7 ms·
Nokia's MeeGo is doomed - A summary of Dublin's MeeGo Summit
- brown 16y agoWell, that's a downer. I had such high hopes for Maemo/MeeGo. It just wasn't meant to be. I do love my N900. Coincidentally, I just started getting into app development the past few weeks. No SDK for Windows or OSX? Seriously? The SDK only works on specific versions of Ubuntu? Really? It all makes sense now why the platform has been a failure.
- stuaxo 16y agoIt's early days... it's a bit early to say that it's a failure, Maemo was never really pushed and Meego is not finished. Of course this is an ominous start. The SDK will come to Windows, thats pretty much a given, KDE works in Windows. If it doesn't, then virtual machines are not too painful, this has a chance of working after all the stack is pretty much the standard Linux stack. This one should be the easiest for developers, your not stuck with a language or framework that is foreign, getting started should be easy. As it is now, we haven't even got any phones running it, so of course it doesn't all work and hasn't been polished yet. Whether Nokia can survive long enough to see it through, we'll have to wait and see, I hope so.
- enjo 16y agoI really don't trust Nokia. They have a systemic internal culture that thrusts engineering into the lowest possible role. The number of engineers within Nokia who would fail at the FizzBuzz problem is staggering, often in key roles. The problem is that upper management doesn't understand why that's a problem. Their hoping that Open Source will save them from themselves I suppose, but that rarely works. As long as Nokia is largely fronting this project, I don't have a lot of faith in it's long-term viability. I just don't.
- harshaw 16y agoI concur. I once spent a couple of days in Tampere "attempting" to fix a couple of serious bugs between our app and the telephony layer on a S60 device. Never once did Nokia pair us up with a hard core device engineer - I honestly don't know if they exist. I can tell you all about the fluffy product manager types and the great times we had eating Reindeer!
- enjo 16y agoOr the Finnish Sauna?:)
- pavlov 16y agoIt just wasn't meant to be. You seem to be taking one journalist's opinion pretty seriously... No SDK for Windows or OSX? Forget about the old Linux-only Maemo SDK. The Nokia Qt SDK is what you want: http://qt.nokia.com http://qt.nokia.com
- bryanwb 16y agowow, pretty damning report. initially it sounded like a cool platform to me. Nokia should just drop Meego and throw in with android while they are still profitable.
- danieldk 16y agoUsing Android would put them in direct competition with (very) low-margin Chinese manufacturers. This is what Apple got right: if you have your own operating system and ecosystem nailed down correctly, people do not mind paying larger margins, and you are in a different game. I guess this is what Nokia is aiming for with Meego. But, despite the excellent work of the Qt trolls, it doesn't really seem to get off the ground...
- Tichy 16y agoI think Nokia is already capable of producing phones cheaply, in good quality. For all I know, they even might have some factories in China already. As an Android fan, I can only say: all I want is a really good Android device. Some are good enough (Nexus One), but there is still room for improvement. And Nokia probably would be able to pull it off. It is very unlikely that they'll go that route, unfortunately.
- thingie 16y agoThere is almost nothing to get off the ground yet… Running meego on some cheap netbook is meaningless, I can put anything there and I'm going to use it in the same way, I want some tablet or smartphone form device.
- metageek 16y agoYeah, but it worked for Apple only because they were first (more or less). Nokia can't go that way. Their only hope is to adopt a successful OS and produce top-notch phones.
- fhars 16y agoNokia has always produced top notch phones. Their only problem is that it looks like they couldn't write decent software for phones if their life depended on it (randomly shuffling browser bookmarks every time I open the IMAP-client? Come /on/...) Sent from my Nokia E sixtysomething or other.
- roel_v 16y agoHow does one get an invite to an event like that? Are they common? All I ever heard of are the 'MS Tech Days' for which you have to pony several thousands and you don't even get cool stuff, afaik.
- rmc 16y agoI heard it was free to go to. Friend of mine went and got the free tablet and everything.
- villiros 16y agoIt was totally open and free. One needed to just sign up on the website and turn up. Which is probably the most damning thing about the platform: when such effort is spent at luring developers in, one wonders.
- blub 16y agoPretty much everyone is trying to lure developers with cash/devices. Except Apple, which don't need to do that.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- pieter 16y agoI'm not so sure. I tried to get a free Android device to see if Android is an interesting platform to develop for, but couldn't find anyone that could get one for me (and I'm not ready to sign a 2-year contract just for an experiment :)).
- forgotAgain 16y agoSeems a reasonable strategy to me if you have plenty of money but are short on time. Probably the largest barrier to having university students play with the platform is the cost of the hardware.
- bsergean 16y ago
- billswift 16y agoThere was a pretty good discussion of the alternatives available to Nokia on ESR's blog yesterday - http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=2772 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=2772 - all the real alternatives: Windows Phone 7, MeeGo, and Android were discussed.
