6 ms·
> I could have learned what I did in a much shorter time. I sincerely doubt it. For learning the non-practical fundamentals of, say, computer science, there is
by MaxBarraclough 8y ago
> I could have learned what I did in a much shorter time.
I sincerely doubt it. For learning the non-practical fundamentals of, say, computer science, there is no known learning environment that beats a university.
> Not a degree, but a trade school
So, only directly applicable skills, no theory and nuts-and-bolts fundamentals? Sounds far inferior to a bachelor's degree.
The software field is known for being open to talented autodidacts, in a way that, say, bridge engineering is not. That doesn't mean it makes sense to dismiss the benefits of quality formal education.
Someone with a decent bachelor's degree in computer science will have a depth and breadth of knowledge far in excess of where they'd be if they'd spent that time teaching themselves web development on the job.
> No BS courses like philosophy, social sciences, etc
Here in the UK, a STEM degree is quite 'pure', and you aren't expected to study topics like philosophy. That doesn't mean there's no value in studying them though. If philosophy struck you as a complete waste of time, then either it was taught badly, or you failed to make the most of it.
- scarface74 8y ago>I sincerely doubt it. For learning the non-practical fundamentals of, say, computer science, there is no known learning environment that beats a university. I think you kind of just made the point. Why would I pay for something that isn’t practical?
- zbentley 8y agoBecause what may prove practical over a long term may not do so in the short or medium term. And because what counts as “practicality” changes as people progress through their careers, but the foundations required to meet each new standard of what counts as practical often remain the same (or change less).
- ghaff 8y agoThat's perhaps the key point. I have engineering degrees (not CS) yet I work for a software tech company and do a lot of things that are much more about a broader liberal arts education and extracurricular activities than they are about specific technical courses I took. And, even when I did work as an engineer, it mostly wasn't in an area where I directly applied coursework.
- scarface74 8y agoAnd my business courses have helped a lot more in both undergrad and as an MBA dropout. Most of us are working to increase business value for companies - either by making them money or by saving them money. They could care less about “Cracking the Code” and LeetCode.
- scarface74 8y agoAs long as I have been doing this professionally - over 2 decades and before that 10 years as a hobbyist writing 65C02 assembly and C. I can honestly say that at this point in my career, the computer science part of what I learned hasn’t really helped me besides one course in data structures. That was only because I spent over a decade doing C. Most developers won’t be doing that these days. As my career has progressed, it’s moved further away and at higher levels of abstractions. These days even hardware is abstracted behind an API with cloud providers.
- danpat 8y agoI think "non-practical" was perhaps poor wording. I assume what the parent meant was a "data structures and algorithms" course, compared with say, "How to code in Java using the standard library". The latter is "practical" - you can take what you learn and churn out code in Java. The former is "non-practical" - you can't make the theories you now understand function without a practical implementation. But you can recognize the implementation in any environment, and understand its implications. The general assertion is that an understanding of the "non-practical" will serve you longer than a purely "practical" education. I tend to agree.
- MaxBarraclough 8y agoWell put. Yes, I might have phrased that better. A concrete example: My firewall rule is set to deny all incoming TCP connections except those originating from port 80, and destined for port 80. Why is it blocking all my HTTP connection attempts? If you understand TCP, you'll understanding that we shouldn't be filtering on source port at all. If you have only the vague sort of understanding that comes from using a technology in practice but never having properly studied it, you might have no idea. And yet I'd still count that as 'non-practical knowledge'. It isn't something you're ever going to apply 'directly', unless you're one of the handful of people implementing their own TCP stack. There's similar value in studying complexity theory (why does this seemingly simple code take so long?), operating system fundamentals (aren't containers and VMs roughly the same though?), and compilers (for a deeper appreciation of programming in general, and, my personal favourite, to instil a due sense of terror regarding undefined behaviour in C-family languages).
