5 ms·
The W3C isn't to blame. No one is to blame, really. We have DRM, we hate it but it's there, and it serves a purpose. If it is your intellectual property, you g
by GuB-42 8y ago
The W3C isn't to blame. No one is to blame, really.
We have DRM, we hate it but it's there, and it serves a purpose. If it is your intellectual property, you get to decide how it is used. And if you don't want to make copying too easy because you think that it will get you more money, that's your right.
The goal of the W3C is not to make to make a political statement about the rightness or wrongness of DRM. They are here to create standards that respond to use cases. And unfortunately, copyrighted content diffusion is one use case, and content owners want DRM.
And if you read the standard they came up with, it is not that bad. They managed to isolate the "evil DRM" part well enough without completely destroying its effectiveness. They also didn't require any proprietary component, though services can require them (that's what happened in the article).
Using WebAssembly (which is essentially optimized JS) for DRM is a terrible idea IMHO. DRM, to be effective, usually requires access to protected system components. It means that to make an effective enough DRM to be accepted by content providers (which is the entire point of the standard), we would need to give WebAssembly way to much power.
- xg15 8y agoThe problem is that pretty much the only way to satisfy those obligations is to turn the internet into a huge walled garden (as is currently happening). So we'll either have to accept the consequences of that, decide that some of the rightsholders' claims described above are not in the public interest or find some kind of middle ground.
- simias 8y agoYou make good points but: >And if you don't want to make copying too easy because you think that it will get you more money, that's your right. They seem to think that but is there any truth to it? I do pirate some series/movies from time to time (mostly out of convenience) and you can get high quality rips of pretty much anything mere hours after it's available on streaming sites anyway. So what is this DRM supposed to achieve? Prevent the average non-technical user from saving the stream? I mean I'm sure they wouldn't even know where to start, there's no "Save As" button on Netflix for instance. Simple client-side limitations would do the trick for 99.9% of the population. On the other hand the few technically-savvy stream rippers seem to have no issue bypassing these protections. DRM works better for interactive content like games because it's not just about ripping the output. How many decades do we have to suffer through this broken scheme and this technical debt until the right owners realize that they're wasting their time and their resources to push a system that only serves to make it harder for legit clients to consume their contents? When iTunes got rid of DRM on music files I thought it would be the tipping point where right owners would realize that this scheme was ineffective and counter-productive, but apparently it's still an industry standard for some reason. Have legit users on unsupported systems stream low-res video while the pirates can watch it in 4k for free. Ridiculous.
- Cyph0n 8y ago> So what is this DRM supposed to achieve? I think DRM in general was never really designed to completely thwart piracy. The goal is actually to delay the pirated version as much as possible and to raise the barrier to entry when pirated versions are eventually released into the wild.
- Endy 8y agoInstead of that, it's turned pirates into heroes of the common person. After all, why pay and be limited in the way you can watch the thing you paid for when unlimited access exists for free?
- jonas21 8y ago> why pay and be limited in the way you can watch the thing you paid for when unlimited access exists for free? Oh I dunno... have you tried asking one of Netflix's 140M subscribers? Or the 26M people who use Amazon prime video? The point of DRM isn't to make it impossible to pirate things -- it's to make it difficult enough to get pirated content that most people would prefer to pay a few bucks a month to watch things via a channel where rights holders are compensated. And by that measure, it seems to be working pretty well.
- Sharparam 8y agoI'm not sure for how much longer it will keep working though. With the increased fragmentation of streaming services (and geoblocking), pirating content is starting to feel more convenient yet again. When it comes to music, I can most of the time listen to it legally via Spotify or Google Play Music/YouTube Music. When it comes to movies (and especially for older movies), the rights holders give me no choice but to pirate because they simply don't make it available for me to obtain in a legal way. As an extreme example: I was looking up an old childhood movie "Hugo: Djungeldjuret". The rights holder have stopped distributing the movie and they no longer sell it, but they do issue copyright claims and take-down requests towards anyone who hosts it. How am I supposed to watch a movie like that in a legal way when the only distributor has stopped distributing it?
- nerdponx 8y agoIf it is your intellectual property, you get to decide how it is used. Another poster here made an interesting point, that this wasn't true until the 90s. Deciding "how it is used" is different from (and broader than) deciding "who gets to distribute it".
- Mindwipe 8y ago> Another poster here made an interesting point, that this wasn't true until the 90s. This was always true. Most copyright traditions recognise Droit Moral, and the right for the author to determine the integrity and treatment of the work, and have for, in some cases, literally hundreds of years.
- nerdponx 8y agoIn the USA at the federal level I'm only aware of VARA which was passed in 1990.
- rndgermandude 8y agoThe W3C, Google, Apple and MS and the TV manufacturers could have said "OK then, keep your content to yourself, let's see how your business does without us providing ways to deliver your crippled content to the eyes and ears of your customers." But of course they didn't say that, because most of them got some direct or indirect interest in DRM, enough so that the few remaining players did have no choice than to hop on board, too.
- Operyl 8y agoNo, honestly then we would’ve just had more plugins like Silverlight/Flash. Widevine helped, in part, to get rid of all of that.