5 ms·
"Engineer" conveys image of middle class white-collar job with relatively high status, good education and responsibilities. That word now used for everyone
by nabla9 8y ago
"Engineer" conveys image of middle class white-collar job with relatively high status, good education and responsibilities. That word now used for everyone doing programming related jobs inside office space for no good reason.
I think the word "tehnician" should be used to describe most grey-collar ICT jobs, including most programmers. Their responsibility and scope of their work is limited. Many programming jobs are closer to blue collar factory level mechanic than engineer.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grey-collar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grey-collar
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technician https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technician
- C1sc0cat 8y agoPlease bitch "associate professional"
- pjmlp 8y agoThankfully there are countries where Engineer is still a proper word, not something that you are allowed to call yourself after a 6 month bootcamp.
- OJFord 8y agoAnd still others have, though it may not be appreciated in all industries, _Chartered_ Engineers.
- FearNotDaniel 8y agoYup, in the UK it bugs me when I keep meeting people who introduce themselves as an 'engineer'. When I ask them if they do mechanical or civil engineering, then I usually get to say "ah, so you're a programmer, just like me". One thing I did sometimes like about being in Austria is the obsession with academic titles they have there... if somebody is a qualified engineer, they invariably use "Ing" as a title in place of "Mr" or "Ms"; people with two doctorates (not uncommon) really do call themselves Dr Dr So-and-so.
- madengr 8y agoWhat is qualified in Austria? In the USA, in most states, you must be licensed to have engineering in your business name. Your name is usually suffixed with PE.
- dharmab 8y agoBut in the USA you can refer to yourself generically as a Software Engineer without any formal education.
- madengr 8y agoYes. I don’t think there is even a PE licensing path for software, so even with a CS degree you could never become a licensed engineer. You have to work under a PE for 5 years, then take the PE exam, then CE credits. I have an MSEE, but can’t put engineer in my title. Though Ing. sounds kind of cool.
- russnewcomer 8y agoThere actually was a PE for Software Engineering, but it is being discontinued, because almost no one took it. https://ncees.org/ncees-discontinuing-pe-software-engineering-exam/ https://ncees.org/ncees-discontinuing-pe-software-engineerin...
- madengr 8y agoWow, didn’t know they had one. I wonder how they handle the licensing as there would be no one to complete the 5 year understudy; chicken and the egg.
- superwayne 8y agoTo use the "Ing" title you have to have a certain education and a few years of practice. To be honest, it doesn't mean much.
- Aeolun 8y ago
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoAnd most states in the US too. Just rarely enforced. Only a licensed PE can do business as an “Engineer”. (For example have a company with the word Engineer or Engineering in the name).
- TheCapn 8y agoProtected term in Canada as well, but I don't know the last time anyone that was used against in any level of court. During my education there was a case study of some guy digging basements calling himself an engineer when he wasn't but that's about it.
- craftinator 8y agoI believe the city of Portland OR recently sued a Danish man for "practicing engineering without a license". They were upset at him for generating strong proof of shortened yellow light times at intersections with red light cameras. He had a degree (and I believe a certificate) from Europe, but it wasn't recognized by the Authorities.
- MeltySmelty 8y agoand we'll get the job done better and quicker than you ;)
- qstyk 8y agoThat said, there's many variants that are perfect valid: network engineer, sales engineer, systems engineer, etc.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoYup. The reality of this industry is that most programmers are closer to the handymen you call to fix your faucet or lay floor tiles than to actual engineers. And we all have first-hand or second-hand horror stories related to handymen.
- spaceribs 8y agoI've come to the conclusion recently that we're all just barbers, bloodletting and burring holes. Until we have proper certifiable and reproducible competency, we'll never become surgeons.
- flatline 8y agoAnd yet the US has consistently been in the vanguard of software development worldwide. Do we need surgeons? Do you need a four year postgraduate degree and three more years of apprenticeship before slinging together a web app? Certainly the industry has its problems, and some applications demand more rigor, but I don’t see this as much of a general solution.
- spaceribs 8y agoThe market didn't demand a high survival rate or efficacy for barbering either, but do you think that the (conscious or unconscious) that software engineers are some sort of magical wizards will last forever?
- mandelbrotwurst 8y agoThere may be explanations beyond wizardry - e.g. maybe barbers were historically often self-employed, small business owners who realized they stood to gain from creating barriers to entry such as licensing requirements.
- PaulHoule 8y agoDon't you need a license to be a barber?
- cat199 8y agoAnd how many 'engineers' would tack on 1000x too much complexity to justify their 'engineering' effort? software in many cases is more art than science.
- mceldeen 8y agoI think this talk is relevant https://youtu.be/lLnsi522LS8 https://youtu.be/lLnsi522LS8