12 ms·
Office Depot computer scans gave fake results
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cazum 8y agoHow likely do you think it is that the settlement amount is less than the money made running this scam?
- mttjj 8y agoWell the article said that customers were charged ‘up to $300’. Let’s be conservative and say customers were charged $150 on average. $35 million/$150 = 233,333. So the question is, did they scam more than 233,333 people? I’d bet so.
- sahin-boydas 8y agoexactly.
- binarymax 8y agoI wonder if you can FOIA to get the actual numbers, or the estimates of the numbers for how the FTC arrived at $15M
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThe question is what percent of total scams were caught and fined, since for the people committing them, it’s a total fines / total profit across all scams calculation. Additionally, the fines come out of company money, and presumably, executives have a network to fall back on so losing their job isn’t likely an issue.
- ams6110 8y agoSears automotive service all over again.
- differentView 8y agoWhat did they do?
- ams6110 8y agoUnnecessary repairs. https://www.nytimes.com/1992/06/12/business/accusation-of-fraud-at-sears.html https://www.nytimes.com/1992/06/12/business/accusation-of-fr...
- spectramax 8y agoOffice Depot, Staples, Office Max : These stores need to die. I’ve never felt worse by stepping into these stores without some clerk coming up to me about up selling this kind a bullshit. They’re old relics that need to die like Sears did. They’re not innovating, they’re getting desperate as we’ve seen RadioShack in early 2000’s leading up to its bankruptcy in 2015. Furthermore, they pay poorly to their employees, and there is a whole bunch of toxicity in there. Best Buy was on its way on the same path but they’ve saved themselves by a narrow margin. I still despise their “Geek Squad”. They take advantage of uninformed consumers and it’s sleezy. It makes me angry just thinking about it. The leaders and executives that run these businesses are completely and utterly out of touch with their core business values, innovation and having a vision for the company. Spineless bozos.
- mttjj 8y agoThe only reason I've had to step foot in an Office Depot in the last 5 years is to drop off shipments. It's the closest FedEx and USPS drop-off location to me. Even then, I always try to have my items boxed and labelled before I go in so all I have to do is drop them off. I make a beeline for the back of the store, leave my items with the person, and politely say I don't need a drop-off receipt. Then I book it back to the front of the store and get the hell out.
- covercash 8y agoThat’s precisely the situation where I’d want a drop-off receipt just in case my package goes missing or magically opens itself.
- rhizome 8y agoThey should have their corporate charters (or other enabling paperwork) dissolved.
- Apocryphon 8y agoFraudulent tech support aside, people still need to buy office supplies. Unless their markups are horrible I don’t see why they shouldn’t exist for that.
- mabbo 8y agoI don't understand this... If I as an individual did the same actions, I would be charged with fraud. I might even serve time in prison for it. In this company, someone up the chain of command knew they were doing this. Someone at some point was presented with "we'll give them fake scan results to upsell our services" and said "yes". Why is that person not being charged with fraud, just like I would have been? What makes it just a fine and a slap in the wrist just because they're a big company?
- fabianhjr 8y ago> What makes it just a fine and a slap in the wrist just because they're a big company? Yes ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CsplLiZHbj0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CsplLiZHbj0 )
- jdsully 8y agoI initially avoided that Dirty Money series because I thought it was going to be just another surface level rage bait documentary - like so many "finance" documentaries have been since the great recession. But it was very well done and had high information content. I wasn't surprised to learn it was from the same director as The Smartest Guys in the Room (Enron Documentary). Bethany McLean even makes an appearance.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ada1981 8y agoCEOs don’t go to jail.
- jjeaff 8y agoTell that to Jeff Skilling, Bernie Madoff, Martin Shkreli, Denis Kazlowski, Martha Stewart, Joseph Naccio, John Rita's, Sanjay Kumar, Sam Waksal, Marty Grass... the list goes on and on.
