12 ms·
If part of your audience consists of people living without much a safety net, that $5 a day adds up. Also, the author's point that saving that much isn't going
by ineedasername 8y ago
If part of your audience consists of people living without much a safety net, that $5 a day adds up. Also, the author's point that saving that much isn't going to be $1 million, but "only" as much as $500,000 then that point rather falls flat. Sure, inflation may decrease the utility of that amount of money, but it will also increase the cost of that latte, so you'll be saving more than just the $5 over time. Finally, this piece ignores the entire mindset of the "avoid the latte" point, which is that it's intended as much literally as metaphorically: don't waste money on the little stuff. $5 for coffee, another $100/month subscribing to every video streaming service and gold-plated cable package, etc.
Obviously if you're already socking away 15% of your income into a retirement account, Have at least 6 months of salary in a savings safety fund, and generally live about 10% below your means, this advice probably doesn't apply to you: you have more than enough to spend on the little stuff. But congratulations, you're in a significant minority, and this advice is aimed at the rest of the working populace who aren't in that situation.
- esotericn 8y agoRight. $5 a day is a significant amount of money to a huge number of people. In the UK, if you're on minimum wage, a 3 quid coffee represents approximately 5% of your daily income. If such an individual (someone who earned minwage for a lifetime) were to end up with even "merely" 100K in today's money at age 60 that would actually be an enormous amount relative to their cohort.
- failrate 8y agoIf someone has that marginal an income, they will never even begin to start a savings plan, nor will that money survive to retirement. It will be gobbled up by the first medical or vehicular emergency that comes up.
- hopler 8y agoI'd rather lose my savings in a vehicular emergency than lose my car and therefore lose my job and future income.
- atomwaffel 8y agoUnless of course they live in a country that has tax-funded health care and useable public transport, of which there are quite a few.
- markdown 8y agoHe/she is talking about the UK, where the burden of healthcare costs are shared by all taxpayers and there are no nasty surprises after a visit to the emergency room.
- failrate 8y agoWhereas I live in the US, where it is common to have to do a back of the envelope calculation whether to drive or take an ambulance. Pro tip: if you are conscious, you'll never take the ambulance.
- geodel 8y ago> 3 quid coffee represents approximately 5% of your daily income. So 60 pounds a day is minimum wage in UK? It seems to be very decent middle class income rather than minimum wage. Or maybe you meant 50%?
- jnurmine 8y agoMinimum wage in the UK seems to be around 1260 GBP/month, that is 60 GBP a day for an 8 h workday. This is pre tax. If it were 6 GBP/day you'd get 120 GBP a month (pre-tax). That is extremely low. Living with so little anywhere in Western Europe would be very challenging, if not impossible. I mean, stingy food shopping at Tesco for basic stuff four times a month would land at (guesstimating) around 10..15 * 4 = 40..60 GBP. This means eggs, bread, butter, vegetables, chicken, yoghurt etc. and no tobacco or beer. This estimate is probably too low as I did not count in soap, toilet paper, toothbrush/paste etc. Likewise, the minimum of 1260 GBP/month in UK or Western Europe is not a lot, but I guess enough to get by somehow. I am curious, what do you think is a high income in the UK (or Western Europe in general)?
- esotericn 8y agoIn London (admittedly a more expensive part of the country) renting a 1 bedroom flat will cost you approximately 1000pm. 60 pounds a day for 20 days is 1200pm. That is to say, it is impossible to rent a basic small flat and you will have to live with housemates or family. Even having done that, transport and basic food will suck up all of the rest of your time and money. It is by no means a 'very decent middle class income', in most of the South East it's poverty level. 6 pounds a day would be utterly comical, I'm not sure if this is a troll, I doubt that would be liveable in cheaper parts of Eastern Europe.
- biesnecker 8y agoI read this very differently -- if $5/day makes up a significant portion of your safety net spending, then you have much larger problems than the $5 delta your latte is causing. It's not that $5/day doesn't matter to anyone, it's that the people for whom it matters are facing much larger systemic issues that we're ignoring while shaming people for the smallest of luxuries. edit: missing word
- devoply 8y agoIf you are 20 years old and you start putting away $5/day and have 500k in the bank at 60. Who can argue with that. In fact they should pass a law to make this mandatory on everyone. It would greatly improve the lives of literally everyone.
- lixtra 8y agoIf you’re not free to spend the money in the bank then you don’t really own it.