- Nouser76 8y agoWhile not everything learned in an undergraduate computer science program is practical in the sense that you'll use it all the time in the real world, there are a fair number of topics that while not necessary 99% of the time turn out to be the best solution that other 1% of the time. Finite state automata, for example, isn't something I'd bother to learn about but has proven helpful a handful of times.
- dragandj 8y agoYou pay for many things in life that are not practical. Why would you expect from education to be 100% practical?
- SamReidHughes 8y agoIf practicality doesn't matter, why not study Pokémon?
- zeroimpl 8y agoThere’s a lot of numbers between 0 and 100...
- walshemj 8y agoWhy have you have not learnt to code at high school if you wanted to do CS
- lumost 8y agoIn the US it's quite common for a BS in comp sci to include 1+ year of required liberal arts courses as a "general education" requirement. It's not a stretch to look at this and wonder if a more focused 2-3 year or 4 year degrees would produce an equivalent or better result.
- cosmodisk 8y agoDisagree. University education is not just about learning how to do something,but more about developing yourself as a person and those additional courses are necessary. CS graduates with little to no exposure to other areas or fields are useless.This eventually results in people who's first email is 'send me the details to your api' instead of asking what issues I'm having,why i'm having and etc. There are also so many businesses opportunities that only become visible after exploring various fields, including liberal arts.
- moosey 8y agoI continue to find great value in the Liberal Arts courses that I took when I went to University. Philosophy, in particular, serves me a great deal: it has helped me to understand the world and personal narratives that I live under, and aided me in finding an ethical framework that I might not have developed otherwise. Regardless, courses in English, Literature, and other courses I had to take outside of my main coursework for Computer Science has made my personal experience better, I believe, or at least more fulfilling. I believe that it is also the job of a good education to prepare someone to be a good member of a Democracy, and as part of that one must be able to accept other tolerant points of view, and be able to reach compromise. Courses all throughout our education should aid us in developing the empathy necessary for the process to work. It appears that we have failed, in the US, in this regard. Quite horribly.
- hnzix 8y agoIn some Universities these mandatory Liberal Arts "electives" are fluffy filler topics where you are forced to buy the textbook written by the lecturer. You can only choose between four equally fluffy filler topics per semester. I was fucking furious when I realized I'd been duped. I'm a voracious omnivore and I do believe Universities should promote wider learning but this was a straight up money extraction scam.
- dsparkman 8y agoAnd a lot of the time they leave University with a BS in Computer Science and can't find (code) their way out of a paper bag.
- fabricexpert 8y agoThis is a real problem, and it does undermine the comp sci degree. Some people are completely intimidated by programming and immediately give up, they get enough credits through the modules that don’t require any actual coding and then do their dissertation on something totally abstract. I think these students are failed by the system as programming’s core concepts are quite basic, it seems to be the tooling around it that students struggle with.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoComputer Science is not there to prepare you to be a good software developer. Comp Sci is 'Sci' :) It just so happens that being a good programmer is mostly an applied skill, and that you don't have to have rocket science Comp Sci chops to be a decent developer. In fact, in 2019, a lot of development just isn't really Comp Sci. That said, I wonder if programs should adapt and be more applied to have more of a professional kind of designation.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoThink of chemistry vs. chemical engineering. Chemistry worries about atoms and molecules, and the reactions that transform one set of molecules into another set. Chemical engineering worries about efficiently producing the desired reactions, at scale, without blowing up the factory. Chemists don't spend much time thinking about pipe bursting strength; chemical engineers do. Sure, a chemical engineer needs to know a fair amount of chemistry, but someone with a chemistry degree is not ready to be a chemical engineer. It's the same way with CS. It should be part of the college of science, just like chemistry. Software engineering should be a separate discipline, and be within the college of engineering. And having a CS degree doesn't really prepare you to work as a software engineer. Unfortunately, what we have is CS departments turning out graduates, most of whom will work as software engineers rather than computer scientists, and who are therefore badly trained for the career that they're going to try to have...
