4 ms·
The U.S. actually goes a step further... the only rights the constitution actually spells out are the rights of government. Most encroachments have been under
by tracker1 8y ago
The U.S. actually goes a step further... the only rights the constitution actually spells out are the rights of government. Most encroachments have been under the guise of "interstate commerce" or "taxation" in general...
> The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
As to the bill of rights, so long as the police are armed and can act with impunity... imho, the populace should be able to be armed. I don't personally own a firearm... I also don't spew racist rhetoric. I am a strong believer in all civil rights.
- Sabinus 8y agoMaybe if the police in America wasn't armed to the teeth and scared of being blown away by armed populace they wouldn't act like they do. For a country who keeps guns to hold governments accountable, your government is just a unaccountable as everyone else; if not more so.
- 12298765 8y agoWe've also been around for longer than anyone else with a modern democracy, and our goal is longevity of a sustainable relationship between the people and their government. We have some issues in our country right now, but I have a good feeling we'll get them worked out in the next few years. Many of our laws and rights are in place not for short term feelings about safety between people and police, but for long term safety of the people from a tyrannical government. And that tyrannical government might take hundreds of years to begin to form in a democracy... But the bill of rights and ability of the people to feel secure without their government's support, keeps the government from getting too power-hungry or separating too far from the will of the people.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> We've also been around for longer than anyone else with a modern democracy No, we haven't. In fact, we copied it largely from the UK. (We didn't like the fact that as a colony we didn't get representation in the national legislature or the full range of rights citizens in the UK itself had, but, hey, the US does the same thing. Initially, and still partially, even to it's capital district. We've got the oldest surviving written Constitution, sure, but that's a different issue.
- why_only_15 8y agoThe US has a very different system in a lot of ways. The UK doesn't have a formal constitution, its executive is subject to the legislature in a way it isn't in the US, one house, etc. The UK is a parliamentary democracy and the US is a republic. Also, the UK wasn't a democracy in any meaningful sense in 1776. The History Of Parliament Online is a very useful resource (https://www.historyofparliamentonline.org/research/constituencies/constituencies-1754-1790 https://www.historyofparliamentonline.org/research/constitue...). Out of some 6 million people in 1776 that lived in Britain, approximately 100,000 had the right to vote, most of which were in a small segment (i.e. the ability to vote was highly geographically concentrated).
- wahern 8y ago> Also, the UK wasn't a democracy in any meaningful sense in 1776 And the U.S. was? Much like the UK, the franchise was reserved to a subset of land freeholders. Only about 10-20% of the US population was eligible to vote. (http://www.crf-usa.org/bill-of-rights-in-action/bria-8-1-b-who-voted-in-early-america http://www.crf-usa.org/bill-of-rights-in-action/bria-8-1-b-w...) The UK did and still does have a written constitution, it's just not entirely written, and what's written is spread across multiple documents--the Magna Carta being one of the obvious ones. The US is not that different. Much of the US Constitution, especially the Bill of Rights, was copied verbatim from the written parts of the English constitution. And even conservative American jurists who reject Substantive Due Process regularly recognize unwritten constitutional rules and norms, especially those deriving from English constitutional norms. Aside from federalism (where states maintained some sovereignty), the most fundamental constitutional differences between the US and the UK relate to judicial review and parliamentary supremacy. But it didn't become clear until 1803 in Marbury v. Madison that the US would follow a different path. If Congress was the final arbiter of legislative constitutionality (as many believed in 1789, and some conservatives argue to this day), there would be little if any functional difference between the US and UK constitutional systems. Indeed, now that US Senators are directly elected, but for Marbury v Madison even federalism would be little different than UK's so-called devolution. Japan nominally has judicial review, but their supreme court has zero inclination to strike down legislation so in practice the Japanese legislature has similar constitutional powers as the UK parliament.
- tracker1 8y agoThe police weren't armed like today back in the 1950's, and guess what, individuals had MORE guns as a general population. The militarization of the police, less training, less acting as part of the communities they serve, etc. It's about conflict of personality and very little to do with real danger.
- CobrastanJorji 8y agoYeah, but the problem is that the Constitution says that you can't infringe on the right to bear arms, and telling me that I can't have a mutated anthrax grenade is, technically, infringing on my right to bear arms. The only reason we're still alive is that lawyers don't parse words in the way that engineers do.
- mirimir 8y agoHey, years ago I took a firearms safety class. The instructor joked that the Second Amendment ought to include tactical nukes ;)
- kdtsh 8y agoAustralia’s constitution doesn’t quite operate in the same way, but the Australian federal government’s powers are enumerated in the constitution much like in the US constitution - as you say, governments are given positive rights by the constitution, and restricted in their power in other areas.