13 ms·
Boeing delays 737 MAX software fix delivery
- sys_64738 8y agoWill we get to see the changeset?
- leowoo91 8y agoAs a passenger do I have choice for not riding a particular aircraft model?
- alkonaut 8y agoIf you can choose the airline you know what fleet the plane comes from. If you search on the flight number on e.g Flightradar24 you can see what model they used on the flight for several recent flights. But in the end I suppose the reality is that even an un-fixed MAX-8 is orders of magnitude safer than your car ride to the airport. So before picking aircraft models, ensure you ride the train to the airport and not a taxi...
- stronglikedan 8y ago> an un-fixed MAX-8 is orders of magnitude safer than your car ride to the airport. Of the 346 people that died in the last two plane crashes, not a single one of them died in a car on the way to the airport.
- empath75 8y agoImpeccable logic
- stronglikedan 8y agoJust as logical as the statement I was poking fun at.
- alkonaut 8y agoI was assuming the person was trying to avoid dying, not trying to avoid plane crashes in particular. Someone who wants to avoid a plane crash but would ride a motorcycle without a helmet to the airport obviously needs to use a different strategy.
- emiliobumachar 8y agoThe reverse can be said about the hundreds of thousands of car crash casualties last year.
- NeonVice 8y ago"The odds of winning the lottery is 1 in 292 million." "But for that one person it is 100%!" sigh
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoOf all the people who died of the Spanish Flu, not a one died in World War One before that.
- ATLsknotowl 8y agoAt least not all of them has been posted on 4chan, 8chan, 2chan, or whatever; having been cum on. That's good though.
- RidingPegasus 8y agoIs someone forcing you to buy the ticket? I'd be more concerned about flying particular airlines than the aircraft model.
- btmiller 8y agoYou can use something like SeatGuru before you book a flight to confirm the model. For instance, the LH490 flight on 4/9/2019 will be a 747-400: https://www.seatguru.com/findseatmap/findseatmap.php?airlinetext=Lufthansa&carrier=LH&date=04%2F09%2F2019&departing=04%2F02%2F2019&flightno=490&from=&from_loc=SEA&to=&to_loc=&search_type=flight https://www.seatguru.com/findseatmap/findseatmap.php?airline...
- bunderbunder 8y agoThe airlines can and do switch planes at the last minute, though. And I imagine part of the selling point of the MAX not requiring any recertification is that it meant they should be able to also swap a MAX for a non-MAX 737 like this. Certainly there have been reports of pilots complaining that they didn't find out they'd be flying a MAX 8 until the last minute, and having to get "trained" on it during their ride to the airport.
- blktiger 8y agoNot really, though they are all grounded until this is fixed anyway. I'd expect them to be safe after this if for no other reason than any pilot of this aircraft is going to end up with special training before they fly.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoIndeed, they won't be allowed to fly until they are likely safer than the older planes in the air today. There was reason to be concerned when the US was hesitating to ground it, but there is no reason to be concerned now that it has been grounded.
- michaelt 8y agoAfter the first crash, I heard a lot of people predicting it would lead to 100% pilot awareness of the defect and its symptoms. The second crash proved that assumption wasn't true :(
- Cacti 8y agoIt was largely true in the US and EU. Unfortunately everyone is so happy to crap on Boeing (in some cases deservedly, in some cases not) that they forget the carriers bear a significant share of the blame here, particularly after the first accident. If Ethiopian Air had put the same emphasis on pilot and mechanic training/awareness following the first accident that the US carriers did, the second crash would have likely never happened.
- simion314 8y agoDo you know if Boeing sent new training material for the pilots? If not how would non american pilots get new training ? I assume not by browsing the web. Also consider the fact that a pilot that never pilot a MAX could be asked from nowhere to fly this new plane since it is supposed to be no difference from the regular plane and they were never trained for it and maybe did not expected to fly it.
