4 ms·
I believe that is an incorrect interpretation of the law. The govt can compell an entity to assist in making encrypted information available. But the entity in
by chii 8y ago
I believe that is an incorrect interpretation of the law.
The govt can compell an entity to assist in making encrypted information available. But the entity in question is not the individual employee, but the company who owns the product or service.
If you're under the employment (i.e., not a contractor), you can't be an entity, and the employer will definitely know if they've been compelled.
But I do agree the law is stupid and erodes all trust from software owned by an Australian company.
- mastazi 8y agoI am not a lawyer so I wouldn't be able to comment on the meaning of "entity", I hope you are right though, and I also hope that the Australian Government would at least clarify the meaning of the provision and the legal definition of "entity" in this specific case.
- AaronFriel 8y agoWhat if the entity is, say, an independent contractor, staffing agency, or consultancy that provides engineering support to Apple?
- chii 8y agoi believe an independent contractor is considered a service provider, and so they could be compelled to provide the gov't assistance. I also believe that these service provider(s) are required to not disclose the fact they've provided assistance. Therefore, apple would do well to not hire any australian company for their contracting purposes (but instead, employ them as an employee).
- Benjamin_Dobell 8y agoIANAL, but sadly, the law does seem to target people rather than (or in addition to) corporations. https://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/download/legislation/bills/r6195_first-reps/toc_pdf/18204b01.pdf;fileType=application/pdf https://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/download/legislation/bi... > 317C: > For the purposes of this Part, the following table defines: > (a) designated communications provider; > (b) the eligible activitiesof a designated communications provider > A person is a designated communications provider if... ... Actually, there's too many to list. But here are a few examples: > - the person provides an electronic service that has one or more end-users in Australia > - the person develops, supplies or updates software used, for use, or likely to be used, in connection with: (a) a listed carriage service; or (b) an electronic service that has one or more end-users in Australia > - the person manufactures or supplies components for use, or likely to be used,in the manufacture of a facility for use, or likely to be used,in Australia > - the person is a constitutional corporation who: (a) manufactures; or (b) supplies; or (c) installs; or (d) maintains; data processing devices Note that in the last situation they specifically mention corporations, but that prior situations do not require this. The requirements listed are to be interpreted as an OR not and AND... so ah, that's fun. So yes, we Australians can be legally required by our Government to perform corporate espionage... and almost no-one in Australia (certainly not the public at large) seems to give a f--k.
- Benjamin_Dobell 8y agoOh, and it's probably worth noting that you need not even be an Australian citizen to be covered, you simply need to have users in Australia. Of course, whether Australia can enforce these laws against non-citizens is another matter. However, this legislation was specifically put together with co-operation of all members of the five eyes, so there's a reasonable possibility of extradition. The Department of Home Affairs even made a public statement confirming as much. It seems to have since been pulled from their website, but is available at: https://cryptome.org/2018/11/5-Eyes-Crypto.pdf https://cryptome.org/2018/11/5-Eyes-Crypto.pdf Five Eyes just wanted this legislation pushed through somewhere and targeted Australia because we: - lack a bill of rights - are constantly distracted by politicians backstabbing each other, and - there's a strong 'think of the children' sentiment in Australia that can be (and has been) used to push through all sorts of egregious bills.
- blotter_paper 8y ago>However, this legislation was specifically put together with co-operation of all members of the five eyes, so there's a reasonable possibility of extradition. The Department of Home Affairs even made a public statement confirming as much. It seems to have since been pulled from their website, but is available at: [PDF link] I read the PDF and didn't notice any mention of extradition. Am I missing something?
- Benjamin_Dobell 8y agoSorry for the ambiguity. The reference I provided was with regard to the fact the Australian Government has collaborated with other five eyes countries with this legislation, or at least the 'need' for this legislation. This is why I simply wrote there's a reasonable possibility of extradition, rather than anything definite.
- blotter_paper 8y agoAh, gotcha. Thanks for the clarification.
- bigiain 8y agoYou are making the incorrect assumption that the people writing these laws are not idiots. They don't understand the technology. They don't listen to any of the people who advise them about this technology. They seem only to be listening to the police and other law enforcement crying about "paedophiles and terrorists GOING DARK". The Prime Minister at the time claimed the laws of Australia overrode the laws of mathematics. Seriously.
- j16sdiz 8y agoThey don't understand technology. But they know law -- and how to abuse them.
- chii 8y agoTHe law provides a specific provision to say that there are limitations to what the assistance can be: > 317ZG Designated communications provider must not be required > to implement or build a systemic weakness or systemic > vulnerability etc. But the issue here is whether it's possible to perform the required "assistance" but not introduce systemic weakness or systemic vulnerability. I think it's a logical contradiction, so the law is pretty damn stupid...
- shakna 8y agoSystemic weakness or systemic vulnerability is redefined to not include anything that the notice can require however, rendering that particular exception pointless. > systemic vulnerability means a vulnerability that affects a whole class of technology, but does not include a vulnerability that is selectively introduced to one or more target technologies that are connected with a particular person. For this purpose, it is immaterial whether the person can be identified. The words "systemic weakness" means something completely different to how the industry would use it.
- bigiain 8y ago"We don't need you to introduce a Systemic Weakness into the whole class of 'electronics', we just need you to selectively target the specific class 'mobile phones' that are connected to John Doe 3 aka bogey-man-de-jour." This is now request that your lawyer would happily bill by the hour arguing with their lawyers in front of a judge - to determine whether it's a correct and enforceable interpretation of that shittily written legislation. Except you aren't allowed to tell your lawyer we asked you to do it.