- devoply 8y agoAnd so what? That's 1800 tax on you per year. Say it was charged as something like a tax. Nothing that most people in the Western world would be effected significantly by.
- lixtra 8y ago> And so what? What you propose is not much different from the social security many countries levy. Typically it’s not an economic efficient way of saving. The absurdity of the forced savings proposal becomes apparent if you cannot afford a life saving operation at age 59 because you cannot access your savings. Please don’t try to add exceptions now. Forced savings is just a bad idea.
- devoply 8y agoOkay. Your argument only becomes valid after the fact that all that money that would have been spent on things like coffee is retained. In most cases people would simply not have that money. Not to mention that if you have some guaranteed amount of money coming to you at some point it should be possible to get a loan using that as collateral. And I would like to see examples of forced savings where any of the supposed issues actually manifest compared to what we have now where we literally have millions of people with no savings and retirement ages that keep increasing. Almost 30 percent of households have less than $1,000 saved, MagnifyMoney finds, though the amount varies drastically by age. As of June 2018, millennials have less saved than baby boomers, because older Americans have had over three decades longer to save and larger salaries to work with. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/28/how-much-money-americans-have-saved-at-every-age.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/28/how-much-money-americans-hav... Here's how Americans' median savings breaks down by age: Millennials (born 1981-1998): $2,430 Gen X (born 1965-1980): $15,780 Baby Boomers and older (born before 1964): $24,280 In fact I could see something like this really putting a dent on all the privilege in America where African Americans and other minorities basically have no savings... and no potential for ever accumulating any real wealth. When grandma or grandpa can send their grandson to college or put a down payment on their house or give them a business loan, that's an actual difference in people's lives.
- bonestamp2 8y agoIt is an interesting phenomena, because it's a relatively expensive product for what it is, but it's also an experience. Even though my wife and I do quite well financially (and save plenty for ourselves, our kids college, etc), I noticed we were spending "too much" on espressos and lattes. Not too much for our financial situation, but too much for my comfort level at least. So, we bought a $600 espresso machine, which basically paid for itself in less than a year. Not to mention the time savings from going to get coffee. I was fully offering to make my wife's Latte every morning, although no pressure if she still preferred to pick one up. I figured if I stopped buying them it would still be decent savings. She wasn't all that keen on me making them for her... at least at first. The most surprising part though is that the lattes are actually better. I started out just trying to save a bit of money and naively assumed that somebody making hundreds of lattes per day would be far better at it than me, and maybe they can be, but perhaps due to the speed demand they cut corners. The consistency is off too, sometimes when I buy a latte it's very good and other times it's not. At home, I can (now) make it perfect every single time and it only takes 5 minutes including cleanup. Of course, I've discovered some other great things along the way like "steamed in" cinnamon and/or tumeric or adding baileys to lattes on the weekend or eggnog to lattes during the holidays. There is a bit of a ritual/experience to picking up coffee, and you lose that, but you gain a whole new ritual of making your perfect coffee for yourself... and even if you still pickup once in a while, you're still saving in the long run.
- bluedino 8y agoI could drink coffee/tea at home - but I use going to get a drink as an excuse for getting out of the house for a bit.
- _delirium 8y agoSame for me: spending time in a coffee shop is part of the value proposition, not wasted time! Buying a latte provides the excuse to hang out there for an hour or so.
- felipemnoa 8y agoThe fee of a Starbucks coffee is just the price of a co-working office space in my case. Well worth it. Much cheaper than using WeWork.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ultrasaurus 8y agoI agree wholeheartedly. I expect much of her audience is carrying credit card debt at 25% -- if you can change your subconscious habits to save $1000/year you stand a much better chance of getting back above water. Redo the calculations from a perspective of 20%+ interest, occasional late fees, the impact on your credit score & your mental health, and now skipping a latte makes a lot more sense.
- dublidu 8y agoIf someone already took out student loans, car loans, credit card debt, etc, then cutting out the latte (or cable or nail salon or whatever) is something that’s totally in their control and allows them to stop the compound interest on their debt. Of course they should try to find a better paying job, of course it sucks that it’s hard to get a better job, but latte is something you can do TODAY and doesn’t require a lot of effort.
- twblalock 8y agoThe point is to focus on the big wins. Save $1000 next time your buy a car and that covers almost a year of $5 lattes every weekday morning. If you overpay on your next car, or negotiate badly on your next job offer, the money you saved by not buying lattes was all for nothing. In other words, major financial decisions vastly outweigh the impact of a daily $5 purchase, so why focus on the small stuff? Yet much financial advice is about the small stuff, and this author is saying that's not a good approach.
