8 ms·
I can't agree with this. This is a mistake that the BBC has been making recently, thinking that all viewpoints are equally valid and deserve equal attention. I
by LeoPanthera 8y ago
I can't agree with this. This is a mistake that the BBC has been making recently, thinking that all viewpoints are equally valid and deserve equal attention. I strongly believe that that is not true.
- jazzyjackson 8y agoStarting an argument with the assumption that some view points are valid and some are not seems like a bad way to go into a discussion. Of course, on settled arguments where trolls abound, it does not reflect well to give a troll the same platform as the expert -- but this is not the case on all matters. There are still many fields (say, AI ethics) where consensus has not manifested.
- tfehring 8y agoI agree with this completely. But the Heritage Foundation, which Kay Coles James represents, isn't a conservative dissident acting in good faith. It actively misrepresents the scientific consensus, without the evidence or expertise to do so, such as by grossly misstating data related to climate change and clean energy [0] and hosting "experts" on transgenderism who are openly hostile to trans people and who have no background in psychology, biology, or other relevant fields [1]. There's a reason that there are no qualified experts claiming that decarbonization provides "essentially zero environmental benefits" [2], or that the transgender acceptance movement is tantamount to "[changing] the definition of women to include men" [3]. That reason isn't liberal bias - it's scientific consensus. Again, I completely agree that unsettled scientific matters are best served by a diverse range of experts, and that subjective matters are best addressed based on a wide range of opinions more generally. But organizations like the Heritage Foundation undermine those objectives, as well as their own credibility on more nuanced matters, by feigning expertise and making politically motivated arguments in bad faith. [0] https://www.wri.org/blog/2017/03/heritage-foundation-gets-it-wrong-costs-and-benefits-climate-action https://www.wri.org/blog/2017/03/heritage-foundation-gets-it... [1] https://www.heritage.org/gender/event/when-harry-became-sally-responding-the-transgender-moment https://www.heritage.org/gender/event/when-harry-became-sall... [2] https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/consequences-paris-protocol-devastating-economic-costs-essentially-zero https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/consequences-par... [3] https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1108365238779498497 https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1108365238779498497
- leereeves 8y agoDeclaring a scientific consensus before serious research has even begun renders the word "science" meaningless. Scientists haven't developed a test for transgenderism, or even identified a measurable difference, and what little research has been done comes from the politicized and not-at-all-rigorous "social sciences" whose reliability is questionable at best. There won't be an evidence-based scientific consensus (as opposed to an artificial consensus enforced by excluding anyone who disagrees with the party line) about transgenderism any time soon.
- tfehring 8y ago> Scientists haven't developed a test for transgenderism Transgenderism is a broader term and is often characterized by gender dysphoria. Aside from that, this is false. The American Psychiatric Association defines diagnostic criteria for gender dysphoria in the DSM-5, and they're listed on Wikipedia [0]. It isn't currently (and may never be) diagnosable by, say, a blood test or MRI in the same way that physical ailments often are, but the same is true of psychiatric diagnoses for many other well-established conditions. > or even identified a measurable difference It's well-established that a significant number of people meet the diagnostic criteria in [0], and that hormone therapy frequently results in substantial positive outcomes for those people [1] [2]. There's some evidence that the same is true of sex reassignment surgery [3], though the consensus naturally isn't as strong because sample sizes are smaller and double-blind trials aren't viable. > what little research has been done comes from the politicized and not-at-all-rigorous "social sciences" whose reliability is questionable at best If the research is that unreliable, a well-funded, properly motivated organization like the Heritage Foundation should be able to identify methodological weaknesses or other flaws in the literature, instead of sponsoring unscientific drivel from people with PhDs in fields like "political philosophy." > There won't be an evidence-based scientific consensus (as opposed to an artificial consensus enforced by excluding anyone who disagrees with the party line) about transgenderism any time soon. Can you cite up-to-date, peer-reviewed scientific research that disputes the existence of gender dysphoria or the effectiveness of hormone therapy in treating it? Or even a single researcher with relevant scientific expertise who disputes those points? If not, I'd ask how else you could reasonably define an "evidence-based scientific consensus about transgenderism." Keep in mind that scientific consensus isn't necessarily uncontroversial among laypeople - see, e.g., global warming [4] and the theory of evolution [5]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_dysphoria#Diagnosis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_dysphoria#Diagnosis [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21937168 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21937168 [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23574768 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23574768 [3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24344788 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24344788 [4] https://news.gallup.com/poll/248027/americans-concerned-ever-global-warming.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/248027/americans-concerned-ever... [5] https://news.gallup.com/poll/210956/belief-creationist-view-humans-new-low.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/210956/belief-creationist-view-...
- pdonis 8y agoBut unless you know exactly which viewpoints are or are not valid and do or don't deserve attention, your belief has no practical value. And if you actually do think you know that on a subject as difficult as ethics, I would strongly advise you to re-examine your belief.
- mike00632 8y agoI'm gay and I know for a fact that gay people aren't inherently unfit to be parents, which is a view held strongly by the Heritage Foundation and they have falsified studies to try and support their opinion. Ethics isn't something that nobody can pin down or say anything definitive about. I and most of the good-natured people at Google know that the Heritage Foundation's views are not valid. They're deceptive and only serve to promote ignorance and hatred.