- salawat 8y ago
- sseveran 8y agoYou could pick an airline that does not use the plane you don't want to fly. In the US Delta does not fly the 737MAX nor does it have any on order. Delta has ordered 100 of the A321neos in place of the 737MAX. https://airwaysmag.com/airlines/delta-orders-100-airbus-a321neos-says-no-boeings-737-max/ https://airwaysmag.com/airlines/delta-orders-100-airbus-a321...
- btmiller 8y agoIn terms of project management, aviation software is one industry where the "three-legged stool" should always, always favor quality, so I'm more than happy to see Boeing take the extra time to get this right. Though the nose-pusher system's entire existence is due to the aerodynamic design of the entire MAX...which seems to be driven by the other 2 legs of the stool (i.e. budget and time).
- sgc 8y agoAirplanes are not gliders. There is no reason to not correct aerodynamics via powered systems since that is how virtually any airplane even flies, with the caveat being - as long as it is done well. In other words, I have no problem with the principle of their design choice, just its execution which lacked typical redundancy, and transparency to the industry.
- pron 8y agoIs there another unstable airliner in operation? Even if it's OK, at the very least flying one (with or without software controls) would seem to me to require a certification by the pilots, which, as I understand, is precisely what Boeing tried to avoid.
- sgc 8y agoThere are a number of unstable planes in service that work just fine. I don't see why it matters if they are airliners as long as instability does not translate to a higher safety risk, and I don't know if any other airliners are unstable or how unstable they might be. In this case the instability appears to have been far less significant than the faulty corrective mechanisms. I agree completely that Boeing was not transparent about how to use their plane and did not make it safe enough.
- pedrocr 8y agoYou are very certain of your conclusion while not knowing the answers to all the fundamental questions to make that conclusion. > I don't see why it matters if they are airliners as long as instability does not translate to a higher safety risk We don't know what the extra safety issue might be. > I don't know if any other airliners are unstable or how unstable they might be. We don't know if anyone has ever done this before, or how completely unusual it might be. > In this case the instability appears to have been far less significant than the faulty corrective mechanisms. And finally we don't even know the level of instability. The system was there possibly correcting for huge issues. After all the fleet is grounded instead of just disabling the system.
- _1tan 8y agoDoes anyone here know how updates like this are delivered? Sadly the article doesn't answer this question. I suppose it's not as simple as downloading it over 4G or something like that.
- gonesilent 8y agoTechs will have to visit each aircraft. It not 100% software fix. Warning light will be added also for those that did not order the HUD.
- AnssiH 8y agoI was under the impression that the AoA disagree "light" is an on-screen item: http://www.boeing.com/resources/boeingdotcom/commercial/737max/updates/AOA_VaneIndicator_AoA_Disagree_lg.jpg http://www.boeing.com/resources/boeingdotcom/commercial/737m... Or does Boeing sell MAXes without that screen altogether? The Boeing update page (https://www.boeing.com/commercial/737max/737-max-software-updates.page https://www.boeing.com/commercial/737max/737-max-software-up...) says it is the "baseline primary flight display" , so sounds like it would be included in all MAXes already, so no physical change may be necessary.
- zuppy 8y agothe physical light is a paid add-on. they’re adding it now through software for everyone.
- mikeash 8y agoAren’t they also retrofitting a second AoA sensor to those planes that didn’t have that option?
- erentz 8y agoSo from what I’ve read (happy to be corrected) the very odd thing here is apparently all of the 737 MAXs do always have two sensors installed. This was purely a software difference as to whether the AoA disagree option was software enable. This feature cost more money but it seems it exists entirely in software. The indicator is even just drawn on the LCD displays, it’s not a special light on a panel. This blows my mind and reeks like other product management decisions I’ve faced in my particular industry where someone said “make that a feature we can enable so we can charge for it”. And they did charge more for it. Now everyone will get it free. Edit: here’s a source for the claim that there’s always two physical AoA sensors installed anyway: https://aviation.stackexchange.com/a/61109 https://aviation.stackexchange.com/a/61109
- dmix 8y agoAnyone know what the text is on the controls? https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/The_737-800_Flight_Deck_3852492599-800x600.jpg https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/The_7... I find it interesting how airplanes jam as much information as possible in wherever they can.
