3 ms·
"Imagine the reverse: a deflationary currency, which becomes more valuable over time." This describes the U.S. dollar from 1870-1890, but this was hardly a tim
by nostrademons 8y ago
"Imagine the reverse: a deflationary currency, which becomes more valuable over time."
This describes the U.S. dollar from 1870-1890, but this was hardly a time of economic and technological stagnation:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Deflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Deflation
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Industrial_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Industrial_Revolution
Far from people holding on to their wealth to avoid missing out on the gains, they invested it heavily to avoid missing out on even bigger gains from being part of the technological revolution happening around them. Deflation was then a consequence (rather than a cause) of the economic growth that followed: with a constant money supply but more goods available for purchase, the price per good steadily fell.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoSo if you have an economy which is naturally growing very rapidly for independent reasons (e.g. because there is an industrial revolution happening) then it can outpace the deflation. But you still have some people hoarding currency because some people have different levels of risk tolerance. One person is willing to build a factory at great risk because there is even greater reward. Another person says give me the steady returns from hoarding deflationary currency. Getting rid of those returns pushes that person back into the market, requiring them to do something productive with their money instead of just sitting on it. Which is all the more important when there are many productive things to do with it. So the deflation caused growth to be less than it would have, e.g. 15% instead of 20% (in real terms), even if it wasn't enough to turn negative. But it was still a reduction. And what happens when the economy is only growing at a normal pace and you introduce a deflationary currency?
- nostrademons 8y agoIn practice what tends to happen is that debtors are incentivized to start using alternative currencies because their debt load becomes unbearable otherwise, and then the inflationary currencies drive the deflationary ones out of circulation through Gresham's Law [1]. Hoarders end up holding useless tokens that are eventually demonetized entirely. The gold-backed dollars of 1873 suffered this attack in two waves. The first was the Free Silver movement of 1892 [2], which sought to allow free coinage of silver currency as a way to create inflation and lower debt burdens for poor farmers who were being exploited by the Northeast's industrial-financial establishment (sound familiar?). This ultimately failed, although it did manage to inspire The Wizard of Oz [3]. The second was the steady inflation of Federal Reserve Notes (i.e. the dollar) from 1914 onwards. This culminated in EO 6102 [4], which made it a crime to privately own significant quantities of gold. Someone who faithfully hoarded gold coins from 1873 onwards would've done great until 1900, okay until WW1 ended, found themselves in the odd position of having money that was worth more on the black market than as legal tender (much like American Eagle gold coins have a face value of $50 today but a market value of about $1200), and then been forced to turn in their gold coins for their face value (effectively confiscating their assets at a loss) in 1933. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gresham%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gresham%27s_law [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_silver https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_silver [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_interpretations_of_The_Wonderful_Wizard_of_Oz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_interpretations_of_T... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102
- tbabb 8y agoBy pointing out the folly of commodity currency, you are making a good case against bitcoin. (This, too, is addressed in the linked article).
- nostrademons 8y agoI don't have a dog in this race, I just want to add the historical perspective. I think that Bitcoin already has failed as a currency, outside of black markets. However, that won't stop it from having value: gold failed as a currency in 1933, but is currently worth $1300/oz. I think we'll see another 1-2 Bitcoin bubbles, each with peaks significantly higher than the rest as Bitcoin are taken out of circulation, until it finally falls to Gresham's Law. I also think that conditions are extremely ripe for a currency crisis in the U.S. dollar within the next 5-10 years. There is a market now for a new currency, as evidenced by the ~3700 contenders (just in crypto alone, not counting in-game currencies for video games or mobile payment networks) launched within the last 2 years. I suspect the eventual winner will be an inflationary cryptocurrency that solves the scaling issues and has a pretty (and fast) UI. Could be Ethereum if they get their act together with Casper, or could be something yet-to-be-invented.
- tbabb 8y ago> gold failed as a currency in 1933, but is currently worth $1300/oz Yes, because gold is a commodity, not a currency. In fact, if you treat gold as a metal with utility similar to copper, but scale the price of copper proportionally to gold's scarcity, you get a price that is very in line with the actual current price of gold. Since copper's value comes almost entirely from its utility as a metal, this suggests that something similar is true of gold. That aside, comparing bitcoin to gold makes bitcoin look bad in multiple ways: The analogy is not good, and even if it were good, that would still be a bad thing. The linked article talks about this. > I suspect the eventual winner will be an inflationary cryptocurrency Almost certainly impossible. Proper active currency management requires anticipating the public's reaction to the management. Even if an algorithm could do that (in other words, a strong AI which is at least as good as people at understanding human psychology), if the algorithm were public, the public could/would use the algorithm to anticipate changes in currency policy, and that knowledge of the future would change what they do with their money, specifically in the direction of instability. So an open algorithm (a fundamental philosophy of crypto) is fundamentally at odds with the very notion of an actively managed money supply. The linked article talks about this too.
- ajross 8y agoWhich is to say, the US economy at the start of the industrial revolution is an outrageous outlier and not something you want to cite in a discussion of the baseline effects of deflation.
- nostrademons 8y agoThe present day economy from 1995-present is also an outrageous outlier and one that shares many features in common with the period from 1870-1890. Hence its relevance. If you want to look at the total timespan of human economic history, the only economic systems that have proven stable over millenia are feudalism and slavery. Democratic capitalism (and particularly post-WW2 democratic capitalism in America, which is even more of an outlier) is a comparative blip on the timeline. We don't live in the 1300s, though; we live in 2019, and so it's worth considering how our present time differs from previous epochs and how it might share similarities with some.
- ajross 8y agoWhat about all the other deflationary economies over the past two centuries though?
- nostrademons 8y agoWhich ones? The only ones I can think of that were a major problem was Japan's deflation from 1990-present, and the Great Depression. Incidences of short-term (1-2 year) periods of deflation have been common, and strongly associated with recessions either concurrently or within roughly 18 months. That link is uncontroversial. Over the long term (10+ years) the connection seems a lot more tenuous, though. The monetary contraction and subsequent recession of 1921 was followed by the Roaring Twenties. Volcker's recession in 81-82 was followed by robust growth throughout the 80s and 90s. Ireland's deflationary episode in 2009 was followed by a return to growth. The U.S. periodically had deflationary episodes and sharp recessions throughout the 1800s, but economic growth was quite strong over the century as a whole. Actually, looking at those incidents is a strong argument for dynamism and technological determinism. Deflation was a large problem in periods where there was no up-and-coming growth industry to absorb surplus labor and liquidated capital. It was a non-event when there were growth opportunities where these factors could be re-deployed. The lack of growth wasn't caused by deflation, it was caused by overly rigid mature industries and an inability to find new ways of doing things that are worth investing in.