- hopler 8y agoYou know what's cooler than saving $1000 every 7 years on a car purchase? Saving $8000 every 7 years on a car purchase and lattes.
- puranjay 8y agoWhy not do both? Save $1000 in coffee and another $2000 in car purchases. It's not like having an expensive cup of coffee has been an intrinsic part of human life forever. It's not even a 50 year old phenomenon. There are certain things you should treat yourself on, but a cup of coffee is too insignificant a hill to die on. Especially since I'm not sure how many people buy lattes everyday because they truly love lattes, and not because it is an extremely well marketed product.
- spenczar5 8y agoYou are getting caught in the specific, and losing perspective on the argument. It's not that coffee is specifically valuable. It's that large fixed costs are more important than small, frequent discretionary spending.
- puranjay 8y agoThe point applies to expenses other than coffee. You don't need most of the things you buy. America as such buys too much stuff. The first time I went to America, I was shocked to see how "full" every house was. Just packed to the brim with odd knick knacks that no one uses. The kitchen gadget industry is the perfect example.
- DoreenMichele 8y agothat $5 a day adds up The article isn't advocating that you buy a coffee every single day. It's saying a. focus on larger issues and b. it's okay to do a little self care and a little self indulgence. I sometimes bought myself a fucking coffee of some sort at Starbuck's back when I was homeless. I needed the caffeine to help treat health issues. It let me plug in for an hour and get some electricity for my tablet, plus spend an hour on the internet because I was wi-fi dependent. It helped me feel like a human being and not just go fucking kill myself. I was working on my larger problems, like getting healthier, paying down debt and developing a better earned income. I eventually got off the street. I still don't have a lot of money. I still have to make judicious purchasing decisions. I still sometimes find that the best answer is splurging on taking care of myself. Sometimes, taking care of yourself in some way is the best investment you can make. Sometimes, that means buying an overpriced coffee.
- hopler 8y agoYou got a lot for your $5. At the other end of the spectrum are chronically bankrupt people maxed out on credit card debt who buy a takeout $6 giant candy coffee whenever they go anywhere and don't even bother to finish drinking it before they have to throw it away because they are walking into a restaurant. This story is based on true events.
- jodrellblank 8y agoSounds like that person has fewer risks of losing all their savings in a freak accident, and lives with more luxuries. Is that not .. an understandable way to live?
- degrews 8y ago> The article isn't advocating that you buy a coffee every single day. It's saying a. focus on larger issues and b. it's okay to do a little self care and a little self indulgence. I agree. But I don't think the people making the argument for spending less money on coffee are arguing against those two things. They are not talking about never going to a Starbucks. As you point out, there are circumstances where buying a latte can provide a lot of value. But those situations don't account for most of the money being spent on $5+ lattes. In most cases, it's people in poor financial health, who are not saving enough, and who spend a significant amount on minor luxuries which don't actually contribute meaningfully to their lives. They do it just out of habit. It feels like a sacrifice to stop, but only because it requires giving up a habit. All habits are hard to give up.
- jchw 8y agoThe entire point is that spending $5 on a beverage should not financially break you. That, if not buying a $5 latte is the difference between financial success and financial ruins, something is very wrong. That, people are much better off focusing on large fixed costs. I agree with the post wholeheartedly... And I bet most of us could afford both the coffee and the $5/day investment, so the point shouldn't be lost on us.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y ago$5 a day. $1800 a year. In ten years a family of two has $36000. This is downpayment for a house.
- setquk 8y agoIn UK that's downpayment for a shed.
- jfk13 8y agoNot everyone needs to buy in London or Oxford.
- setquk 8y agoI don't want to live anywhere other than London.
- jfk13 8y agoOK, so that's your preference; yes, it'll cost you. (Personally, I wouldn't want to live in London even if it were cheaper than my current small-town location.) But please don't presume to speak for the UK in general just because you've picked a particularly expensive market.
- illvm 8y agoIt's a bit more complicated than that, no? I mean... if someone is a Londoner born and raised but has to leave in order to buy a home is a bit more complicated of a situation than "they picked a particularly expensive market" to live in.
