6 ms·
Google's Current Bid for Groupon: $5 Billion.
- csmeder 16y agoWhy didn't Google move quickly to make a competitor to Groupon? I feel like this would have given them much more leverage to offer a lower price. With google's reach and talent, I feel like they could have made groupon sweat. And then bought groupon for a more reasonable amount of money. 5 billion seems like a lot for a company that has such a low barrier to entry for competitors.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoProbably because they didn't want someone else to buy it?
- gfunk911 16y agoThe value of an acquisition is (simplifying) a product of how easy it would be to replicate the target without buying it, that is itself a combination of (again simplifying) how big a first/early mover advantage they have, and the technical lead they have, in terms of software, data, infrastructure, etc. Groupon obviously has an early-mover advantage, although it doesn't seem insurmountable, but their technical advantage doesn't seem enormous. I don't mean to undersell what they've done and fall into the "I could build X in a weekend" trap, but what they've accomplished technically seems easily repeatable in a year by a company of Google's talent, if not less. Their early-mover advantage has established them as the definite leader in the area, but again, it does not seems insurmountable. There isn't significant vendor lockin (the vendors are constantly changing), nor customer lockin, (other than having to sign up for a new site). There is a clear avenue for competitors to break in, by offering better terms. Basically, they are printing money by being a middleman. Funny, i thought the internet was supposed to eliminate that kind of business. They are certainly worth billions, as they are enormously profitable, but 6 billion seems excessive. What this says to me is that Google sees locally-based commerce that occurs online (bad phrasing by me) as a critical space in the coming years, and they would rather significantly overpay and jump ahead rather than risk being lapped.
- gkoberger 16y agoDoes Google have the technical skills? Of course- after all, Groupon started out as a mere blog. That being said, imagine a Google-made version of Groupon. It would be horrible. Google may not get it when it comes to making products similar to this- but at least it seems to know it doesn't. Google isn't in it for the technology. They'd be buying it for the community and the atmosphere- something they can't reproduce. After all, nobody will care about "Google Coupons", the minimalistic Groupon knockoff with that big blue "Buy now!" Google Checkout button.
- Mystalic 16y agoThis is not about the technical aspect at all or about being an early mover. Great companies solve the technical problem and the distribution problem. Groupon's value is in its distribution and its ability to scale that to the moon. Don't think just any company could replicate that.
- fookyong 16y agoIf you've had no experience in E-commerce it's often overlooked just how hard it is to get people to come to your site and open their wallets. This is part analytical, part marketing and part secret sauce. Groupon has figured it out and they are scaling it up. This is not something that anyone can replicate. Anyone can build a group-buying site and hire a sales force to do deals. Acquiring the members and getting them to buy stuff to the point where you are doing $50MM in sales p/m is a vastly different set of challenges that I think most of their competitors are incapable of.
- enjo 16y agoI wonder what Living Social is doing these days in revenue? It may be difficult, but you can't convince me it can't be replicated for far under $5 Billion. In my small sample Groupon hardly has a ton of brand loyalty and they certainly haven't penetrated the larger mindshare in the same way companies like Google or Facebook have. Google surely knows something that I don't... but I just can't imagine them shelling this type of money out for something like this.
- dstein 16y agoFor the same price they should be buying Twitter.
- oscardelben 16y agoI suspect at this time Groupon would be a better business model.
- asmosoinio 16y agoIs Groupon really that big?
- varjag 16y agoDunno how big is it, but the whole internet advertisement business lately seems just about groupon promotions. (yes I surf without adblock)
- bl4k 16y agoever googled for 'pizza delivery near me'? (where 'me' is suburb)
- vibhavs 16y agoGroupon supposedly earns $50MM/month in revenue. So this offer would be at ~8x annual revenue. Overpriced? Yes. Is Google desperate? Hell yes.
- falsestprophet 16y agoWould this mean their army of Ruby on Rails developers being laid off and replaced with a team of many fewer Google engineers? edit: sure it is a bit offensive, but it is a serious question
- sulla 16y agoPretty sure that sales, marketing & brand is what's the most valuable here.
- mkramlich 16y agofrom what I've seen of their UI and feature breadth, a site like Groupon should not require many web developers. It's so limited and "canned" in it's look. Now having several smart engineers to help make it highly performant and scale up -- that would be useful, and would be something Google could obviously help with.
- jaredmck 16y agoGroupon doesn't have that many developers- it's sales in which they have an army of employees. The most recent number I've heard is 2,500. Groupon is not a tech company, it's a sales company. Lefkofsky and Keywell (the original investors who often are referred to as "founders") continually bring a slight bit of tech into old industries and then throw tons of salespeople into them. Highly doubt the profits will last.
