3 ms·
>The non-profit aspect won't help them in the least. // AIUI one of the tests for Fair Use [in USA] looks at whether use is non-commercial (not the same as non
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
>The non-profit aspect won't help them in the least. //
AIUI one of the tests for Fair Use [in USA] looks at whether use is non-commercial (not the same as non-profit; commercial use can be free-gratis, for example; nor is it a sufficient condition in itself), so it could be a key element in a court decision I feel; what's more important perhaps is that people are less inclined to sue non-profits because of the potential harm to their own public image.
Google are pretty canny, I'd expect them to let IA lead - eg assumed consent with old books - in order to set a non-binding precedent so that they can go to the press should they be challenged and say "well we just followed what the noble souls of IA are doing, and this court decision will harm the IA".
Last I looked, IIRC, Papua New Guinea wasn't signatory to copyright treaties, but I think they were planning on signing. There's probably a country in a similar circumstances that would be a reasonable place for holding a backup archive that includes the stuff less liberal regimes want you to ditch.