- james_pm 8y agohttp://imgproc.airliners.net/photos/airliners/9/9/2/1495299.jpg?v=v40 http://imgproc.airliners.net/photos/airliners/9/9/2/1495299.... Google search for "737 yoke checklist" reveals a variety.
- TylerE 8y agoChecklists
- ams6110 8y agoAssuming you're asking what does the "AOA DISAGREE" alert look like: https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune.org-vbulletin/960x600/aoa_vaneindicator_aoa_disagree_lg_5b196fd8ae169ef64d606b82244f75aa9a78eac9.jpg https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune.org-vbulletin/960x600/ao...
- astockwell 8y agoMan oh man. Having (loosely) followed this saga, it sounds horrifically similar to every other "feature rush" I've ever seen in software development. I know this a fiction, but I can just imagine the scene - boss comes into SWE meeting, says "some other team implemented this thing that the higher-ups wanted, we have to change all of our stuff to make it work, and we only have X weeks/months" (common sin: deadlines before effort estimates). Then more issues are discovered in dev, SWE's try to push back but are ignored (common sin: concerns are not heard). "Scope is reduced" (common sin: this ALWAYS happens with hard deadlines, but SHOULD NEVER happen with human safety involvement, although it still does all the time e.g. healthcare). It's not until some poor, senior engineer, who is probably one of their best staff, has a stellar reputation, and genuinely cares about their job, their team, the product, and the company ... they have to fall on the sword and TELL management what's going happen: we're not shipping this yet, IT IS NOT SAFE. Then that goes all the way up the chain, management at every level wrings their hands, "how oh how did this happen?" (although they specifically are talking about the missed deadline, not the safety concerns). It gets high enough that feeling is overcome by senior leadership wrath, which flows back down, and ultimately that engineer and their entire team is punished. What a dumpster fire.
- cal5k 8y agoThat's not really what happened here. If you know what's going on, MCAS is quite safe - there are two highly visible switches that kill electric trim completely (thus disengaging MCAS) and allow the pilots to take manual control. Activating these switches is a memory item (i.e. pilots have to memorize the checklist) for runaway trim and would be universal across 737 variants. Unfortunately, it appears that both the Lion Air pilots and the Ethiopian Airlines pilots did not recognize that this was a runaway trim issue at all (or until it was too late). If the Ethiopian Airlines disaster turns out to have an identical cause to the Lion Air crash, one has to question why the pilots did not take this simple corrective action.
- CodeSheikh 8y agoBecause Boeing refused to provide them additional training that was needed to make these decisions. Boeing wanted to sell it as an add-on package. And the basic mandatory training they provided was on an iPad instead of simulator.
- tus87 8y agoSoftware can't fix a broken air-frame.
- CodeSheikh 8y agoThat's the gist of this issue.
- ncallaway 8y agoI don't think the air-frame for the 737 MAX is broken, though. I definitely agree that the MCAS system should have required two AOA sensors, and been automatically disabled when there was a disagree. I agree that Boeing should have briefed airlines and pilots about the MCAS system, the AOA disagree indicator, and potentially required new training.
- krustchinsky 8y agoThis is not an airframe issue. It has never been an airframe issue.
- village-idiot 8y agoOf all the software to not deliver in a hurry, this has to be in the top 3.
- Havoc 8y agoNo luck moving those engines back with software yet huh?
- wibblywobbly 8y agoComputer controlled instability in a military aircraft is one thing, but instability in a civilian aircraft another thing entirely. Someone here said built-in instability was an accepted design feature in modern civilian aircraft. I do not remember being asked. I wonder why? John, PPL(IR), passenger.