeine pills in the dollar store if a medical fix is needed but typically there are more targeted fixes for respiratory than caffeine
- _bxg1 8y agoHe's also hooking into a larger narrative battle, where lattes and avocado toasts are stand-ins for social-darwinist poverty-victim-blaming. "You're not poor because we've screwed up the economy, you're poor because of your character flaws."
- jimbokun 8y ago"The article isn't advocating that you buy a coffee every single day." That is EXACTLY what the article is advocating, very explicitly. Your case sounds very different than the "$5 latte a day habit", which is probably just someone standing in line in the morning, grabbing their coffee and absent-mindedly sipping it as they walk to the office. You got an hour of shelter and a comfortable place to sit in a nice environment, plus power and wifi, in addition to the caffeine and enjoyment of a nice beverage. It sounds like you made an efficient use of the limited resources you had available to you. And I think the $5 latte is meant to be a symbol of how to get your expenses under control, not a complete retirement plan. Add to cutting out the lattes cooking more meals at home, cutting your cable bill to the most basic Internet only plan, looking for a cheaper cell phone bill, buy a beater instead of a new car next time you need to purchase one... Once you have your emergency fund, most debts payed off, and are starting to save a reasonable amount for retirement, then the $5 lattes maybe aren't going to kill you, as long as you keep your overall spending within your means.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoFrom the article: Let’s consider five reasons why you should occasionally treat yourself to a cup of Joe. It's arguing against the people saying "Your daily coffee habit is costing you a million dollars!" It's saying that is nonsense. That isn't the same thing as issuing the opposite edict that you, yes you, need to rush out and drink coffee every. single. day. Defending your right to make such purchases as you see fit isn't actually the same thing as insisting you spend $5 a day on coffee. But I imagine this comment will fall on deaf ears. Like the time someone asked how to foster independence in their toddler and I told the story about locking up the breakables when my toddler began hurling his dishes into the kitchen sink like it was a basketball hoop so as to let him do his thing without it going bad places. The eager young parent replied "I like that! I'm going to promptly start making my toddler put their dishes in the sink!!!!" (facepalm)
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y ago> It's arguing against the people saying "Your daily coffee habit is costing you a million dollars!" It's saying that is nonsense. Hopefully nobody is saying that. A $5 daily habit costs $20-30k per decade, after you factor in reasonably anticipated investment gains. No more no less. Viewpoints about what an ideal world would look like, or one's right to make such purchases, or whatever else, have zero impact on the cost. It is what it is. Each person has to make their own judgment about whether that cost makes sense for them.
- notyourday 8y ago> The article isn't advocating that you buy a coffee every single day. It's saying a. focus on larger issues and b. it's okay to do a little self care and a little self indulgence. Huh? That's exactly what keeps people that are on a cusp of climing out of the hole in a hole. It is too bad fatwallet.com is dead. It has very long threads ( years long ) of people describing the tiny improvements that they made and how over years it significantly affected their life in a way they could not imagine when they made that silly "I won't buy $5 late and instead add that $5 to my credit card payment" change.
- isoskeles 8y agoIt's saying focus on issues mostly out of your control (inflation). I'd prefer to focus on the things that are in my control. I agree that some level of indulgence is okay, obviously this is a balance. Everyone has to figure out what they're comfortable with here, but some people we know may have become way too comfortable and complacent yet still want to complain about their financial situation. These are the people who need to figure out why and how to adjust their behavior.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWhen I was homeless and going to Starbucks, I used to watch people get $60 worth of takeout coffee on a Saturday morning. Family was coming over. Everyone needed a cup. But no one tells well-off people to cut back on buying $5 cups of coffee by the dozen. No one suggests that if they saved that money, they could have two or three million more and, clearly, that's the morally correct thing to do. No one is saying coffee consumption is the root cause of terrorist attacks and calling for coffee abolition. No one is saying coffee is generally some kind of moral failing. It's apparently just a moral failing if you are struggling financially. And then you really need to quit it, you bad person you. This whole "Your coffee is the problem!" narrative is just judgy, moralizing nonsense. Why is it focused on expensive coffee in specific? Why not candy bars on your work break? Or the high cost of participating in the annual insanity we call Christmas? Because expensive coffee bought and consumed publicly is conspicuous consumption, something that is a pecking order signal of being one of The Haves. So The Haves are offended by The Have Nots participating. That's part of what this article is criticizing. Let The Have Nots have a small luxury here and there and quit picking on them over it. Geez. Personally, I mostly stopped doing Christmas (and Halloween) years ago. It's not obvious because I'm so fucking poor that no one expects me to buy them presents. But if you want to start a campaign to tell America that our modern Christmas habits are one of the roots of all financial evil in the world, I will happily promote your campaign. I'm sure you will be pelted with rotten tomatoes, because now you are also being judgy of the spending habits of The Haves, but I will support your right to subject yourself to that.
- Zenbit_UX 8y ago
- BenMorganIO 8y agoYeah... I did that too when I was homeless. More with Tim's though instead of Starbucks when I got my PNA; now BNA. Although, when I look back, it would have been smarter not to have done that. I did manage to save $600 when receiving $30 a week though.
- smsm42 8y agoI think the point is not "never ever buy a coffee again until the day you die (or retire)". The point is "examine your routine spending and see if you can cut off anything and use it as a source of money for savings". If you did that and consciously prefer saving a little bit less and indulge now and then, these recommendations are not for you, you're already past that stage. A lot of people didn't even get to "consider your spending, make a budget and evaluate your expenses and decide which ones you can do without". They don't even think in terms of considering whether it's worth it or not. I think getting people to think about that is the point of it.
- kpU8efre7r 8y ago>Sometimes, taking care of yourself in some way is the best investment you can make. Yes but is spending money on little things you don't need really taking care of yourself? I don't like the mindset that the only way to treat yourself or take care of yourself is to buy things.