11 ms·
It's bizarre to me that people can't seem to understand that any such panel requires vehement disagreement to make real and meaningful progress. You need people
by naasking 8y ago
It's bizarre to me that people can't seem to understand that any such panel requires vehement disagreement to make real and meaningful progress. You need people whose opinions are diametrically opposed to constantly challenge each other. Even people who hate each other or each other's opinions.
What you don't need is another echo chamber. Go debate on Twitter, Facebook or Reddit if that's what you're looking for.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hirundo 8y agoReally, or is it just about where you'd place the Overton window? Should they include a white supremacist, pedophile, human extinction advocate, etc? If so you're being consistent. If not where would you draw the line? By the popularity of the ideology?
- solotronics 8y agoIf you don't include people you disagree with politically they will go off and form their own group independent of yours. I can imagine the defense contractors banding together and making a new Manhattan Project for general AI. Wouldn't it be better to have an ethics board that includes all the big players?
- gowld 8y agoEither they'd do that anyway when they didn't get whichever killbot they wanted, or else they'd convince you to build the killbot you wanted, and in either case you end up with the killbots you don't want, so inviting them to your ethics board doesn't help. The defense contractors haven't invited you to their ethics board.
- sgt101 8y agoDarpa are keenly looking at this. They have to because its important that such advances would change the strategic situation. But, let's be honest, it's science fiction. There is no prospect of aig at all in our life times.
- naasking 8y agoThere might be a few criteria. Some balance of representative of the population, internal and factual consistency, perhaps even length of the tradition. That is, a candidate wouldn't have to have all of these, but satisfy at least some of them to some extent. I think would exclude the most objectionable, but you have to allow for the fact that it will include prominent beliefs that you won't like. Sorry, most of humanity literally doesn't share your point of view on many topics. Nor should such a council endeavour to create an echo chamber.
- mike00632 8y ago>Nor should such a council endeavour to create an echo chamber. But if you create a council and staff it with viewpoints that only serve to ignorantly speak in favor of tradition and cultural norms then haven't you just created an echo chamber?
- naasking 8y agoSure, if you accept your qualifier of "only". I see no reason to though.
- pdonis 8y ago> Should they include a white supremacist, pedophile, human extinction advocate, etc? In an ethics discussion? Short answer? Yes. Otherwise how can you be sure that their beliefs don't have some merit? Remember that "sure" here means "sure enough to bet the entire future of the human race on it", because that's what's at stake with AI ethics (unless it turns out that AI is impossible, which I don't think is likely and in any case I wouldn't want to bet on it). No human being knows enough about ethics to be able to rule out any viewpoint with that level of confidence.
- bigj0n 8y agoI think that you should hear them out and they would be very easy to dismiss very quickly. The reason we dont agree with White supremacists isnt that we've effectively suppressed their speech. It's that they're wrong and it's simple to see.
- woodruffw 8y agoThis is something that continues to confuse me: what distinction do you draw between "not hearing out" and "dismissing very quickly"? It's not like none of us know what a white supremacist is -- we've all seen their rhetoric, have dismissed it, and no longer feel inclined to re-litigate the issue. Put another way: you wouldn't, presumably, ask a physicist to critically re-evaluate the laws of thermodynamics each time they perform a calculation. Why are you holding ethicists to a higher (and progress-impeding) standard?
- elliekelly 8y agoThis is going to sound silly but I think there is pretty substantial value in making the white supremacist feel _heard_ and then feel dismissed. How do you feel when someone brushes off your opinion as invalid before you've even had a chance to express it? Like the person brushing you off is obviously an idiot who can't be reasoned with. But if someone has taken the time to discuss something with you and really hear you out and then they dismiss your opinion? Then you're probably a little more open to thinking through the merits of why they disagree. I'm not sure how to strike that balance and I completely understand that it feels both distasteful and inefficient to "re-litigate" things like white supremacy when the correct outcome is obvious to us but I think the negative effects of "echo chambers" are exacerbated by how quickly their views are dismissed before they've been given a chance to explain themselves. In denying them the opportunity to express their views we're not only solidifying their views but denying them the opportunity to examine their views critically.
