15 ms·
After accidental vote, EU copyright bill faces three legitimacy issues
- thepangolino 8y agoFor me this is not just the EU copyright bill that faces legitimacy issues but the whole European Parliament. The vote only served to highlight systemic issues regarding how votes are conducted.
- gambiting 8y agoHow so? Can you expand on that?
- amelius 8y agoI think the words "accidental vote" in the title say enough.
- fasterthanlime 8y agoHere's MEP Dobromir Sośnierz showing how the two different kind of votes look like: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zLh9DMuetm4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zLh9DMuetm4 It seemed incredible to me how one could "accidentally vote wrong", but seeing the process and speed at which it goes, I totally buy it now.
- seba_dos1 8y agoKeep in mind that this video comes from a very biased source (an unimportant party that literally went to elections with a claim to want to "destroy the EU from inside"). The issue may be real, but beware of how exactly it's being painted in this material.
- lisper 8y agoIf this issue is real (and it seems plausible to me) then destroying the EU from the inside might very well be an honorable thing to do.
- trickstra 8y agoIt most certainly isn't plausible. Have you ever seen any livestreams or full recordings of parliamentary sessions? Not necessary from EP. They are voting whether to have 10 minute break. They are voting whether to accept the daily schedule. They are voting whether to follow with the next point in the schedule. They are voting whether to start voting. Those are the ones voted by raising your hands. Those are the ones that nobody expects any protests so the people don't even raise their eyes. Copyright act was voted by names, otherwise Julia Reda wouldn't have the lists
- lisper 8y ago> Copyright act was voted by names And yet there are ten EU parliament members on the record saying that they voted in favor of the copyright act "by accident": https://www.theverge.com/2019/3/27/18283837/europe-copyright-directive-accidental-vote-meps-amendment https://www.theverge.com/2019/3/27/18283837/europe-copyright... So there's clearly something wrong with the procedures.
- jeremyjh 8y agoSounds like a great way to have your cake and eat it too.
- isostatic 8y agoIn Westminster the voting system means you have to leave the chamber and go through into another room. Takes about 15 minutes. You get MPs that vote both yes and no. People saying they “made a mistake” only say such a thing because they regret it - they’ve probably never had anyone contact them about which way they voted in the past.
- 8y ago
- herbstein 8y agoThe clips he shows of the chairman looks a lot like "formal" votes. We have them here in Denmark too. It often goes something like this: > Bill x can be fast-tracked. Does anyone oppose? <half a second break> It has been fast-tracked. It's done like that because no one is going to oppose.
- trickstra 8y agothe lack of context in the video suggests strong populism. I don't believe this is how the copyright act was voted (I'm actually pretty sure that one was voted by names, not by hands, because we have the voting results on the european website)
- trickstra 8y agoI managed to find the actual video of how the Copyright Act was voted: http://www.europarl.europa.eu/plenary/EN/vod.html?mode=unit&vodLanguage=EN&startTime=20190326-12:48:04-384# http://www.europarl.europa.eu/plenary/EN/vod.html?mode=unit&... I see absolutely no reason to excuse those who failed to vote correctly in this setting.
- kozikow 8y agoBrexit vote expressed people disagreement with bureaucracy and corruption like this, not with being a part of Europe.
- viraptor 8y agoYou may need some references for that idea. I'm not saying it's wrong, just that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
- dbdjfjrjvebd 8y agoListening to people that voted for Brexit has shown me that they voted for it for many reasons. This is one of the reasons that people have given me. Furthermore this is a reason that many remainers were not able to push the case for remain strongly enough.
- PavlovsCat 8y ago> This is one of the reasons that people have given me. Which by definition means it wasn't the only reason, which proves kozikow's comment to be untrue.
- pessimizer 8y agoIt doesn't unless kozikow deleted some reference to it being "the only reason." It's a commonly cited gripe. I suspect it often comes from people entirely unfamiliar with EU processes, but who don't like EU membership or the idea of EU membership for other reasons and since it's a commonly cited gripe (and also doesn't mention immigrants, and has a pro-democratic connotation) they use it themselves. It would be strange that no one in this thread has ever heard a Brexiteer cite bureaucracy and corruption, but I fear it's an urge to insist that the only reason that anybody voted for Brexit was racism to delegitimatize leaver votes or even the possibility of debate between two good people on the subject. I fear that attitude will not convert many previous leavers to new remainers in any future people's vote. I suggest not bothering with arguments against racism, which racists will have heard before and dismissed, looking at left-wing arguments against EU membership from the 70s, and responding to those.
- trickstra 8y agoaccidental my ass
- OrgNet 8y agothey think all of us are stupid...
- johnnycab 8y agoOthers have said the incorrect votes were perhaps not so accidental. Magnus Andersson, leader of the Swedish Pirate Party, suggested on Twitter that MEPs may have corrected the record just so they could later say they meant to do the right thing “as a way to get away with how they voted.” https://www.theverge.com/2019/3/27/18283837/europe-copyright-directive-accidental-vote-meps-amendment https://www.theverge.com/2019/3/27/18283837/europe-copyright... Some votes cast in the plebiscite were incidental rather than being accidental; the upcoming European elections in May, might require some members to contain the backlash or limit any blowback.
- mrosett 8y agoI'm not sure if the author is in the "denial" stage or the "bargaining" stage of grief. The outcome of the vote is an absolute travesty, and I don't understand the intricacies of EU politics, but everything I've seen gives me the impression that this is a done deal.
- johnnyfaehell 8y agoJust curious why you think upholding copyright is a travesty?
- DINKDINK 8y agoRegardless if you think "copyright" increases or decreases quality of life, it is irrefutable that it violates Natural rights. If I memorize an illegal number [1], then I've made an copy that the corporate/state doesn't allow and consequently, I no longer own my body. Enforcement of copyright breaks the NAP. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_number
- CamperBob2 8y agoThe EU isn't big on natural rights, though. They talk a good game, but once you get beyond the vaguest platitudes, the people in power at the moment are the ones who get to define what "rights" mean. As usual it comes down to whoever has the most lawyers, guns, and/or money. The concept is problematic enough here in the US, where our founding documents assume that rights are granted by a deity who rarely bothers to put in an appearance when said rights are being violated. It's best to find more rational bases than "natural rights" for arguments like copyright reform, if at all possible.
- johnnyfaehell 8y agoI don't think you understand what a copy is. Memorising something isn't a copy. The Wikipedia page you linked to doesn't even list knowing an illegal number as a crime. It says process, utter, or transmit. I personally feel like you've tried really hard to find something that makes copyright look like a bad thing and something that breaches your human rights. But all I think is you don't know what you're talking about.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- karmakaze 8y ago"Well that didn't go as intended. Let's amend it. Oh right, we can't."