- 0xffff2 8y ago>I sincerely doubt it. For learning the non-practical fundamentals of, say, computer science, there is no known learning environment that beats a university. This is just nonsense. I would go so far as to say that I never actually learned anything in my undergrad CS classes. A combination of challenging internships and personal curiosity let me to teach myself everything I was taught in school before I was taught it in school. Of course, I only got those internships in the first place because I went to a good school and had connections that I gained by attending that school, but the idea that an otherwise competent developer can't teach themselves CS theory efficiently on their own is totally absurd. Furthermore, being taught CS fundamentals in a university is far from a good indicator of developer ability. I've interviewed a shocking number of candidates with at least a BS in computer science who were completely unable to complete incredibly simple exercises (think similar in complexity to FizzBuzz). I expect developers to have a strong grasp of the fundamentals, but they also need to be able to actually apply those fundamentals. CS departments are utterly failing in that regard.
- zeroimpl 8y agoI learnt plenty in my CS courses. I just don’t use most of them, and most of the skills I do use I didn’t learn there. That does not mean it was a waste of time - knowing the theory behind various data structures, algorithms, and circuitry make programming more satisfying for me.
- Boxxed 8y ago> I would go so far as to say that I never actually learned anything in my undergrad CS classes. I'm not sure whether to think your school had an awful CS program or you went into your classes with the wrong attitude. There are lots of practical skills that get taught in universities that aren't direct trade knowledge -- you didn't feel like you learned how to learn? Or were exposed to new ideas and parts of the field that you otherwise wouldn't know about?
- reallydude 8y ago> For learning the non-practical fundamentals of, say, computer science, there is no known learning environment that beats a university. God forbid you don't even consider that you're wrong. "Wrong attitude" signaling is pathetic. > There are lots of practical skills that get taught in universities that aren't direct trade knowledge That's a problem, but it's also hyperbole. I mean, I'm talking to a 1998 CS/EE from Berkeley who couldn't bother to try to repair his own power supply because it has a danger sticker on it. What you learn in University is to be so blind in your lane, that you don't even recognize it. It's the antithesis of learning to learn.
- itslennysfault 8y ago> I sincerely doubt it. For learning the non-practical fundamentals of, say, computer science, there is no known learning environment that beats a university IBEW electricians apprentice program is 5 years long. 6 months classroom, 6 months on a job site, repeat for 5 years until you're a journeyman. IMO the exact same pattern would be more effective than a 4 year degree any day. I've interviewed 100s of college grads at a top tech company, and I used to teach a bootcamp program. My 14 week bootcamp grads were more useful than any college grad I've interviewed, but had weak understanding of the fundamentals. If that bootcamp was 2 years I could've probably gotten them up to speed. If that classroom time was intermixed with actual industry experience they'd come out the other end ready to hit the ground running.
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y ago> were more useful than any college grad I've interviewed, but had weak understanding of the fundamentals That's the issue with bootcamps, along with the cost. A local bootcamp (Wyncode) is 11 weeks at $10,000, which is ridiculous. 1-2 programming classes at a local school can probably supplement your fundamentals, honestly, Operating Systems, Parallel Programming, and Senior Project would probably be the most useful courses for a bootcamp grad.
- itslennysfault 8y agoI don't think you understand what a bootcamp is. The one I taught was 14 weeks of 40 hours per week classroom plus an additional 20+ hours of homework. It is BY FAR the most bang for your buck for practical hands on coding skills. A couple programming classes isn't even in the same universe. Beyond that, our course material was bleeding edge. When some new hottness came out we incorporated it into our curriculum. Colleges have too much bureaucracy to keep up with the latest tech trends.
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoThere's nothing wrong with bleeding edge in course material, the issue with bootcamps has always been lacking of computing fundamentals.
- walshemj 8y agoAnd I do think that they where referring to the advanced vocational training route and not a traditional craft apprentice. Hell if you had called any of my pears on my Mech Eng Btech (termo fluids) course an apprentice we would have told you where to shove it.
