8 ms·
It's a strange age to be living in. On the same day I've visited people in a WeWork, been driven around in an Uber, and had food delivered by Deliveroo. All of
by lordnacho 8y ago
It's a strange age to be living in. On the same day I've visited people in a WeWork, been driven around in an Uber, and had food delivered by Deliveroo.
All of them blowing a huge load of money for the privilege.
If they don't make back this money, it will represent a huge waste of resources.
It's private money behind, but I still wonder whether this a reasonable way for the economy to run.
For one, it means the little guy can't compete. Only people with deep pockets. And they might not be the most competent.
For the investors it means selling a dream of profits, but not profitable businesses. You make more out of convincing someone your OD empire will succeed than making it do so.
I wonder what would happen if there was a rule that you could only resell equity in a business whose financials had improved recently.
- skybrian 8y agoIf the "waste" is subsidizing services you actually want, is it really waste? It's more of a transfer from investors to landlords and drivers, who certainly wouldn't be as happy with less money.
- est31 8y agoAnd some of the investors are landlords, so part of the transfer goes from landlord-investor to landlord-investor. Your landlord doesn't even have to directly be an investor at the precise company you are working at, already the silent agreement of all landlord-investors to use SV is enough.
- xsmasher 8y agoAre the drivers getting paid more than they are worth, or are you getting a service for less than it should cost? Either is possible; or other options - like Uber is making money per ride in some regions and losing in others.
- AlexandrB 8y agoI think it's more interesting to look at it as a corruption of traditional supply/demand signalling in a market economy. By heavily subsidizing a service, investors are able to put their finger on the scale and choose winners despite what consumers would actually choose if competition was more fair. Previously, this kind of behaviour was considered "dumping" and anti-competitive. Yet, currently it's considered OK because startups (read VCs) are doing it instead of large monopolies. It's interesting to see how this might relate to wealth inequality as well. If investors had less money and consumers had more, would they choose a less-subsidized Uber over traditional cab services as readily?
- rchaud 8y agoI think the "waste" aspect of it comes from the crowding-out effect of capital allocation. Large sums going into the on-demand economy businesses means that there's far less available to invest in other types of business models. That in turn may incentivize some businesses to "pivot" to an on-demand model purely to get their foot in the door with some investors, regardless of whether it makes business sense. Remember Kodak's stock skyrocketing in 2017 when they released KodakCoin? [1]. My opinion is that it is worrying that the line of thinking is that "the profits will come once they're a monopoly". The actions you take to be profitable are different from the ones you take to be a monopoly. Uber and Airbnb have used their millions to circumvent local laws and lobby for their interests. Microsoft in the 90s used their OS monopoly to prevent OEMs from bundling rival's software on their machines. Monopolies might be great for shareholders but they're not good for consumers and they don't incentivize innovation. And here, I'm not talking about "natural monopolies" like utility companies and telecom network infrastructure. [1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/30/technology/kodak-blockchain-bitcoin.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/30/technology/kodak-blockcha...
- skybrian 8y agoI'm not sure the crowding-out effect is real? It seems hard to argue that this is a bad time for startups to raise money. Compare with a boom-bust cyclical model where boom times make raising money easier for everyone. Under this model, overly enthusiastic investors eventually get discouraged after losing a lot of money, so the amount of investment money available changes a lot and thinking of it as zero-sum doesn't really work.
- pitaj 8y agoIt's called malinvestment, and it's tied to monetary policy. When the central bank churns out money, the lower interest rates discourage banks from lending, making it harder for small businesses to collect capital that way. The lower interest rates simultaneously drive investment from bonds into the stock market and real estate. Look up Business Cycle Theory
- solotronics 8y agoIs it bad though? I would think new innovative services would be a better place for money to go compared to sticking into some long term bond. At least this way a bunch of people get jobs and servers/compute/CPU/whatever get bought. For every Uber there are dozens if not hundreds of Slack/Splunk/Softlayer type companies that end up with some of that money and employ people. This is somewhat related to how I perceive the economy of China working. Whenever I visit there I marvel at all the infrastructure projects and you realize it doesn't need to "make money" over there. The government just decides what to build and loans itself money to get it done.
- ABCLAW 8y ago>Is it bad though? Yes. Hence the 'mal' part. Investment should be going towards enterprises which produce actual value. If the only way you can produce value is by throwing away money through predatory pricing, then you aren't creating value. And so without any value to create, eventually you blow up and lose a bunch of people their money. When enough people lose enough money, people stop lending their money so freely and the business cycle starts the contraction phase. Now good enterprises have trouble getting capital, so they delay purchasing all of those cool servers/computers/whatevers. Since the companies selling those things now receive less orders, they order less from their suppliers, etc. Suppliers go under. People lose their jobs. People without jobs spend less, which kills demand further. Fuck. etc. If it helps to have a misleadingly simplified 1 phrase summary: you can think of malinvestment as taking money from workable enterprises in the future and funnelling it into shitty enterprises now.
