7 ms·
Blame Google and Microsoft. They were the people who created the specification, and pushed for it, when Netflix came begging for a solution to their DRM conundr
by jcranmer 8y ago
Blame Google and Microsoft. They were the people who created the specification, and pushed for it, when Netflix came begging for a solution to their DRM conundrum. Even if the W3C hadn't approved it, that's two of the big four browser vendors who are committing to implementing it anyways, which is enough to guarantee a de facto standard anyways.
- tiraniddo 8y agoNo, blame the movie studios, record labels etc. They're the one which require asinine DRM support for web browsers. Google/Microsoft/Apple/Adobe want to support media content, but to do so requires towing the line with the media companies otherwise they refuse to license the content (at least in HD+). Having worked with various DRM teams I know that they have to treat their code as if its the most secret code in the world, if they don't the media companies can swoop in and ban them and then no Netflix for your users. This is why Widevine code isn't open source (other than the glue EME code) and is almost certainly the reason for the refusal to work with a small open-source form of Chromium. If for example the project was used to "steal" content the media companies would be mad at Widevine, with lasting repercussions for all Chrome users. It's worth noting that typically all DRM teams work as if the hosting environment is an adversary. For example Widevine don't trust anything Chrome says as someone could recompile it and lie about the security. The only times this is relaxed is where the platform is deemed secure, such as CrOS or iOS.
- Zak 8y agoThe weird thing about this is I can find a high-quality torrent for anything on Netflix in under a minute.
- sabujp 8y agoDRM are like locks on a house, just keeps honest people out
- gloflo 8y agoExcept the lock is remotely controlled by your adversary. And your house also belongs to them. According to your analogy.
- psadauskas 8y agoAnd if you bought something from them, they're permitted to come in and take it away from you whenever they want.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoYou never bought it in the first place. The Adversary doesn't sell things anymore, it only rents them out.
- est31 8y agoSounds familiar. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19536991 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19536991
- patagonia 8y agoDRM are like locks on a gated community, just creates economic moats to enable rent seeking and prolong the status quo.
- tptacek 8y agoOk? That’s a strong argument in favor, isn’t it?
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoYou've missed the joke. In the DRM case the honest people are the ones who should be allowed in, but the DRM only allows the pirates in.
- tptacek 8y agoNo, I think you’ve missed my point. A technology that prevents generally honest people from slipping casually into dishonesty sounds valuable. Battling people who are determined to be dishonest sounds much less valuable.
- rohan1024 8y agoTorrent is something that I have nothing to complain about. It's decentralised. No big corporation is trying to control it. It's truly by the people for the people. I wonder if more protocols like this will get invented and become mainstream. Or those glorious days are already behind us? Since every big corporation is just trying to grab market share by creating walled gardens for everything.
- Reelin 8y agoI assume that policing of torrent networks by the authorities will continue to increase. As a result, I'm hopeful that darknet (ie social connection based) solutions might emerge at some point. Why use a VPN and a tracker (private or otherwise) if I could request things via (anonymized) friend-of-friend-of-friend in a straightforward manner? That way you only trust your immediate network.
- tedivm 8y agoWe could just blame all of them, since they were all involved.
- 0815test 8y agoThen Google/Microsoft/Amazon and others who are being impacted by this issue should throw some non-trivial money at media creators who are willing to commit to DRM-free content. Like Creative Commons or the Blender Foundation, for starters. We had a comparable opportunity there when Netflix started offering streaming services, but they chose to go with DRM across the board. Fine, whatever. But unless the tech industry seriously gets behind this, Big Media will start to take their "content" hostage and mandate use of their own DRM 'solutions' to "protect it adequately" - with royalties for use set as high as the market will bear. Yeah, you can say that would be an antitrust violation, whatever. Legal processes take a long time, and Big Media have plenty of political support behind them. They don't have to care if they can make things crappy enough for everyone else.
