5 ms·
This is, frustratingly, false. They have access to internal customer support that you can't even pay for as an external user. It's fucking infuriating. My brot
by smt88 8y ago
This is, frustratingly, false. They have access to internal customer support that you can't even pay for as an external user. It's fucking infuriating.
My brother is disabled and hadn't logged into his Gmail account for a few months.
I helped him log in, which somehow triggered some kind of security system. It thought we were hacking the account. We got stuck in an infinite loop of "verify your 2FA, answer personal questions, wait for customer support to review the situation, repeat".
It was hellish. We tried over and over again for months to get back in. I still even had access to the Gmail account that sent him the original invite. But when no human will review the situation, you can't break out of the loop.
The only way we got his email account back was by talking to one of my friends who works at Google.
- frutiger 8y agoWere you (or your brother) paying for his Gmail service?
- Dylan16807 8y agoIt doesn't matter. We already know google will lock out paid accounts without the ability to talk to a human.
- frutiger 8y agoIt does matter. Expecting something for free is exactly what leads to being ghosted, whether by a person (see the lament of the GNOME Calendar maintainer that was up here earlier) or a company.
- macintux 8y agoI’m confused. What did his brother expect other than adequate user support? If you can’t support a service, don’t offer it.
- Dylan16807 8y agoThey do the same thing to paid accounts. How can I be clearer.
- frutiger 8y agoProviding some data comparing relative rates of such incidents of paid vs. free customers would be a start. Repeating something does not make it clearer nor more convincing.
- Dylan16807 8y agoThe claim is that you can't even pay for good support. The relative badness between paid and free is irrelevant. Have you honestly never seen one of the stories about how badly google treats paying customers, and specifically how automated it all is? I can do the job of searching that if you need me to, but I'm not going to argue about free vs. paid because that's not the topic at hand.
- frutiger 8y agoYou went from “how can I be clearer” to deciding my criteria for clarity are not relevant in this discussion because we are not arguing free vs. paid. I thought that was exactly what we were discussing based on my original question. Furthermore, sporadic blog posts/tweets here and there are not indicative of how the vast majority of users feel about this service. Especially paid users who generally are too busy adding value to complain. It’s worth remembering what email was like before Gmail came around. With their spam analysis they basically fixed email and moved the world towards a simpler web ui for email (as opposed to hotmail etc. of the day).
- craftinator 8y ago"Especially paid users who generally are too busy adding value to complain." Sooooo, people who are too busy paying Google for services, while also being data mined for profit, to complain about being on fully automated support? You need to add a disclaimer that you work for Google.
- mostlysimilar 8y agoIt's "free" in the sense that we aren't giving them money directly, but they make their billions by relying on us to use these services. Implying users who aren't entering a credit card number are of no value to Google is either disingenuous or short sighted. Beyond just that point I think a critical dependence on these services, mixed with a general tech illiteracy and an uncaring corporation is a dangerous situation to be in. One could argue that it's the user who is responsible for maintaining access to their email account, but the reality is that the vast majority of users are not educated in these areas and absolutely need help. A corporation that won't help them use the services they provide deserves to be replaced by one that will -- unfortunately, Google is so dominant that the chance of someone seeking out and finding ProtonMail or rolling their own server is tiny. It's hard to compete with Gmail, even when you have options like ProtonMail which provide excellent customer service (with phone numbers!) I'm just thinking out loud. It seems like a problem to me. Dunno how to solve it.
- pishpash 8y agoMaybe they should make it clear then that all Google accounts/services are disposable like used toilet paper. See how that goes over.
- smt88 8y agoI would pay $10/mo for ad-free Gmail without hesitation. I'd pay $20 to speak to customer support. In that particular case, I would've paid $1,000 for a Google investigator to spend 10 min verifying the account. None of those options are available at any price.
- frutiger 8y agoYou can pay $5/mo for ad free gmail (I do). You cannot pay for this $1000 special investigation option. That doesn’t exist in almost any service, I don’t know why Gmail would be any different.
- Dylan16807 8y agoMost services will let you get 10 minutes of someone's time, and they won't even charge per incident.
- smt88 8y agoGmail should be different because losing access can destroy someone's life. Literally. And every paid service I've ever used has at least email support. Gmail has nothing.
- craftinator 8y agoGoogle was making advertising revenue from their data profiles... We ALL pay for Google Service, even if we don't make an account.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- q3k 8y agoThere's an internal form for accelerating account recovery. There's no 'access to internal customer support'. And it would be bad karma to create (internally public) bug reports with PII (like someone's email address).