- afarah 8y ago
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y ago> I wonder what would happen if there was a rule that you could only resell equity in a business whose financials had improved recently. How does that work with failing businesses? If a business turns into a shit-show, everyone on board is forced to ride the ship down to the seafloor?
- lordnacho 8y agoYeah hmm I hadn't considered the other side. What if the business had to have had a good year at some point?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- orasis 8y agoIf they fail there will still have been a massive amount of learning, so it won’t be a waste.
- raz32dust 8y agoWell investment is always a risk right? The investors aren't being fooled, they know what they're getting into but still believe in the business model. I agree with the little guy can't compete problem though. But that has been around forever. E.g Amazon has driven many smaller companies out of business by just being able to sustain massive losses for prolonged periods.
- narag 8y agoIt's private money behind, but I still wonder whether this a reasonable way for the economy to run. I'd say it is. On the one hand, it's good for you that receive a cheap service at the expense of VCs. On the other hand, the economy is far far better exploring multiple solutions, some of which will stick, than entering the dead way of what an experts comite consider sensible. Once the capital is burnt, the survivors will be healthy businesses. As for the little guy can't compete (is that really always true?) I'd say it's the value for society that matters eventually.
- darawk 8y agoThis is how the economy is supposed to work. The people pouring billions into these companies are taking a calculated risk. It might work, it might not. If it does, we'll all get a bunch of cool new services. If it doesn't, those people will be out billions of dollars and we'll have gotten some cheap services for a while on their dime. They're taking a risk to create something new, and if it works, they'll be handsomely rewarded. If it doesn't, they'll lose all their money. That's ok, that's the system working.
- quadrangle 8y agoAs others emphasized, it's totally possible for investors to get some exit before a bust, hoisting off the risk onto more naive later investors. In short: create the appearance of a successful business, convince others (suckers) that it's a great investment, profit from selling your shares.
- darawk 8y ago> As others emphasized, it's totally possible for investors to get some exit before a bust, hoisting off the risk onto more naive later investors. Yes it is possible. But people consistently overestimate how easy it is to do this. Would you bet billions of dollars on being able to fool other managers of billions of dollars? I wouldn't.
- quadrangle 8y agoIt's not that this is itself a straightforward strategy. It's that the possibility of this, even if odds aren't great are something that adds to the list of possible exits and thus reduces the total risk of an investment that isn't consciously intended to go this way.
- darawk 8y agoSure, but how much is that influencing decision making? If the probability of that is relatively small, you still need to plan to have a successful business.
- patmcc 8y ago>>If they don't make back this money, it will represent a huge waste of resources. Hardly; it'll just be a transfer from VCs with too much money to everyone else in the economy. We could probably use more of that.
- soVeryTired 8y ago> Hardly; it'll just be a transfer from VCs with too much money to everyone else in the economy. We could probably use more of that. The VCs are gambling with someone else's money though. They raise money from institutional investors: pension funds and insurance companies. Ultimately the little guy will pay via government bailouts, pension reductions, and higher insurance premiums.
- Ericson2314 8y agoI get they raise others' money, but which pension funds are being into this high risk stuff?
- maxxxxx 8y agoQuite a few. Due to underfunding they are under a lot of pressure to produce higher returns so they invest into VC and private equity.
- bspn 8y agoAlmost all of them. They manage their portfolios like most other large fund managers albeit with a slight preference towards lower risk assets to ensure their short/medium term pension obligations are met, but they will almost always have an alternative investment bucket which VC will be a part of. They're also not interested in doing direct investments, so they'll diversify their early stage risk by investing in a couple of the more successful, established VC funds who spread the bets for them.
- notfromhere 8y agolots of them allocate a percentage to alternatives, and with a low-return environment, there was a push to keep doing it. However, there's also been a counter movement of pensions moving cash out of alternatives due to mediocre performance after fees are accounted for. It's a mixed bag really, a lot of it has to do with pensions sometimes being run by untrained elected officials, or them buying whatever bs a pe or hedge fund shop is selling them.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- noelsusman 8y agoI won't pretend to understand the world of unicorn startups, but it's important to remember that this isn't how the economy is run. For all the billions being set on fire here it's still a relatively small piece of the technology sector, much less the economy as a whole.
- empath75 8y agoA lot of that money gets funneled into Facebook, google and aws, though. Once these unicorns crash and burn it won’t be contained to one segment of the tech industry. Engineer salaries will decline, companies like atlassian, datadog and elastic search will take a hit, etc.
- Jommi 8y agoBut Google search and aws are both profitable and legitimate business models?
- chansiky 8y agoBut but, I thought tech companies were worth an absurd proportion of the economy: [1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/08/02/technology/apple-trillion-market-cap.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/08/02/technology/ap... [2] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/this-1-chart-puts-mega-techs-trillions-of-market-value-into-eye-popping-perspective-2018-07-18 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/this-1-chart-puts-mega-tec...
- CalChris 8y agoIt feels like pets.com all over again.