4 ms·

I cannot read this article because of: "You're in private mode. Log in or create a free New York Times account to continue reading in private mode". How NYTime

I cannot read this article because of: "You're in private mode. Log in or create a free New York Times account to continue reading in private mode". How NYTimes knows I am in private mode?

karmakaze 8y ago
Googling "detect incognito stackoverflow" finds a question answered "The FileSystem API is disabled in incognito mode."
- mcv 8y ago
  Maybe they shouldn't disable it, but simply fake it.
  - deleted 8y ago
    [deleted]
  - munk-a 8y ago
    Now that people are using it to detect incognito mode they probably should...
  - vinniejames 8y ago
    They plan to deprecate it
ForHackernews 8y ago
No cookies? Access to local storage disabled?
wanone 8y ago
Worked for me in Firefox private browsing
- gibybo 8y ago
  Also worked for me in Chrome's incognito
  - throwaway8129 8y ago
    They are A/B testing it, or rolling it out slowly. I saw reports a few weeks ago, but didn't get hit with it myself until today.
- sebazzz 8y ago
  Firefox may be leveraging container functionality for private mode. Firefox containers are fully functional isolated containers of data where regular browser features function like expected. Even if it doesn't, the Firefox temporary containers add-on would help.
cs02rm0 8y ago
A quick look suggests it might be trying to do something with geolocation. I didn't get the message in Chrome.
MisterTea 8y ago
A minimalist browser that ignores everything but the most basic of html works just fine. I visited using mothra on 9front and was able to view the full article including images with no nag screen or articles remaining nonsense. It doesn't render perfectly but is completely readable. Just text and images with no other fluff to get in the way. I miss the old web.
shrimp_emoji 8y ago
NoScript = no problems Well, not the one you're mentioning.
sct202 8y ago
Whatever they're doing generates a weird reaction in Edge on my computer, where I get the private mode warning in normal Edge and no warning in inPrivate Edge.
jakeogh 8y ago
Works fine without JS.

I cannot read this article because of: "You're in private mode. Log in or create a free New York Times account to continue reading in private mode". How NYTimes knows I am in private mode?

karmakaze 8y ago

Googling "detect incognito stackoverflow" finds a question answered "The FileSystem API is disabled in incognito mode."

mcv 8y ago
Maybe they shouldn't disable it, but simply fake it.
- deleted 8y ago
  [deleted]
- munk-a 8y ago
  Now that people are using it to detect incognito mode they probably should...
- vinniejames 8y ago
  They plan to deprecate it

ForHackernews 8y ago

No cookies? Access to local storage disabled?

wanone 8y ago

Worked for me in Firefox private browsing

gibybo 8y ago
Also worked for me in Chrome's incognito
- throwaway8129 8y ago
  They are A/B testing it, or rolling it out slowly. I saw reports a few weeks ago, but didn't get hit with it myself until today.
sebazzz 8y ago
Firefox may be leveraging container functionality for private mode. Firefox containers are fully functional isolated containers of data where regular browser features function like expected. Even if it doesn't, the Firefox temporary containers add-on would help.

cs02rm0 8y ago

A quick look suggests it might be trying to do something with geolocation. I didn't get the message in Chrome.

MisterTea 8y ago

A minimalist browser that ignores everything but the most basic of html works just fine. I visited using mothra on 9front and was able to view the full article including images with no nag screen or articles remaining nonsense. It doesn't render perfectly but is completely readable. Just text and images with no other fluff to get in the way. I miss the old web.

shrimp_emoji 8y ago

NoScript = no problems Well, not the one you're mentioning.

sct202 8y ago

Whatever they're doing generates a weird reaction in Edge on my computer, where I get the private mode warning in normal Edge and no warning in inPrivate Edge.

jakeogh 8y ago

Works fine without JS.