5 ms·
> He says Epic uses such insights to improve the client experience. But coming up with fixes is difficult because doctors “have different viewpoints on everythi
by jrochkind1 8y ago
> He says Epic uses such insights to improve the client experience. But coming up with fixes is difficult because doctors “have different viewpoints on everything,” he says.
This suggests to me they are doing UX design based on "what specific interfaces and interface changes the customer asks for." While common in "enterprise" sales, I think we all know this simply _does not work_.
And it's not just an issue of the executives who make the decisions asking for different things than the end-users would. They say it's "doctors" who have "different viewpoints" we can charitably assume they really are getting UX feedback from the end-users not just from executives (I don't really believe it, but let's be charitable).
It's that UI/UX design is hard, and "just doing what the customer tells me to do" never works. The customer is not a UX designer. What the customer thinks will help may be a "local miminum" or may not actually help at all. even if it is end-users telling you what they want. end-users may be experts on the problems and frustrations they are having, but not on the design solutions.
> “We had all the right ideas that were discussed and hashed out by the committee,” says Mostashari, “but they were all of the right ideas.”
> "“The industry was like, ‘I’ve got this check dangling in front of me, and I have to check these boxes to get there, and so I’m going to do that.’ ”"
Yup, sounds like enterprise software alright.
> “It’s like asking nine women to have a baby in a month.”
That's even a paraphrase from Fred Brooks author of "The Mythical Man-Month", although the speaker may not have known it. (Brooks prob wasn't the first one to say it... but might have been about software?) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooks%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooks%27s_law
- snarf21 8y agoIt is and it is just like Salesforce or Oracle or SAP. It is the people who never have to use the software that buy it and force it on the people who do and they hate every minute of it.
- LeftTurnSignal 8y agoThis is exactly right. I used to work at a hospital and some clinics in a previous life. The administration went forward with a new EMR system without actually getting the users to "test" it beyond a webinar. I left before it started to be implemented. Not sure how it went, but it's been 4 years and they're still "working on it" according to some old co-workers still there.
- pas 8y agoFurthermore, the problem is that in these situations its the lack of iterations, and that workflows are hard to change, design is basically impossible. (Sure, an expert working group could spend time on it, but usually by the time these big projects reach the end-users and experts, it's already crunch time.)
- nwhatt 8y agoPart of the problem with UX is also the fact that large customizable systems like this push a lot of the "design" down to the IT staff responsible for maintaining the software.
- caycep 8y agoActually, what happens is they let some nurse administrator at the hospital design the UI. which leads to some horrible "kitchen sink" design w/ insane amounts of buttons and toolbars.
- tylerwince 8y ago> end-users may be experts on the problems and frustrations they are having, but not on the design solutions This is the key here. We have continuously designed our healthcare system for “quick-fix” instead of the right solution that takes longer. Even the HITECH push for EHR adoption and Meaningful Use - twisted the arms of providers to find and use an EHR before they could be built to positively impact patient care.