4 ms·
This is why I don't really like poker. There's just too much variance. Unless you play again and again and again there's not much correlation between skill and
by IshKebab 8y ago
This is why I don't really like poker. There's just too much variance. Unless you play again and again and again there's not much correlation between skill and the winner.
I think it's why people also believe there is "beginners' luck" - there isn't really - the entire game has tons of luck. But when confronted with someone who clearly isn't skilled but wins anyway, poker fans really don't want to face the reality that the game is mostly luck.
Another issue with poker - at least Texas Hold'em - is that the best strategy is folding 90% of the time, which is just boring.
I'm sure there are much better bluffing games.
- trevyn 8y ago>when confronted with someone who clearly isn't skilled but wins anyway That’s what keeps the fish around!
- shorsher 8y agoI would disagree with the blanket statement that folding 90% of the time is optimal, and can be discouraging to new players who are interested in learning poker. Good players generally play around 20% of their hands, but even that vastly changes based on how aggressive the player is. Also, there is much more to factor in than just the hand you are dealt. You might want to play a tighter range (play less percentage of hands) in early position (let's say first or second to act in a betting round), compared to being last to act (where you might want to play a higher percentage of your hands). This is because being last to act in each betting round extremely useful in poker (If you want to know why, there's a lots of great articles on the internet who could explain much better than I [1]). [1] - https://www.tightpoker.com/position.html https://www.tightpoker.com/position.html
- btilly 8y agoNot optimal in all situations. But if you're playing with a full table of weak/loose players, it is good to play even tighter than that. Only play a high pocket pair or AK, and play them aggressively. Your hope being to take people 1 vs 1 for all the money you can. You don't need to be any cleverer than that until people pay enough attention that they won't call you unless they think that they have you beat. Then you will have to go for a wider range and start to play a better strategy.
- shorsher 8y agoRight, totally agree with you. Very situational and dependent on the skill level of others, whether you need to play GTO or not, tournament vs cash, how deep you are in a tournament, how many BB you have left, etc.
- jdietrich 8y agoEven that is highly dependent on your post-flop skill. Marginal hands and drawing hands like small pairs and small suited connectors can be highly profitable on loose tables if you're confident in your reading ability. Playing like a nit is the easiest way to play profitably on a loose table and has dramatically lower variance, but widening your range and playing intelligently post-flop can often be substantially more profitable.
- base698 8y agoI used to be profitable in the golden days being a nit and just letting the huge swaths of players pay me off. So many all-ins to bluff me off while holding top set, nut straight, or nut flush. Just recently got back playing and am trying to learn to play against real players. I'm down overall after about 50 hours of play, but not very much. Any advice?
- shorsher 8y agoOne book that I have really really enjoyed that is somewhat recent (2016) is The Grinders Manual [1]. It gives fantastic advice that is still relevant and is extremely readable. Covers a wide range of topics and came widely recommended to me. It’s helped my game a lot as I just started playing seriously about 5 months ago. It’s geared toward online cash playing, but I ignore most of the HUD stuff and can use all the concepts in my live games. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Grinders-Manual-Complete-Course-Online-ebook/dp/B01GBFF890 https://www.amazon.com/Grinders-Manual-Complete-Course-Onlin...
- dbancajas 8y agowhat's your VPIP and 3B%? and what stakes do you hangout usually?
- QuotedForTruth 8y agoThe variance is also what allows poker to thrive and pro players to have an income though. Since poker is zero sum (really negative because of the casino's take) there has to be a steady supply of losing money playing. That means bad players have to believe they have a shot. If they never or very rarely won against higher skilled players, they'd dry up. Imagine casinos that had cash chess tables or basketball courts. Would you have enough dead money willing to risk playing? I'd wager no. You'd get occasional fish willing to try but they'd get dunked on and go home. Without enough new money, the game would dry up as the best players and the casino accumulate all the rest.
- btilly 8y agoAnd this is why every card room has Texas Hold'em but you have to search for Omaha High/Lo. (Skill has a lot bigger edge in Omaha.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- travisjungroth 8y agoNow I want to see $200 buy-in basketball tournaments.
- dbancajas 8y agothe term you are looking for is a donkey or a fish. A fish that has a lot of money is called a "whale". Back at pokerstars I was always amazed by some unknown out of a middle eastern country (UAE or SA) -- this is when they still display your country -- and they'd be playing with the pros 100/200$ blinds. I always thought, are they good or too much oil money?
- rahulrrixe 8y agoThis is true for newbie investor after reading a book and investing in Wall-Street. They almost always lose the money and again Wall Street releases a new easy book on investing. I find a huge co-relation between how poker and wall street is aligned.
- empath75 8y ago> Unless you play again and again and again there's not much correlation between skill and the winner. Depends how closely matched people are. Last few times I've played games with friends/family who aren't poker players, I literally took all the money and I'm just using poker 101 strategy. The skill is all in getting people to play with you more than once :( And if you ever watch casino games -- it's just a constant money spigot from fish to sharks.
- rhcom2 8y ago> Another issue with poker - at least Texas Hold'em - is that the best strategy is folding 90% of the time, which is just boring. That's what I always appreciated about professional poker players. Their patience and their emotional regulation. Both of which made me terrible at the game.
- bena 8y agoOddly enough it's a good way to learn both. Or at least putting cash on the line gives you the incentive to do so. Another game I like recommending is Fluxx. It teaches you how to lose. The game is very chaotic and there are things that can happen which cause you to just lose. Or just win. There is some amount of skill involved, but you can be forced in a situation where you cause someone else to win randomly. You learn to divorce your efforts from the immediate results and to accept loss and move on. Partly because the games are pretty quick.
- splonk 8y ago"emotional regulation" is not exactly a term I would use to describe the majority of professional poker players, although I think it is more prevalent within the better ones. Patience and discipline are probably present within anyone who manages to survive as a pro for more than a couple years, but it's not a guarantee. There's a reason the term "degen" (for degenerate) gets thrown around so much in gambling circles. I've played thousands of hours against mid/high/nosebleed stakes pros who've played many more thousands of hours of poker than I ever will, and it's always a surprise how many of them are children throwing a temper tantrum whenever they lose any hand where they were a favorite. (This includes multiple people who each have multiple WSOP bracelets.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jandrese 8y agoBeginners luck is notable because most of the time unskilled players get bled dry very quickly. When a beginner makes all of the rookie mistakes but still wins out of sheer dumb luck then people take note. But then as you note the skill cap isn't very high. Once everyone figures out the strategy it goes back to being mostly luck and who has the biggest bank account to ride out the bad times.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- friedman23 8y ago>who clearly isn't skilled but wins anyway, poker fans really don't want to face the reality that the game is mostly luck. A game of poker is not one hand of poker. It is typical in poker games to be all in and have a 70% chance of winning. If you are playing a bad player and you go all in 5 times against this person with a 70% chance of winning is there any luck involved? To me it looks more like printing money. >Another issue with poker - at least Texas Hold'em - is that the best strategy is folding 90% of the time, which is just boring. You should not be folding 90% of the time.