- jhasse 8y ago> No, blame the movie studios, record labels etc. They're the one which require asinine DRM support for web browsers. Google/Microsoft/Apple/Adobe want to support media content, but to do so requires towing the line with the media companies otherwise they refuse to license the content (at least in HD+). Let's say Google, Microsoft and Apple announce that they will be removing any DRM from their browsers on 2020-01-01. They will also remove any DRM playback app from their App Stores. So no Netflix on PCs, Macs, iPhones, iPads or any Android device (including stuff like Android TV). What do you think would happen?
- clarkmoody 8y agoThis is the correct solution. The big tech companies control the distribution channels. Currently, they bend to the requirements of large content producers. If they leaned the other way, toward open source and DRM-free distribution, the producers would have no choice but to comply. Of course, content producers could run back to the state for more protection (as they always do) and get legislation forcing browser makers to comply. And around and around it goes.
- wolfgke 8y ago> Of course, content producers could run back to the state for more protection (as they always do) and get legislation forcing browser makers to comply. Implementations of such forced-by-court features tend to be buggy. ;-) The implementation bugs might differ in subtle ways in each new browser release. ;-)
- chinathrow 8y agoWhy would they need to remove the DRM playback app in your scenario? If they would only remove it from the browsers, they would start pushing their native applications like Netflix for Linux, Netflix for Windows, Netflix for Mac. And browsers would be free of their DRM which causes all this.
- jhasse 8y agoBecause that would still prevent Metastream from working with Netflix ;)
- pera 8y ago> No, blame the movie studios, record labels etc. More specifically, those associated with the MPAA and the RIAA.
- jrockway 8y agoI'm pretty sure some method Netflix uses is broken anyway. People don't seem to have trouble uploading 4k rips to Usenet. (Though I haven't actually checked recently.) We were sold DRM as "the evil legacy studios are evil and make us use DRM". Well, now that Netflix produces their own content and it's still DRM'd... I guess that isn't really the reasoning.
- 0815test 8y agoTurns out Netflix is an evil legacy studio after all!
- jedberg 8y agoNetflix doesn’t make most of their content. They just have exclusive license to show it. The studio that makes it still demands DRM. In the rare case of content that is actually made by Netflix, it’s easier to just put DRM on it, because otherwise every system dedicated to encoding and playback would have to have a code branch that was special for non-DRM content. It would be a maintenance nightmare. It’s a lot easier to push all content through the same pipelines.
- throwaway2048 8y agoNetflix only content isn't "rare" anymore, sorry if I don't purchase this particular red herring. DRM benefits Netflix just as much, if not even more than it does traditional media companies.
- jedberg 8y agoIt’s very rare. I’ll bet you can’t name a single show that Netflix produces. Remember all those big name shows are produced by other people and then sold exclusively to Netflix. DRM does not benefit Netflix. It’s complicated and takes a lot of resources to run. They’d much rather not have to deal with it at all. Having DRM does not gain them any customers — in fact it loses them some. But it’s the only way they can get content.
- 8y ago
- michaelt 8y agoGoogle/Microsoft/Apple/Adobe want to support media content, but to do so requires towing the line with the media companies Sounds like the problem is the web browser companies also deciding to be movie streaming companies. Thus giving movie producing companies leverage over web browser tech. If it weren't for Google Play Movies and iTunes Movies they could have just told the MPAA companies to take a hike.
- anoncake 8y agoWhy not blame everyone involved who let EME happen? Blame is not a limited resource.
- gowld 8y agoAs the OP explained in the backwards complaint, DRM support is NOT required for web browsers. You can make a web browser that does not render DRM content.