- bradleyjg 8y ago> Someone with a decent bachelor's degree in computer science will have a depth and breadth of knowledge far in excess of where they'd be if they'd spent that time teaching themselves web development on the job. Also, zero professional judgement, and more likely than not, not even knowing what they are missing. Engineering curricula have their problems but at least fresh MEs and EEs IME realize that they don't know anything. Fresh CS grads come in and want to do a rewrite--in a language not used anywhere else in the company no less. Give me a self taught guy any day of the week and twice on Sundays.
- MaxBarraclough 8y ago> zero professional judgement, and more likely than not, not even knowing what they are missing. Engineering curricula have their problems but at least fresh MEs and EEs IME realize that they don't know anything. Fresh CS grads come in and want to do a rewrite--in a language not used anywhere else in the company no less I agree with all of this. I suspect it's due at least in part to the way the software world has an attitude of move fast and break things, whereas bridge engineers and aeronautical engineers are shown disaster photos to emphasise the point that If you screw up in your professional responsibilities, you may kill hundreds of people. You don't ask a fresh graduate to single-handedly design a bridge. If you did, I like to imagine they'd be sufficiently terrified that they'd decline, and not just because of the legal regulations. There is no such 'culture of responsibility' in the software world, excepting a few life-critical problem domains. I suspect universities could reduce the fresh graduate know-it-all effect if they made the effort: * Teach students about the cognitive biases that will cause them to overestimate their own expertise early in their careers * Related: teach them the principle of Chesterton's Fence (especially valuable in junior developers) Also, perhaps explicitly enumerate the skills that they simply will not have on day 1 in industry -- the skills that cannot really be taught in a university -- such as: * The ability to work effectively with with legacy systems that are large, badly written, use inconsistent style, and are poorly documented (like a boxer, much of a developer's job is simply to cope with chaos) * The ability to communicate effectively with non-technical customers (coursework is a poor simulacrum) > Give me a self taught guy any day of the week and twice on Sundays. Perhaps if you're hiring them for a 6 month stint, this might make good sense. I'm not saying a degree is a substitute for industry experience, I'm saying there's value in what's taught, and that developers are unlikely to ever learn those things on the job.
- cmroanirgo 8y ago> there is no known learning environment that beats a university. I've tried university twice and left both times before getting a degree. We are utterly incompatible, despite my grades being in the top 1% from an academic standpoint (And while attending my GPA was 4.0) I was headhunted in 1st year (the first time) and never looked back. I've come across many 'self motivated' coders like myself who thrive in all things IT, without needing to be spoonfed. > no theory and nuts-and-bolts fundamentals? I've done digital and electronics and full stack engineering, written compilers, embedded systems, 3D engines and modellers, etc, etc. I think that suffices as 'nuts and bolts'. I'm only yet to write my own OS. When hiring, I would basically ignore the degree and look at their work: their code and their ability to communicate their understanding of it. I think we live in two different worlds indeed! I'm more like OP and like getting down and dirty. I see problems (in the marketplace) and I make solutions - however they come whether it be JS or ASM.
- MaxBarraclough 8y ago> We are utterly incompatible, despite my grades being in the top 1% from an academic standpoint (And while attending my GPA was 4.0) It seems fairly clear then that you aren't representative. > When hiring, I would basically ignore the degree and look at their work: their code and their ability to communicate their understanding of it. This could well be a wise strategy. I'm not saying academic achievement is the best predictor of industry success - there are plenty of horror stories of seemingly impressive graduates failing fizzbuzz. It seems clear to me though that for many of us, a CS degree is the proper way to start one's tech career. > I'm more like OP and like getting down and dirty But you're clearly quite capable at working with advanced topics 'behind the code'. This can't be said of all professional programmers. There are plenty of code monkeys out there who don't even understand basic data-structures, let alone the concepts behind compilers and rendering engines.