- mkramlich 16y agosounds like that aspect is a good fit for Google then, since Google is strong in tech but weak in sales and customer service. I think $5b is overpaying. But at a much lower price point I can see how acquiring them would make sense, because of this tech-needs-sales&service fit.
- gojomo 16y agoAnd if they buy in the next 17 hours, 23 minutes, and 15 seconds, they can have $6 billion worth of Groupon for only $3 billion.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoI can't help but remember Geocities, which sold for $3.5 billion way back when. Sometimes you buy a company on the cusp of rapid exponential growth, other times it's merely on the cusp of rapid obsolescence by a flurry of superior competitors. I have a hard time buying the idea that groupon is actually worth $5 billion.
- paradox95 16y agoI'm with you. This price is WAY too much in my opinon.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoThe major difference is that Groupon has revenue estimated around $350m, and is profitable ($50m/year). As far as I can tell, GeoCities never turned a profit and only had something like $30m in revenue their last year. That said, buying a company for 100x its annual profit still seems pretty steep.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- InclinedPlane 16y agoIn hindsight, sure. At the time of its acquisition by yahoo geocities was the 3rd most visited site on the web, and was publicly traded with a market cap very near what yahoo paid. At the time it looked like a sure bet to snag geocities, bring it under the Yahoo ad network umbrella and simply wait for the inevitable windfall from ad revenue tied to continued exponential traffic growth. Unfortunately, Yahoo screwed up, they killed a lot of traffic by driving away users through unpopular terms of service changes and other silly changes. Meanwhile, the web was growing up and sprouting innumerable new free content hosting sites that were far better than geocities (blog hosting sites like blogspot being the prime example) while the cost of full service paid web-hosting was falling through the floor. At the same time the dot-com bubble burst and internet ad revenue dried up. Geocities found itself obsolete, unliked, and decidedly unprofitable. In comparison, groupon looks positively questionable. It needs to grow not merely 100x but more like 1,000x in order to justify the huge investment that google will put into it.
- gojomo 16y agoGroupon: great name, great consumer awareness, an existing salesforce hitting on all cycles, a growing database of what works and what doesn't -- but fairly easy to copy the basic formula. Also notable: some of Google's profits come from unsophisticated operators often overbidding for Google ad placement, the "winner's curse" of auctions. Some of Groupon's profits similarly come from unsophisticated small businesses overpaying for a new kind of promotion, in order to be a featured daily deal. Neither company wants this tendency for overpaying to go too crazy, burning out their customer base. But each likes the way these market dynamics drive even savvy operators towards paying more than half of the 'gains from trade' to the promotion-provider.
- zzleeper 16y agoDoesn't Google uses Vickrey auctions (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vickrey_auction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vickrey_auction) just to avoid this? I recall an article by Hal Varian some time ago about this..
- redwood 16y agoyup
- gojomo 16y agoThe Vickrey/second-price auction helps a sealed bid auction behave more like an iterative escalating bid auction, and helps encourage bidders to reveal their true reserve value. But, it does not directly address the "winner's curse", which is that whatever the auction mechanism, the winning bidder(s) are especially likely to be those who have overestimated the value of the item at auction (even if paying the next-highest-overestimator's bid).
- zzleeper 16y agoThat makes sense.. however winner's curse is more relevant when you have common value auctions (eg: bidding for something with an unknown value that is the same for everyone). However, in advertisement everyone has a different value derived from the ads, and also since you advertise every day, winner's curse is less likely (you learn). =)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- RtodaAV 16y agoSorry google but you should pass.
- siegler 16y agoHard to believe the company is so young. Founded only two years ago by Andrew Mason. Built on collective buying technology that he built for a site, The Point, that he started only a year before in 2007. http://www.groupon.com/about http://www.groupon.com/about
- antidaily 16y agoAnd Jason Fried is on the board of directors??
- vaksel 16y agoit's a little easier to grow when you have an existing company to piggy back on, since you get a large customer base right away. That's pretty much the #1 reason they became #1 in the space...otherwise they would have been matched by competitors at this point, and Google would be buying living social for a few hundred mil
- wooster 16y agoDifference between Google and Apple: Steve Jobs would commit seppuku before spending $5 billion on something he could remake, better, in a couple of months with a handful of dedicated engineers and a barn full of even more dedicated marketeers.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoAnd he'd continue to enjoy his niche.
- wooster 16y agoNiche? Apple is the second largest company in the world. It's long past being 'niche'. For perspective: when I started there, the market cap was less than the amount of cash we had in the bank.
- pyre 16y agoThey are still a minority in some of their markets, even if they are a highly profitable minority. This is where people get 'niche' from.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoCompare the number of Android handsets selling versus iPhones. Compare the number of users of Ping and Last.FM. I'm not saying they're not good at what they do, or that they're not profitable at all.
