3 ms·
> Why do we have to have nuclear? It's a good question. Really. The reason why is that current renewable tech cannot handle our energy needs. Technology for a
by godelski 8y ago
> Why do we have to have nuclear?
It's a good question. Really.
The reason why is that current renewable tech cannot handle our energy needs. Technology for a "well connected `super grid'" just doesn't exist either. The battery tech isn't there.
But don't just believe me. Look at Germany[0]. Many point to it as the leading example of adapting renewable technology. They have some huge advantages places like the US, India, and China don't have: being small and more dense. This means you can have less power loss in transit (theoretically). But you have to ask yourself, why is Germany's use of renewables skyrocketing but their carbon footprint is relatively stationary? Hint: What are they replacing their nuclear with? It isn't just renewables, and there's a reason why.
Remember, no pro nuclear person is anti renewable. We just believe we need to act NOW and not when renewables become advanced enough. Personally I just don't think we have the time.
Edit: Wanted to share a link I was sharing in another thread. France, which has about 75% of its energy produced from nuclear also has one of the cheapest electricity costs in Europe. [1]
[0] https://www.worlddata.info/europe/germany/energy-consumption.php https://www.worlddata.info/europe/germany/energy-consumption...
[1] https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profiles/countries-a-f/france.aspx https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-pr...
- petre 8y ago> What are they replacing their nuclear with? Russian gas. That's why they're building a new pipeline in the Baltic.
- Faark 8y agoOf cause the carbon footprint is stationary, since both nuclear and renewable are good on that front. Replacing nuclear with coal wouldn't be stationary and graphs [0] look like renewable has decently taken over former nuclear. I don't understand where you see something not working. I do understand nuclear advocates arguing the carbon footprint could be even better. Also keep in mind some rural areas fighting tooth and nails to keep brown coal use/mining running, since these areas don't have much other economic prospects. [0] https://energy-charts.de/energy.htm?source=all-sources&period=annual&year=all https://energy-charts.de/energy.htm?source=all-sources&perio...
- godelski 8y agoMy issue is that the reason to switch to renewables is to reduce your carbon footprint. If you aren't reducing your footprint, why are you investing that money? I should rephrase my statement. They are replacing nuclear with coal AND renewables. But to me the better strategy is to replace coal with renewables first. Then you can reduce your nuclear production. Get to the problem. The priority should be to reduce the carbon footprint.
- jabl 8y ago> The priority should be to reduce the carbon footprint. This. After you reach carbon neutrality (or realistically, we're gonna need negative emissions), fine, go ahead and replace those pesky nuclear plants with hamster wheel power, for all I care.
- Faark 8y agoNo, reducing carbon footprint is not the only priority. It is an important one, but doesn't top everything else. I don't want emergency responders driving slowly just because its for the environment. Nuclear, especially the waste management, was an another priority here in Germany. Apparently a priority our politicians (and industry) were unable to solve satisfyingly in another way. So they took the opportunity and boldly went against nuclear, even if overall results won't perfect immediately. Just like they decided to do that plan pushing renewable energy regardless of how imperfect (how crazy is doing solar that far up north?!) and eventually helped jump-start the solar and wind industry for everyone else to benefit from. But i do understand nuclear enthusiasts having different views/priorities, so we'll probably never agree.
- godelski 8y ago> Nuclear, especially the waste management I think there's a big misunderstanding of waste that the public has. Even though it is toxic and radioactive the amount of waste matters. For example, if I throw out a coke can of the most toxic stuff on the planet yearly or throw out train loads of waste daily. That's really the comparison we're making with nuclear waste and coal waste. I always get a little ticked off when people ask "what do you do with the waste" because the answer is the same with what you do with coal waste. You bury it. But in this case we have to bury a lot less material (and remember, coal waste is also radioactive and toxic). Even though there is a danger issue difference, let's call it two orders of magnitude, there's a huge difference in scale (>>2 orders of magnitude). Frankly, that matters. Some side notes: In France ~15% of their total power comes just from recycled nuclear waste (remember, their entire grid is ~75% nuclear and they have one of the lowest carbon footprints). Not all nuclear "waste" is waste. A lot gets used in things like medicine and a bunch of sciences.
- imtringued 8y agoThe fundamental problem is that the carbon impact of electricity just doesn't matter that much. It's only something like 24% of the total energy used in Germany. If the renewable electricity share is 50% then that means total renewable energy share is only 12%. Transportation and heavy industry still depend on fossil fuels. Innovation in these sectors is far more important now than more investments into renewable electricity (which is still welcome of course).
- godelski 8y ago> Innovation in these sectors is far more important now than more investments into renewable electricity (which is still welcome of course). Like the innovation of electric cars? Or are you saying we should ditch electric cars and focus on hydrogen fuel cells? If these innovations follow the common trend, they will convert from combustion engines to electric engines. Bearing with me, this means that the more things switch to electric means that the carbon impact of the grid becomes more important. Yeah, some things can't become electrified. You can't make an electric cow. But lab grown meat has much higher electric costs than grass fed cows.