- microdrum 8y agoIt seems absolutely insane that the FTC is going after Office Depot for this. . . .and not $100B+ illegal collusory and monopolistic activity of Google’s Doubleclick server, AdWords sales, and AdExchange intermediation businesses. It’s like the FTC has time traveled to 2019 from 1959. This can’t go on forever.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 55555 8y agoJudging from the downvotes you need to be more clear why you believe their activity (which specifically?) is illegal and monopolistic
- microdrum 8y agoJudging from the downvotes there are a lot of Googlers and Xooglers here. That’s all. Here is one place to start: https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/a-serf-on-googles-farm https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/a-serf-on-googles-farm
- mikestew 8y agoJudging from the downvotes, one might do well to learn the concept of “on topic”. I don’t give a shit about Google, but whataboutism is a sure fire way to earn some down arrows.
- ims 8y agoThe actual complaint: https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/cases/office_depot_complaint_3-27-19.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/cases/office_depo...
- _cerv 8y agoAHAHAHAHA! About time. One of my first tech jobs was with Office Depot, where I was hired on as the technology lead, thinking that I was going to be sharing my 2008 era knowledge. I still remember feeling excited and sharing with the store my first laptop sale, explaining how I was able to sell a Windows Vista Basic machine with a copy of Windows XP and a stick of memory. My boss was quick to tell me that they don't make any money on that stuff and selling high end items with the amount of time that I spent doing that sale was actually hurting the store. So I could either lose my job or sell extended warranties and services, and earn 5-10 dollars a sale. I was 20 years old, wanted a new iPhone, and was living with my parents, so my path was pretty clear. At Office Depot, we had two kinds of warranties, either a "Kit" or a stand alone warranties. With services, we had the "make your computer faster" and "so you just bought this pos, lets make it faster". With warranties, I went straight for the scare tactics, such as your printer ink cartridges could leak all over over or the new chair you bought could have a castor leak grease, both of these were not covered under the normal warranty, but for 25-100 dollars, you could be protected from the unpredictable. With services, we just put your new computer on a cabinet where we ran a flash program that showed "vulnerabilities", and for 100 dollars, we could patch up this machine that would have been hacked to shreds by the Chinese if it were not for us brave souls. I made two grand that month and was given an award by the Office Depot district manager. I felt like shit too. I was able to get my conscience back after helping people under the table when they bought one of our bullshit comfort blankets and wouldn't anything other than the shredder kit - which included a bottle of literal synthetic snake oil.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoThanks for sharing that story. Although I'm a little surprised that you eased your conscience by (IIUC) committing tax fraud.
- _cerv 8y agoIt was all for free.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y ago
- chrischen 8y agoA lot of big brands launder their shady services through secondary service providers, or indirectly profit off of shady third party service providers.
- cazum 8y agoYep. I worked at a toys r us in high school, and can say that selling toys was a secondary priority. A sales associates main purpose was to sell extended warranties offered through some bullshit 3rd party. I don't know how prevalent this was, but I was trained to lie to customers in order to sell them. I was told the warranty would cover any damage to products at all, and 5 months in I finally read the fine print and realized I'd been used to scam hundreds of people. Quit shortly after.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoThe same can be said of many online service companies who use outside expertise to do the actual work and mark up their services to cover the cost and essentially profit for by talking to the customer. Welcome to the real world.
- ipsin 8y agoI feel that the FTC's story leaves a few things to be desired. Here's a timeline: 1) Circa 2009, scammy "PC Diagnosis" scam starts. 2) Feb 2012, class action filed against Support.com for scareware up-selling a subscription service. [1] 3) Nov 2016, two TV affiliates run similar tests finding they're ripping off customers. [2] 4) Nov 2016, Office Depot discontinues the scam. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Support.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Support.com [2] https://www.pcmag.com/news/349821/office-depot-caught-selling-fixes-for-non-existent-pc-prob https://www.pcmag.com/news/349821/office-depot-caught-sellin... I feel like this could use a postmortem more than what feels like a congratulatory press release. I'd be curious to know if there were complaints filed with the FTC prior to November 2016.