- patd 16y agoIsn't the difference just that Apple excels at marketing while Google sucks at it and know it ? Google would be acquiring a great marketing team by buying GroupOn. We'll see what Apple is going to spend its cash on, but it could be something that Google already has or could replicate easily but Apple can't generate on its own.
- smackfu 16y agoLike Ping?
- gamble 16y agoI get shivers imagining a single company that combines the integrity of Groupon with the customer service of Google.
- Tichy 16y agoI can't believe it :-( I am not sure if Groupon is not actually evil by nature (manipulating consumers).
- InfinityX0 16y agoOne billion? You know what's cool? One trillion.
- spektom 16y ago"We buy companies to get excellent people" @ Mark Zuckerberg May be the same holds true for Google & Groupon?
- kees 16y agoMaybe Google wants to buy a highly salesforce, capable of luring small business owners in very risky deals. They definitely could increase the amount of adwords customers as well.
- kennethh 16y agoGoogle bought youtube for 1.65$ billion and is now paying 3 times as much for something which is basicly an email marketing list and who get all their customers from aggressivly marketing on adwords? They have an good idea but the price is pretty steep. On the other hand they have been good at buying up local companies doing the same (they bought mycitydeal which operated in scandinavia/germany)
- vchien 16y agoWow...better work hard....
- davi 16y agoOn the face of it this is hard for me to understand. Here's the way I can rationalize it: imagine Google spends $20 million (or whatever) to build underlying technology. Then spends $2 billion to roll out a nationwide sales force sufficient to saturate all cities of some threshold size, and another $1 billion for a nationwide marketing campaign to introduce the project to consumers, all over the course of 1 year. On the surface this is a better deal. But does it remind you of anyone? Microsoft. This is what Microsoft does when they try to do something new. And all too often, they fail. One reason they fail is that it's hard to effectively mobilize thousands of people and spend gobs of money in a short amount of time. The effort is so big it threatens to crush itself under its own weight if it is not properly managed. And management is hard. Google is essentially sidestepping this management risk by spending a ton of money. They get something that is in a working state, rather than trying to quickly deploy something huge and new. Money is (relatively) cheap to Google, but opportunities for low risk, significant growth into a complementary space are rare. So this makes sense for them. Here endeth the half-baked disquisition.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoI was curious how this compared to other acquisitions in terms of ROI for the investors. Here are a few I drummed up (from Crunchbase): Groupon: 171m => 5b = 30x YouTube: 11.5m => 1.65b = 145x MySpace: 21m => 580m = 27x AdMob: 47m => 750m = 16x GeoCities: 40m => 2.87b = 71x
- andrew1 16y agoMaybe I don't understand these investments but I don't think that makes any sense. Presumably the 171m that's been invested in Groupon hasn't bought the whole company, only a proportion of it, so the investors only get that same proportion of the 5bn. For example if that 171m represents only 10% of Groupon's shares then the investors only get 500m back; a 3x return rather than a 30x return.
- redthrowaway 16y agoWhile true, I doubt investors own only 10% of Groupon, especially not at a $171M stake. Groupon had (at least) two cash injections, one for $1M in seed money, the other for $135M. The last round was for 10%, which gave them a $1.35B valuation in April. Some reading: http://www.forbes.com/forbes/2010/0830/entrepreneurs-groupon-facebook-twitter-next-web-phenom.html http://www.forbes.com/forbes/2010/0830/entrepreneurs-groupon...
- moon_of_moon 16y agoWhere does all that revenue come from? (I'm not in the US so I don't use the site). Forbes is reporting $500mm annual sales. Boston, for example, has a deal today for 150 * $15 meals at a restaurant.That's $2250 revenue for a day or about $800k for the year. Assuming there are about 30 large cities in the US thats $24mm annual revenues. Even if the average deal size (item price * count) is FIVE times that its about $110mm annually. Also kind of tough to scale when the USP is ONE deal a day right? I mean will this work with two deals a day? What am i missing? Thanks.
- inthewoods 16y agoMultiple cities, and you're looking at a small deal. For instance, the recent GAP deal for $25 - sold 20,000. At $12.50 (50% margin), that's over $200k for one day.
- jonknee 16y agoGo back and look at recent deals, 150x$15 is quite small. In my city there was one for 1189x$110 this month. That's $130,000 in one day in just one of 250+ markets.
- mkramlich 16y agoI'm a bit amazed that something that seems lame and is useless to me personally as a potential enduser is worth $5 billion to Google. Goes to show how "scratching your own itch" is not the only way to build a profitable new business.