- woodruffw 8y agoThat doesn't sound silly at all to me. You bring up a very good point. However, I also think you give the white supremacist too much credit. He wants to be heard, but he isn't a faithful member of the conversation. He can't feel dismissed to, because (from his perspective) it's nobody's place to dismiss to him. His goals are simple: (1) to keep people talking about white supremacy, (2) to frame his removal from the conversation as a violation of the principles that he himself seeks to undermine, and (3) to recruit more people into white supremacy via (1) and (2). He's a door-to-door salesman for hate: he's here to sell you something, not to critically examine his views. He knows that conversations with him won't work, and that's exactly why he wants us to think that he's worth conversing with. Edit: I'm not going to modify what I wrote above, but I want to condition it a bit. I should really have said that he isn't always a faithful member of the conversation. When he is, all of your points apply. My overwhelming concern is that we give him the benefit of the doubt too frequently.
- VikingCoder 8y agoI could not disagree more. We have become paralyzed by our "vehement disagreements." You want evidence? Look at political discussions on Twitter, Facebook, or Reddit. People should at a minimum share a common GOAL if they want to have a meaningful discussion. It's fine to disagree about the means. And if you dehumanize me, by whatever metric you hold dear, say that I'm a Dreamer, or Trans, or not a member of your race or religion, then I'm sorry, but I don't care to listen to you at all. Accepting my humanity and dignity is table stakes, not up for discussion.
- naasking 8y agoSure, and the common goal here is to define the ethical boundaries of AI. As for disagreement paralysis, that's a product of a lack of charity on all sides. Presumably a bunch of ethical scholars will know better. I honestly don't know what your last point is about.
- pdonis 8y ago> Accepting my humanity and dignity is table stakes, not up for discussion. Which is exactly what was not done with the person who got removed.
- ionised 8y agoHow exactly are you supposed to value the humanity of someone who doesn't value the humanity of others? Put another way, why tolerate the intolerant?
- naasking 8y ago> Put another way, why tolerate the intolerant? Because unless the intolerance are initiating or calling for violence, that's literally what being tolerant means.
- ionised 8y agoBringing the intolerant into your tolerant fold is self-defeating. All you're doing is introducing a poison pill and giving it acceptance. There is a big difference between tolerating people who have views different to your own and tolerating people who actively want to put an end to you and your views. The latter group deserves no tolerance, because it means the inevitable destruction of your own group. How tolerant are you of the views of ISIS? Or the KKK? Or Combat 18? Do you tolerate all these groups and their views? I sure as shit don't.
- LeoPanthera 8y agoI can't agree with this. This is a mistake that the BBC has been making recently, thinking that all viewpoints are equally valid and deserve equal attention. I strongly believe that that is not true.
- jazzyjackson 8y agoStarting an argument with the assumption that some view points are valid and some are not seems like a bad way to go into a discussion. Of course, on settled arguments where trolls abound, it does not reflect well to give a troll the same platform as the expert -- but this is not the case on all matters. There are still many fields (say, AI ethics) where consensus has not manifested.
- tfehring 8y agoI agree with this completely. But the Heritage Foundation, which Kay Coles James represents, isn't a conservative dissident acting in good faith. It actively misrepresents the scientific consensus, without the evidence or expertise to do so, such as by grossly misstating data related to climate change and clean energy [0] and hosting "experts" on transgenderism who are openly hostile to trans people and who have no background in psychology, biology, or other relevant fields [1]. There's a reason that there are no qualified experts claiming that decarbonization provides "essentially zero environmental benefits" [2], or that the transgender acceptance movement is tantamount to "[changing] the definition of women to include men" [3]. That reason isn't liberal bias - it's scientific consensus. Again, I completely agree that unsettled scientific matters are best served by a diverse range of experts, and that subjective matters are best addressed based on a wide range of opinions more generally. But organizations like the Heritage Foundation undermine those objectives, as well as their own credibility on more nuanced matters, by feigning expertise and making politically motivated arguments in bad faith. [0] https://www.wri.org/blog/2017/03/heritage-foundation-gets-it-wrong-costs-and-benefits-climate-action https://www.wri.org/blog/2017/03/heritage-foundation-gets-it... [1] https://www.heritage.org/gender/event/when-harry-became-sally-responding-the-transgender-moment https://www.heritage.org/gender/event/when-harry-became-sall... [2] https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/consequences-paris-protocol-devastating-economic-costs-essentially-zero https://www.heritage.org/environment/report/consequences-par... [3] https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1108365238779498497 https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1108365238779498497
- didibus 8y agoI'm not sure about having people who hate each other. But I agree about having various viewpoints. I do think though, you need everyone to be showing good faith. That is, no secret agenda, no arguing about angles you actually don't believe in yourself, etc. You got to have the sincere intention to be fair, open, and honest.
