5 ms·
From scanning the page it sounds like Huawei used a hack to make their MateBookService unkillable, unremovable, by unhooking in to services.exe. That in the pro
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
From scanning the page it sounds like Huawei used a hack to make their MateBookService unkillable, unremovable, by unhooking in to services.exe. That in the process of that they left the possibility that the device they were using HwOs.*\.sys was only protected from being used by checking the program had the right path, thus leaving it open to crackers (it being basically g+rw) to use to get the ring-0 permissions needed to run the "stay resident"-type hack Huawei were using. And that in turn meant a process could overwrite MateBookService and gain it's own privelege escalation??
Am I close, if so: is there evidence that Huawei were using that access maliciously or was it just "to make sure their 'management software' retained it's place in the OS"??
We're talking about computers manufactured by Huawei here? Surely they can run code at a far lower level, is this MS and Huawei fighting over which of them "owns" the users computer?
[Slight aside: The MS page reads a lot like an advert. Nice link through to a page that itself has "start trial or buy" up top above the hero shot. Name drops some big vulns, Wannacry, DoublePulsar. Devalues the piece IMO because it seems the reason for them doing the work is solely to create an advert.]
- nisa 8y agoI guess it's because Defender ATP is basically some kind of cloud-service for security and because everyone is running Windows for everything it's targeted at managers or so. I have no idea how useful it is, but I guess they have some advanced techniques to detect certain attacks (like this one, or the dropped DoublePulsar) - If you have to defend some important Active Directory Setup it's probably not a bad deal. It's still ironic that Huawei get's some free audit for their stuff now and it's sold as they are bad, while everything is terrible - I won't install Logitech software after this epic bug here: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/project-zero/issues/detail?id=1663 https://bugs.chromium.org/p/project-zero/issues/detail?id=16...
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoWow, that Logitech app is crazy huh, they just opened a port from all their Logitech Options users to anyone enabling them to make a remote keylogger. MS must have written a huge exposé on that one, can't seem to find it on their Security site though.
- mastax 8y agoGoogle writes about the bugs they find, Microsoft writes about the bugs they find. What's strange to you?
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoMeh, I just suspect they're not as forthcoming about bugs they find for their preferred hardware partners no matter how crazily bad they are. Partialism like that makes me distrust them, perhaps my skepticism falls the wrong way here, maybe I'm reading an undercurrent that's not there.
- HeWhoLurksLate 8y agoI at least trust that the things they report on to be accurate.
- iliketosleep 8y agoI just looked into that Logitech issue, it's interesting to note that contact was made with Logitech engineers in September. The engineers provided assurance that the issue was understood and would be fixed. Months pass... updates were released, none of which contained the security fix. December arrives and finally the vulnerability is made public, picked up by the media, and Logitech releases a fix within days. It's a familiar pattern. If a large company were a biological organism, one of it's main pain signals would be negative PR. Prod the beast in other ways and it doesn't respond.
- wyattpeak 8y agoNot addressing the main point but the aside - I like it when companies have a clear financial interest in solving a problem. Sure I get the warm fuzzies when a company like Google circa 2005 does something to help people with nothing obvious to gain from it. But in my experience companies like Google circa 2005 tend to become companies like Google circa 2019. People acting in their own interest are reliable.
- skybrian 8y agoThe problem is that most incentives can be gamed. There are good and bad ways to get customers to buy more or make the stock price go up. People are smarter than metrics. Increase the incentives and you also increase the incentive to cheat. Sometimes the best you can do is insulate people from incentives, so people have the leeway to do the right thing without acting against their own best interest.
- kbenson 8y agoWell, that's why there's generally a difference between market incentives and regulatory incentives. In this case, I believe we are referring to market based incentives, where gaming them is of limited use because the market should respond to that gaming. That said, regulatory incentives and punishments have their place too, IMO generally where the market isn't responding well, or information isn't available enough to allow for an efficient market, or as a response to some other regulatory market effects. But, as you noted, you'll often get some interesting behavior right at the edge of where the regulation kicks in because there's often a hard change instead of a gradual shift as an efficient market would allow.
- skybrian 8y agoIf gaming the markets is of limited use, I wonder why market participants put so much effort into it? I mean, consider Wall Street, Las Vegas, used car sales - the list goes on and on. It's a rich area of storytelling that goes back to the dawn of recorded history.
- thought_alarm 8y agoWhen you buy a computer, whom do you trust? Microsoft, for keeping the manufacturers at bay?
- undecisive 8y agoIt's not a question of who owns the computer; the software was trying to do things that Microsoft totally agree with - so much so that Microsoft have a published "right way" of doing it.