4 ms·
> the fundamental job of almost every market participant Not true. You might make an argument that this is the effect of having them together in a market, but
by lordnacho 8y ago
> the fundamental job of almost every market participant
Not true. You might make an argument that this is the effect of having them together in a market, but that's not their job:
- Market maker: hang around the market offering to trade with anyone (pref retail) at a spread. Doesn't care whether TSLA is gonna be able to make all those Model 3s.
- Pension fund: make sure they can pay the liabilities that are coming due. If that can be locked in, happy to pay a bit more than fair value to do so.
- Hedge fund: make absolute returns. Buy before it goes up, sell before it goes down. Whatever form of voodoo (or skill) fulfills this is fine. This doesn't have to mean finding the right price (could just mean you guess which way it's going), though of course often it is part of the objective.
- Broker: finds people on both sides of a trade. Doesn't care terribly much except to create excitement.
- Banks: lend money/securities and offer services to all of the above. Create research to make people trade. Securitise stuff so people can trade it. Often do a bit of everything.
Source: used to run hedge funds.
- scarletham 8y agoI think you're missing the gist of his statement and also overlooking the word "almost"? That being said, most of your definitions are still dependent on competitively pricing securities. A market maker who can't calculate reasonable theos won't be a market maker for long.
- lordnacho 8y ago> most of your definitions are still dependent on competitively pricing securities No, the MM doesn't care if TSLA is overpriced. He just sees where everyone is and makes a market roughly there. > You can't provide quotes if you don't have something to quote around. But you don't have to quote around the actual value of the item. That's the point.
- scarletham 8y agoI work in a MM group so take this as you will, but the days of profitably making markets by just fitting everything to the screens are long gone.
- lordnacho 8y agoI think it depends a whole lot on what exactly you are market making and how you're trying to profit. Of course many desks take views as well, but mixing in prop positions doesn't change the essence of it: the MM is trying to make money off being available for other participants. You can of course also learn some things about where to market is going in the course of this business, and many desks are able to piggy back on some flow information for their advantage.
- ctlby 8y agoThe only real practitioner in this thread has one of the only downvoted comments. Incredible.
- wmxxpdx 8y agoThanks for being so concise. Getting license to sell estates (life insurance), hope to make $$$, worm my way into FINRA to take series 7, then try operate under reg crowdfunding to raise $1 million capital for new biz. What you do now?
- ionwake 8y agoHope you dont mind me asking a slightly unrelated and possibly dumb question. Im a programmer, but on the side have made on average 150% profit in share dealing over the passed 5 years, but more importantly, a much higher return in other assets to 2 orders of magnitude higher. My question is - would experience / gains like this - if i had proof etc - get me an interview in a fund as some type of well paid (6 figure atleast) analyst?
- gringoDan 8y agoIf [0] those returns are accurate, can be proven, and your strategy can be scaled up to multi-million dollar positions, you should take it to a hedge fund/prop shop/etc. and be able to make 7 or 8 figures. Your bonus should be dependent on performance; you may be able to negotiate a % of the profit. Those companies don't care about your background if at the end of the day you make them money. [0] Granted, that's a huge "if".
- gcb0 8y agoand how do you prove some method scale up without either already being on the million dollar scale or disclosing your secret sauce?
- bduerst 8y agoShort of spending a million dollars right then and there, you can use historical market data. Or datasets provided by the person you're trying to prove it to. Keep in mind that after a certain volume, your model would start influencing the market itself.
- ohaideredevs 8y agoThe reason financial transactions don't scale is volume - your $100 trade can move a penny stock to $.02 from $.0002 a share if there is no volume. Some markets can absorb an enormous amount of volume, such as the FOREX market. Now, when you start making good trades in a "big" market, intelligent players can mimic / play off of them, so it is hard to prove in that regard. At a minimum though, you could prove that it works on assets that are not volume-dependent.
- user5994461 8y agoOne little correction. Hedge Fund: Convince customers to invest their money in the fund. Extract as much of it as possible through fees. Doesn't care much where the market goes, charge a fee either way, a bit more if it goes up.