4 ms·
TLDR: Data sharing between competitors ain't gonna work. Data quality is abysmal, requiring more ETL & QA work than you can imagine. -- My team designed, impl
by specialist 8y ago
TLDR: Data sharing between competitors ain't gonna work. Data quality is abysmal, requiring more ETL & QA work than you can imagine.
--
My team designed, implemented, and supported 5 exchanges. Here's a PR for three of our customers.
http://newsroom.questdiagnostics.com/press-releases?item=94548 http://newsroom.questdiagnostics.com/press-releases?item=945...
We handled labs, notes, scripts, etc. (Our product didn't touch any of the financials, billing, etc. So I can't speak firsthand to the fraud stuff mentioned in the article.)
Everyone involved understood that data sharing between competitors would never be feasible. In other words, useful interchange requires someone with a big stick, such as single payer.
The push for ICD-10 (from insurers & consultants?) was ridiculous, is a work multiplier, and has zero benefit for patient care.
Our usability was pretty bad, but miles better than others (Epic, Cerner). We had the benefit of a clean slate, but too few resources to hire real, full time UI people. Also, working with (mid 2000s era) doctors was mostly brutal.
That said, healthcare is just about one of the most complicated things I've worked on. And rapidly changing. Of course the user experience sucks. I wouldn't expect any of it to improve until the domain settles down. For example, since lab reporting is industry standardized, we were able to do a pretty good job on those UIs/reports.
- nradov 8y agoICD-10 has some benefits for patient care in that it can be more specific than ICD-9. That helps when one provider sends a coded list of patient conditions to another, like for a specialist consultation. By the time ICD-10 was mandated, ICD-9 had been obsolete for years and remaining on that version was no longer tenable. Going forward the whole industry will probably have to upgrade to ICD-11 at some point. It's just a cost of doing business. Like if you write an application targeting Windows XP, eventually Microsoft stops supporting that platform and you have to expect to upgrade occasionally.
- alligatorbite 8y agoICD-9 had one code for animal bites. ICD-10 has too many codes. My favorite is alligator bites: https://www.icd10data.com/ICD10CM/Codes/V00-Y99/W50-W64/W58-#W58.01 https://www.icd10data.com/ICD10CM/Codes/V00-Y99/W50-W64/W58-... For statistical purposes and public health data, knowing what animal bit people is useful, but from a fee-for-service side, having to determine and adjust the amounts paid for all these new codes seems like unnecessary complications.
- nradov 8y agoIt's a hierarchical code system so there's no additional complication for payers. They can just set a single coverage policy and reimbursement rate for all animal bites.