3 ms·
The obvious comparison to the GPU arms race is the VR hardware arms race. Same number of companies rising and falling in about the same period. Carmack is at th
by derefr 8y ago
The obvious comparison to the GPU arms race is the VR hardware arms race. Same number of companies rising and falling in about the same period. Carmack is at the forefront of both, too.
- ekianjo 8y agoYou cannot be serious. VR headsets have not been evolving at the pace of hardware back then. The resolution of headsets does not double every year or something and VR today is not much better than one year ago. Nothing comparable.
- taneq 8y agoLinear resolution maybe not, but pixel count is roughly doubling. Vive and Rift are both ~1k x 1k pixels per eye, first gen Windows Mixed Reality headsets came out a year or two later and are 1440 x 1600, and the just-announced HP Reverb is ~2k x 2k. The teased Valve Index is likely to be 2k x 2k as well, with a field-of-view bump from 110° to 135°.
- pfranz 8y agoThey talk about a 4 year timespan. The Oculus Kickstarter was in 2012. DK1 was released in 2013, DK2 in 2014, and the final Rift in 2016. The Rift-S is rumored to be released in 2019. None of those have had quite the leaps 3d did back in the late 90s.
- adventured 8y agoFor contrast, id went from Doom to Quake III Arena in six years (Dec 1993 -> Dec 1999). Thanks to the rapid pace of graphics card improvement and the engineers writing the software engines to keep up with it (Carmack, Sweeney, etc).
- santoshalper 8y agoVR has been a wet fart compared to 3d graphics. Tons of hype but very little progress and almost no broader impact on the technology or games industry.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoNot sure why you've been so heavily downvoted, perhaps there are a lot of people here working in the field. It definitely seems the case that the average consumer couldn't care less about it, however. VR is the new 3D TV.
- pjmlp 8y agoPeople were already trying to play Doom on the first iteractions of VR headsets during the mid-90's. I don't believe it ever become a real thing. AR on the other hand, has quite a few interesting industrial applications.
- mxfh 8y agoVR is a high friction/opportunity cost setup clutch and not a casual setup and interaction thing as TV. The biggest issue with VR is that it's by nature not a passive/low energy thing in it's default mode, it's way closer to sports and work than TV, so more niche as a recreational time activity. In essence VR competes with activites like soccer, badminton, shooting ranges, lasertag, trampolin parks etc. not general purpose home use TV. If you benchmark it against them VR, on it's current trajectory has a place to exist in garages and arcades. If VR/MR/AR gets away from being marketed as high energy activity there is a future there, if there is found a way to make headset's superficial or significantly lighter and easy to handle at resolution better than TV screens at the equivalent distance. Powerful wireless (standalone) headsets and couch compatible VR might take off.
- smcl 8y agoIn the Wolfenstein 3D black book, written by the author of this article actually, there's even mention of a company trying to do this with Wolfenstein 3D
- bluedino 8y agoI remember a million years ago at an arcade, seeing stand-up pods where you wore a VR headset and could play Duke3D
- 8y ago
- andrewmu 8y agoThe problem is that VR performance is tightly coupled to GPU performance. Currently, adding more pixels requires an equivalent increase in GPU performance to maintain quality. I'm prepared to believe that e.g. foveal rendering will give step-wise improvements without more GPU power, but it's not the same as the years of continual process improvements were for GPUs.
- mxfh 8y agoThe VR adoption got slowed down quite signifanctly by the artficial price inflation through the cryptomining boom happening in the same period over the last 3-4 years. Before that high-mid to high end GPUs were in a range of USD 200 to 500, inbetween they tripled in price and are now slowly going back. When FOVeated rendering and the equivalent of 2x4k at 90FPS+ are doable significantly below USD 500, i'm sure things will look different quite soon again. Before that, you could double GPU performance for same price every two years or so, now its about 5 or more years, when looking at GTX 970 vs RTX 2070 for example. In my opinion GPUs speed are at least three years behind trajectory because of this market anomaly. Just hope AI isn't throwing stupid money at GPUs again.