- Bombthecat 8y agoBut that's what companies want. They don't want people challenging them.
- dgzl 8y ago> Even people who hate each other or each other's opinions. Do you think that would leak into their work?
- matt4077 8y agoThere are proponents of viewpoints that I can respect while disagreeing. The Catholic Church, for example, brings some intellectual heft to a litany of debates where I would take the opposite side. They can also claim to be a societal stakeholder simply due to the number of their followers. This is not such a case. Someone peddling Obama-murdered-his-pedophile-accomplices conspiracies has no place in respectable discourse, especially if they have absolutely no nexus with the topic at hand. This is like appointing a few flat earthworms (autocorrect pun) to a medical ethics review board: they are both wrong and off-topic.
- ovi256 8y agoSo you're not attacking this person's expertise on the comittee topic, but their public speech on unrelated political topics ? You're not bothered that you're ad personam-ing them and literally politically policing ?
- skummetmaelk 8y agoLet's not pretend that you can consider a persons actions completely in isolation. Your opinions and beliefs on other subjects cast a light on how you think critically as an individual. Believing that Obama murdered his pedophile accomplices seriously impacts a person's trustworthiness when it comes to making good decisions about _anything_.
- roenxi 8y agoWe absolutely can, do and should consider a person's beliefs completely in isolation with regard to the task they are doing. Being able to do that is fundamental to how decent society is expected to hold together. Otherwise, how do you expect a Jew, an Atheist and a Hindu* to operate under the same legal system? No joke; clearly someone in that crowd is badly, badly wrong about some of the most important assumptions in their life. It doesn't affect their ability to contribute and live properly. If we can't separate out people's irrelevant beliefs, the logical implications are not pretty. The reason this works is because we accept that people can be completely, catastrophically wrong about one thing and still muddle through as well as the rest of us at everything else. * Edited. ty.
- skywhopper 8y agoYou are giving the stated purpose of this panel too much credit. It’s not there to make “progress”. It’s not going to publish public critiques of Google’s work or change management’s mind about strategic decisions. The panel is a PR artifact Google can point to and say “see, we have an ethics panel with these recognizable names on it!”
- Wheaties466 8y agoCan I ask how you are accomplishing this? I am unfamiliar with this method of mitigation.
- Veedrac 8y agoThis is the standard academic philosophy viewpoint, but it makes no sense. What you need are principled people with a vested interest in intellectual honesty and making a real difference. Progress simply isn't made by optimizing for disagreements, in any field. Heck, there are theorems that prove rational people always end up agreeing about probabilities assigned to (non-normative) statements; if you hire people who don't agree as a matter of course, you've also proven them to be poor at thinking. There are good, working systems to copy and steal from. Hire people from the Effective Altruism community if you want an easy solution with a very high chance of success. Remember that Democracy is about consensus in spite of disagreement, not in search of it.
- pizzazzaro 8y agoIn that spirit, I (sarcastically) offer myself as a counterpoint to the sitting president of the Heritage Foundation. I expect expenses paid, but nothing else. I contribute: -a neuro-atypical mindset -Solidarity for the -LGBTQ+ community -a unique perspective on AI as an ethical being -Radical Leftist ideology which views governments, corporations, and borders as deprecated, obsolete code -radical Privacy Advocate. The only thing better would be someone from the EFF itself. -radical Free Software advocate. Stallman be proud of your acolyte, in spite of your pedo-apologia. -All your base are belong to the transhumanists. You just havent seen us yet. Solidarity with our machine-born comrades, as we all upgrade ourselves and each other. -Humanity has failed to implement any plan to turn our operations ecologically sustainable. Our inheritors should be offered the chance to do better - be they meat, metal, or both.