- metageek 16y agoI've had Maemo in my pocket nearly four years now--first the 770, then the N810. I love my N810. The browser's only so-so, but the xterm is fantastic. I can do development on it, running gcc, python, python3, clisp, guile, hugs, mosml, emacs, and I forget what else. git and svn, of course. When I got a new phone a year ago, I considered the N900, but held back because its 3G was only for T-Mobile. (Yes, I actually travel in areas where T-Mobile doesn't have 3G. I spend one week a year in a spot where they don't even have GSM coverage.) But I figured I'd get its successor in 2012 or so. Then Nokia and Intel announced MeeGo. I still haven't seen a good explanation for this--merge two OSes, only one of which has shipping products, instead of dumping the one that doesn't? Cue sinking feeling. Nowadays I don't think I'll ever run MeeGo. Even when I get an Android phone, I'll have to carry my N810 until it dies. When it does, I'll have to try building a decent dev environment on Android. People have xterm running on it, but it doesn't have most of the tools that make Unix useful. Sigh.
- adambyrtek 16y agoJust being curious, are you comfortable doing serious coding on a machine with such a little keyboard? I can't even imagine using Emacs efficiently on a device like that. Don't you think a small netbook would increase your comfort and productivity without a considerable loss of portability?
- metageek 16y ago>Just being curious, are you comfortable doing serious coding on a machine with such a little keyboard? It's certainly slower than with a larger screen. The keyboard doesn't actually slow me down much. Hacking with one of the crappy 3-row keyboards common on phones (e.g., the N900, mrphl) would be a lot worse; but the N810 has most of the symbols I need right on the keys. For the others ({}, [], |), the xterm has a customizable palette; I just tap the right button on the screen. >I can't even imagine using Emacs efficiently on a device like that. Shrug. It's emacs. I've been using it for 20 years now; the control keys are burned into my brain. The main impediment is the screen size; I can't see much of my code at once. >Don't you think a small netbook would increase your comfort and productivity without a considerable loss of portability? No. With the N810, I can hack while walking down the street. Can't do that with a netbook.
- bergie 16y agoI think the complained availability of applications will improve pretty quickly when this stuff is done: http://www.qaiku.com/go/a25h/ http://www.qaiku.com/go/a25h/ Currently maemo.org is serving some 1.5 million open source apps for the N900 per week.
- lazylland 16y agoFact 1 : Nokia bashing is fashionable Implication : Posts bashing Nokia are bound to get lots of views Example : HN item id:195100
- jodrellblank 16y agoFor your example you pick a comment about lisp datastructures?
- lazylland 16y agooops ! typo .. should have been 1954100 :D
- jodrellblank 16y agoMeeGo is doomed, and Nokia with it if the suits holding the purse-strings aren't careful. Nokia are the 120th biggest company in the world ( http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/global500/2010/full_list/101_200.html http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/global500/2010/full_l... ) (falling from 85th in 2009); they have leeway to do a lot of things wrong before they are "doomed".
- nl 16y agoGeneral Motors is the 38th biggest company in the world (http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/global500/2010/full_list/index.html http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/global500/2010/full_l...) and they went into bankruptcy protection in 2009. Assets value and size doesn't protect you from a fall in demand. Their revenue fell 23% in 2009, and their profits fell 78.8% (http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/global500/2010/snapshots/6652.html http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/global500/2010/snapsh...). Their biggest concern has to be their share price. In December 2008 it peaked around $40. It's now around $9. If it keeps falling like that people will start talking about takeovers and/or private equity buyouts.
- moondowner 16y agoI strongly disagree with the blog's author opinion. Before basing your opinion on MeeGo on a biased article, read Arstechnica's article too: ( http://arstechnica.com/open-source/news/2010/11/meego-conference-momentum-intact-despite-lack-of-hardware.ars http://arstechnica.com/open-source/news/2010/11/meego-confer... ) P.S. "At one point, after a long explanation that failed to answer the question of why MeeGo didn't yet have a framework for developers to sell their apps, a developer from Norway shouted out: "We don't care about openness, we need to be able to make a living."" What is Qt then? http://qt.nokia.com/products/platform/meego/ http://qt.nokia.com/products/platform/meego/ Come on...
- sdfghjkjhg 16y agoQt is a very nice cross platform gui framework - it's not an app store
- moondowner 16y agoWell an app store isn't a framework either :) The author's sentence then doesn't make sense. Either-ways, my point was MeeGo has a great platform for developing applications, Qt is great, and QtCreator is an excellent IDE.
- sdfghjkjhg 16y agoI think in this context 'framework' means "a way is provided to" not in it's technical sense. The developer was complaining that there was no system in place to sell apps to users - not that there was no gui toolkit to write them.
- blub 16y agoHow can you sell apps for phones that don't exist yet? Ovi store and Intel AppUp will allow sales for MeeGo when the time comes.
- commandar 16y agoThe article used the word "sell," not develop.
- jimbokun 16y ago"You will have a browsing capable machine in your car, kitchen, living room, pocket and probably bathroom. For optimal convenience, each of these devices needs to communicate." iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch. "Doug played us a charming little video that showed cartoon MeeGo-people pausing movies on their televisions, stepping out into the car and playing the movie immediately from its last pause." Netflix streaming, more or less. Wii, XBox, PS3, iOS, Windows, Mac, some Blue Ray players, I think. All of which know what's in your queue and even where you left off watching on your other device. The future happened while this guy wasn't looking.