- mindslight 8y agoWhat is the point of this "blame", especially stating it as if it were exclusive? All of these companies are past the startup/responsive/customerserving stage. They're immune to public opinion when you just keep on patronizing them. Rather, focus on concrete steps you yourself can take: 1. Make sure the hostile black box is not available / disabled in your browser. So when you end up at a page that wants to use DRM and it doesn't work, you simply attribute the problem to the website being broken (which it is), and move on. If you do need to keep using the DRM crutch for now, then only use it on a separate dedicated browser or device. 2. Base your media setup around a DRM-free pipeline (eg Kodi). Make torrenting content your default. If you want to pay indie creators for DRM free downloads, feel free. But don't fund any studios that generally push DRM. 3. Share downloaded content with friends (eg USB drives), encouraging them to not fund Netflix et al developing and promulgating more DRM. This is especially relevant for "exclusive" releases that are meant to push people into signing up for yet another subscription.
- mtgx 8y agoAnd Netflix.
- jerf 8y ago"when Netflix came begging for a solution to their DRM conundrum" Does Netflix DRM even "work"? I've never personally seriously looked around for how to break it, but I note there are still plenty of people who seem to manage to review Netflix-based shows on YouTube with video clips of sufficient quality [1], and at least some of the reviewers in question I am fairly confident aren't getting any sort of privileged backdoor access or anything. Is it "anyone can crack with a smidge of effort" or "it's really hard but it spreads once cracked"? I'm not asking for a lot of details of the crack per se, just general details of how successful it can be said to be in practice. [1] I'm not claiming they aren't necessarily re-re-encoded by the time they get to me, but if they are, I can't tell for sure, so I'm going with "sufficient quality" as a description.
- microcolonel 8y agoHDCP is broken, so people just get their captures from there I think. The Widevine stuff is also clearly not as trusted by publishers, which is why they only publish 720p streams on it IIRC. I think this is because it gets less help from the platform to prevent copying the frames.
- notyourday 8y agoThere are gazillion of 1:2 and 1:4 Chinese video splitters that strip HDCP from up to 4K sources letting any capture card rip anything that can be played on up to 4K TV. I have had the 1080p one for 5 years.
- bscphil 8y agoNo, this used to be the case, but isn't any more. Captures using lossless capture cards are called Webrips and generally disliked because they have to be reencoded (losing quality) and can only be ripped in realtime. For a long time now the better p2p groups (and even some scene) have figured out how to extract the encryption keys directly from the EME modules. So most of the Netflix rips you find on torrents these days are actually byte-for-byte copies of what you would view on Netflix. Actually they should be byte-for-byte copies, but generally aren't, since Netflix makes you jump through half a dozen hoops to get the highest quality streams, so pirated copies are actually much better quality than what you can get on Netflix.
- sangnoir 8y agoI have no sympathy for Netflix; not too long ago, Linux users had to jump a series of hurdles just to be able to play Netflix videos (including installing 32-bit Mono and Silverlight (yuck) and faking the User Agent string). As an end-user I'm happier now that it just works; as a FOSS fan, I blame the "content-owners" onerous demands for DRM.
- apostacy 8y agoI blame the OSS community that rolled out the red carpet for DRM. They are the only ones who really had a choice to make. I frankly don't blame the corporations pushing this, because they have been trying the whole time. And they did it for the worst reasons. Vanity and pride. The corporations pushing DRM are merely motivated by greed. But the players in the OSS community that opened the door for DRM were TERRIFIED of being labeled as "obsolete" or losing pretend "market share". They refused to take a stand against DRM, if it meant losing any users. Just look at the discussion thread where Mozilla decided to support DRM. The arguments in favor of DRM by the OSS community are always the same: - We need to support terrible DRM because it is popular (and being numerically popular is super important). - We need to compromise against our users because if we don't then we won't have any leverage (which we are conceding we don't have anyway) - "marketshare" - "integrated branding"(?) None of this makes sense, because Google, Apple, and Microsoft have completely different goals with building for-profit forms. People who speak in slimey business sales marketing speak are making decisions about the direction of OSS software. And these people are obsessed with cargo-culting the big commercial platforms.