6 ms·
Two wheeled dynamically balanced warehouse robot like that is completely unnecessary complication. Boston Dynamics is developing amazing tech but they are demo
by nabla9 8y ago
Two wheeled dynamically balanced warehouse robot like that is completely unnecessary complication.
Boston Dynamics is developing amazing tech but they are demoing robots for tasks that are better with 4 wheels. Dynamically balanced walkers inside are niche application.
Smarter robot hands and 4-wheeled robot movers are where the markets and money is. Boston dynamics may be moving towards that direction but they still like to show the cools stuff they can't find markets for.
- imhoguy 8y agoI think it is like LHC, core concept may be waste of resources for some however the benefit here is research and development on materials, sensors, engines, power supply, automation so on. At least better than arms race (I know that DARPA funds some robots).
- tnecniv 8y ago> I know that DARPA funds some robots DARPA funding is not necessarily violent. One can argue that the current explosion in self-driving cars is due to the DARPA challenges in the 2000s.
- godelski 8y agoDARPA's mission is "to make pivotal investments in breakthrough technologies for national security". Depending on how you view national security, you can make some easy arguments for DARPA investing money into sectors that help increase the nation's economy.
- Florin_Andrei 8y ago> Two wheeled dynamically balanced warehouse robot like that is completely unnecessary complication. I had the same intuition, but then I remembered the toy I'm playing with - the spectacularly unstable 4-rotor copter that could not even take off without an onboard computer actively keeping it level all the freaking time. And it's rock solid almost no matter what. As technology changes, our intuitions must follow.
- nabla9 8y ago4-copter has use for the balancing and has replaced complex mechanical flybar with cheaper electronics. 2-wheeler is not better or more stable than 4-wheeler and requires more maintenance.
- cm2187 8y agoAnd 4 wheeler will be cheaper.
- hinkley 8y agoCheaper and will not automatically fall over in the case of a power failure.
- cm2187 8y agoOr a bug! I assume it will also consume less power.
- dwiel 8y agoAre you 100% sure? 4 wheeler needs twice as many wheels and a larger frame. A little controller and imu is pretty cheap by comparison.
- cm2187 8y agoNot just a little controller, a counterbalancing mechanism with gyroscopes, etc. Versus a motorised trolley.
- hinkley 8y agoThis was my reaction too, but after I thought about it for a second it seems only half right. For a device leaning into shelves to grab things, being dynamically balanced might be useful. Like a racing sailboat with a movable keel or ballast. But you could do that with a three wheeled design. I bet there's also a static version of this bot with three wheels, slightly larger footprint, where the battery pack is situated over the third wheel for leverage. But the swinging battery pack? In theory it reduces the footprint of the bot, but any time the bot is trying to grab a package, the battery is moving. Which means you can't let another robot or human enter that space. So either you have a very very complicated calculation of what areas of the warehouse are 'empty' at any moment, or your logistics program has to treat the robot like it's its worst-case footprint at all times. At which point you might as well make it static. Right?
- jhales 8y agoSeems like it wouldn't be too hard to just put a cover over the batteries entire range of motion.
- bluedino 8y agoOSHA would want a light curtain like on virtually every other machine in a factory
- wool_gather 8y agoIs this physical safety margin a substantially different problem than human-operated machinery, though? You don't want to get too close to a live forklift, either.
- HALtheWise 8y agoI'm not sure that these intuitions are actually correct. For example, while it seems obvious that a four wheel solution should be faster and cheaper, that is only really true if you assume that software and controls algorithms are expensive. This robot needs fewer wheels, tires, frame structure, and drive motors than a conventional four wheel design, and the ability to lean into the direction of motion gives higher acceleration limits, increasing speed. Just like a bike is cheaper and higher performance than a recumbent tricycle, this might actually be cheaper and higher performance than something more conventional. If not today, Boston Dynamics seems to be betting that it will become so in the future.
- ivalm 8y agoThe counterweight swinging seems like a major hazard. Also, I am curious what stability issues it will have if there is a sudden hazard appearing (let's say person walk in front of it).
- fludlight 8y agoCover it with a hard plastic skirt at the max range of motion.
- Havoc 8y ago>The counterweight swinging seems like a major hazard. Seems like an easily enough problem. Basically every car out there has reverse sensors...
- readingnews 8y agoYou are assuming that there are people around to be a liability. I am assuming there will be no people in this warehouse.
- lukasm 8y agoThe people will always be there to restart the system and clean up the accidents. Robots have to be designed in that in mind.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoThey may be working around Deka patents.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoMaybe an obsolete objection. "Just use coal for god's sake. All these electronics - bah!" I think they have solved 2-wheel control. Lets move on.