- Annatar 8y agoWelcome to running Windows on your computer. What a steaming pile of garbage software is that companies can defraud people like this.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI'm not a Windows user, but pretending that retailers aren't also ripping off Mac users using similar tactics is just dishonest.
- Forbo 8y agoA big selling point of this scam is the "tune-up" to disable the loads of bundled crapware that comes preinstalled from OEMs. How much bundled crapware comes preloaded in a Mac?
- brokenmachine 8y agoitunes?
- Annatar 8y agoNot funny.
- brokenmachine 8y agoYes, it's just sad.
- Annatar 8y agoNo it isn't. You're just bashing itunes because you believe it's good to bash Apple Computer. That's just dumb, not to mention a huge waste of time, time which you will never get back.
- 8y ago
- anonu 8y agoThis is similar to the VW emissions scandal in reverse.
- kbos87 8y agoThis brings to mind Home Depot's free "water tests" hanging at the entry to every store, emblazoned with the Home Depot logo. Free water test! Make sure what your family drinks and bathes in and cooks with is safe! they say. The reality is that everyone gets an urgent call from a sales rep about some vague characteristics of your water that urgently need to be corrected by one of their $7,000 water softening systems that nobody actually needs. The salespeople are relentless, they call daily, and insist on finding a time when "both spouses" will be home to listen to their pitch. I haven't been subjected to that but I'm sure it doubles their chances of one person caving to their high pressure sales tactics. When I first came across this, I was stunned that a big name retailer with a lot to lose would do something so shady and unethical. I wonder if they even actually do test the water and would notice or tell you if it was actually loaded with lead or something else.
- acheron 8y agoI have never noticed that, but yeah that sounds sketchy. (Relevant to your post, if you actually want a water test (in the US), check with your state's cooperative extension -- they probably offer something unlikely to be associated with salesmen, e.g. Virginia: https://ext.vt.edu/food-health/home-water-quality.html https://ext.vt.edu/food-health/home-water-quality.html )
- turc1656 8y ago"Many of us would gladly take advantage of a free computer tune-up from a big-name retailer. We wouldn’t suspect the tune-up might be a tech support scam." Funny, that's precisely what I would suspect it was.
- jawns 8y agoCan anybody speak to why some of these "deceptive claims" settlements end up as a settlement with the FTC, which collects and disperses the funds in the form of refunds, while others end up as a class action settlement, where some private party sues on behalf of a class? In a standard class action lawsuit, the lawyers for the plaintiff (if successful) get a pretty nice cut of the settlement, and the remainder is dispersed to class members. But if the settlement is with the FTC, does it get its own cut, or does the entire settlement amount go out to class members?
- sizzzzlerz 8y agoIs there a polite way to call them scum-sucking bastards?
- notme77 8y agoYes. "Y'all are scum-sucking bastards."
- busterarm 8y agoI used to work for Support.com in a senior technical role during part this window of time, but not directly on the Office Depot tenant. Support.com followed similar practices of other scanning software like MBAM (MalwareBytes) and SAS (Super Anti Spyware) at the time. In fact, Support.com acquired Super Anti Spyware. The big problems were: a) their staff is incredibly poorly trained, mostly because they barely pay above minimum wage to these workers, their training barely covers more than the UI of their tools and they're pushed on resolution time. These workers don't have much skill and don't have much reason to care. They basically don't know the difference between spyware/adware and infections. b) Office Depot was upselling this on brand new computers which are bundled with loads of adware. Effectively they were telling customers that their brand new computers were infected. Support.com is an incredibly stupid company who repeatedly hired their business development people from failed companies (ex-Radio Shack, CompUSA and Circuit City hires were the rule, not the exception). That said, they weren't the only bad actor here. Also, nobody should be surprised that this company was founded by Mark Pincus of Zynga fame.