- naasking 8y ago> I'm gay and I know for a fact that gay people aren't inherently unfit to be parents I agree, but suppose for the sake of argument that having gay parents caused some developmental or social difficulties that didn't happen with heterosexual parents. That's not inconceivable is it? But if researchers were all operating in a pro-gay echo chamber, they would almost certainly never discover this, at least not for quite some time. You might even need people who actively fight against gay rights to find some nook, some crack in existing research to force the research to be more thorough and robust. And that would be valuable to you as a gay parent, would it not? So even if you detest such researchers, and they detest you as a gay person, isn't their contribution in the overall scientific process still pretty valuable to you?
- mike00632 8y ago>...suppose for the sake of argument... No, I'm not going to assume your bigoted viewpoint. It absolutely is inconceivable to me. The only way you could think this view has merit is through an extreme lack of empathy and a lot of ignorance. >...pro-gay echo chamber... Considering gay people to by like other people is not being "pro-gay." It's just being a decent human being. >...existing research... Keep in mind that we are talking about the falsification of research to malign gay people and take away their kids or prevent them from having kids. This isn't about science but about what types of views and actions Google finds acceptable and valuable on a team.
- roenxi 8y agoThere are subtleties here. I don't know how intentional it was, but naasking didn't say that the viewpoints were equally valid. What was said was "people whose opinions are diametrically opposed". An ethics board isn't a technical committee working to patch AI when they become unethical. They are a mechanism to flag ethical concerns _before_ there is concrete evidence of a problem. That means they will have to function more like a debating panel for management and interested observers than a technocratic mechanism. 1) A part of what is being done when discussing ethics is modeling what the arguments are to deal with bad positions. That is much easier to do if someone on the panel takes up a bad position. Watching a bad argument get dismantled is more useful then hearing 3 respectable people agree on an obvious point. 2) Even if an idea is wrong, being radically different is often enough to trigger some exploration of very different perspectives on a problem, some of which will be valid. People aren't usually wrong because they are wrong about everything they've ever thought or done ever. People are usually wrong because they've got a few key parts of a larger picture wrong, but many other details are still correct. 3) There is always a risk that, no matter how obvious the situation is, a group has been contaminated by groupthink. As I like to say, intelligence is no defense against groupthink; it just means that the individuals involved are better at rationalising it.
- naasking 8y agoExactly. Moreover, we could never be sufficiently confident in an argument of a position until it's been thoroughly excoriated by people who vehemently disagree with each step or even the basic premises. That's how you get watertight proofs, and that's what we would need for AI ethics.
- Aunche 8y agoEven if Kay Cole James is egregiously wrong about trans-people, that doesn't mean she's incapable of participating in a conversation about AI ethics. She clearly has is intelligent enough to be in the position she is today.
- vore 8y agoShould she be in a position where her opposition to trans people can possibly have a direct effect on the lives of trans people? If one side of the argument is "trans rights matter" and the other is "trans people are just men cosplaying as women", then morally you can only choose the "trans rights matter" side. Any political concerns take a backseat to the direct wellbeing of trans people.
- AllegedAlec 8y ago> then morally you can only choose the "trans rights matter" side I don't think that word means what you think it means. If you think that it's acceptable to twist the words of someone you disagree with to say that, you have no basis on which to make moral judgements.
- tomp 8y agoIsn't that a false dichotomy? I don't see a reason why people who "cosplay superman" or someone/something else would necessarily have to be denied any rights whatsoever...
- naasking 8y ago> If one side of the argument is "trans rights matter" and the other is "trans people are just men cosplaying as women", then morally you can only choose the "trans rights matter" side. I don't think anyone reasonable thinks that trans rights don't matter, they just disagree on what counts as a fundamental right. The N word is and should be taboo because it dehumanizes black people; it's literally calling them subhuman and not deserving equal consideration as a fellow human being. But as an example, this is not the case for misgendering. Misgendering a trans person isn't calling them subhuman or not deserving of equal human rights. Nearly everyone believes men and women should have equal rights, so misgendering is simply denying that a person has a right to classify themselves as a different sex than their "biological sex" [1]. I think there can be a legitimate debate on the ethical status of misgendering, but no such debate can happen given the mountains of vitriol thrown from all sides. [1] assuming you subscribe to a binary model of sex, but this too would be part of the debate
- ALittleLight 8y agoWhy should we grant your view on this matter equal attention?
- sgt101 8y agoDid I miss the racist homophobes on the BBC recently? Or the Islamic radicals? Or the anti vaxxers? I know that one climate change denier appeared, but didn't they hold an enquiry and apologise? What are you talking about?
- Iv 8y agoYou can find valid but opposite viewpoints. Especially in ethics. But reading the article, the problem was not opposing viewpoints, but conflicts of interests. Something you don't want to have in an ethics committee.
- navigatesol 8y ago>I strongly believe that that is not true. All when and good when it's "our" opinion that's considered valid, and "theirs" isn't.