- fludlight 8y agoThe author's point is that decades of wage stagnation combined with tremendous inflation in big ticket items (housing, healthcare, education) have made it impossible for the bottom 80% to save. That cohort will be perpetually broke because of housing, healthcare, and education. The other 20% won't notice the difference. Rent? Enjoy annual increases that eclipse your wage growth. Bought a home with rented money? You still have to pay the mortgage even if you get laid off. You still owe the same amount even if property values tank. If you deplete your savings you might face foreclosure, which, compounded with a down market could wipe out your equity. Most home"owners" don't understand these risks. Major illness or emergency? Your insurance plan is tied to your job. A full time job in a competitive field at a generous company will get you decent, affordable coverage. A full time job at a company that's circling the drain or is focused on shareholder value will get you expensive coverage that doesn't cover much. A part-time job means you get to look for health insurance on your own, a process that confounds even healthcare economists, and the quality of your options varies greatly from state to state. This is where you'll eventually end up anyway, since you'll be too sick to work. Your company will find a way to fire you. Once you deplete your savings, you might qualify for aid, but not much. Your parent/uncle/niece/unmarried SO needs money to treat a chronic illness? Government assistance won't cover everything. Neither will crowd-begging or their savings. Or yours. Have young kids? Daycare costs $15k-30k per year. Kindergarten is only 4-5 hours a day, elementary school is 6-7 hours. One parent can only work part time--very, very close to home, or drops out of the workforce for 10+ years. This destroys their career and lifetime earnings. Kids want to go to college? Financial aid is "need based". Live on the coast where your salary is high but so is the rent on your modest home? Too bad, need is not regionally adjusted. Are you poor and broke? OK, you have a need. Decades ago your child would receive grants, now they'll receive grants and loans. Hopefully you planned and parented well so they go to an in-state state school, otherwise they end up shackled to a mountain of debt. Frugality won't save you. Don't be stupid and live way beyond your means, but a latte a day doesn't matter. The most important thing is to get in the top 20% on one salary and hope you stay there.
- PButtNutter 8y agoThats not the point the author is making. The point being made is that if all that is stopping you from financial ruin is a $5 coffee a few times a week, you're pretty much already in financial ruin. The coffee really isn't and shouldn't be the thing making the difference.
- jfengel 8y agoThat's why the quote is there up front: "If spending $5 a day on fancy coffee puts your retirement at risk, you’ve got bigger problems." If you don't have a safety net, then indeed that $5 adds up. But if that $5 is critical to your safety net, then you're still not saving for retirement; you're saving up for the inevitable crises. This was originally in Bloomberg, and what's really going on there is an implicit critique of everything Bloomberg stands for. Bloomberg's target market does not include that significant minority for whom $5 a day is a big deal. Bloomberg tends to advocate policies that make life easier for its target market, and if it acknowledges that significant minority at all, it's with a tacit assumption that those policies will somehow trickle down money on them. The lesson is really "You have plenty of money. Spend it, and while you're at it, think about what we can do for those for whom $5 a day is a big deal." He's challenging the assumption that everybody is so poor that we need to scrimp every dollar and maximize our retirement funds. Maybe we should be more generous, starting with ourselves, including enjoying a latte now rather than decades from now.
- bigmanwalter 8y agoSomeone who gets it!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dba7dba 8y ago> But congratulations, you're in a significant minority, and this advice is aimed at the rest of the working populace who aren't in that situation. Wait, so you are saying people who can least afford to spend on daily luxury to spend more money? That is basically like a secret business plan of financial and credit companies, who basically get majority of their profit from overdraft, interest charges and fees.
- jimbokun 8y ago"Sure, inflation may decrease the utility of that amount of money, but it will also increase the cost of that latte" That is a very important point I missed the first time through. The author was only looking at the decreased utility of the saved and earned dollars, but not the increasing prices of the consumed good over time.
- fredgrott 8y agoit all depends on timing, ie the investment phase... If you are in your early 20s than yes every penny invested counts more given a 40 year plan to invest for retirement as the interest compounded adds up. However, those at the end of their retirement investment plan say in the last ten years its a different story where $5 a day will not matter much in terms of increasing investment funds for retirement.
- esotericn 8y agoIt'll matter if it does, and not if it doesn't. It's really simple. If you don't spend $5 now and you even get close to matching inflation that's a few dollars you will have in retirement. Most people seem to miss the point entirely on this and go off on some sort of weird tangent into calculation of exponential returns or whatever. The simple fact is that when you no longer have a job, having money is useful.