8 ms·
What's weird to me is: Europe isn't exactly a content powerhouse. Why are they so concerned with copyright protections?
by onlyrealcuzzo 8y ago
What's weird to me is: Europe isn't exactly a content powerhouse. Why are they so concerned with copyright protections?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- apexalpha 8y agoA lot of European media sees their content stolen and re-uploaded by anonymous users on YT, FB, etc... FB in particular have not responded to this and thus content creators lose a lot of views and money. This video sums it up nicely: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7tA3NNKF0Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7tA3NNKF0Q
- luiscleto 8y agoHowever, the fact that there is a problem, does not legitimize doing something regardless of what the something is. I haven't seen any support for the articles which actually shows the effects of the policy will be good, rather than arguments saying "it's meant to be good". Which is a fallacy that affects many politics which later end up having adverse effects. But ultimately bureaucrats are happy whenever there is an excuse to increase bureaucratic power. Edit: spelling Further edit: For the particular point you're putting out, to justify the EU policy you have to at least show that 1) those media outlets would receive all that traffic that those FB posts generated if the FB posts didn't exist in the first place, 2) that this outweighs costs from abusing that policy (claims over fair use, e.g. youtube copyright system) and content that simply will not get reshared, even if fair use and linking to the source material, out of fear of triggering the safeguards mechanism
- apexalpha 8y agoOh I agree that this law is shit, and a huge overreach. Like shooting a mosquito with a cannon. I was just trying to put in perspective WHY the politicians feel the need to do this. It's mostly backlash against Facebook for years of content stealing. Youtube and itś content ID system are actually what this law wants to introduce everywhere. While not perfect, it's still better than Facebook, which seems to be lawless on copyright.
- c3o 8y agoI work at the European Parliament, and in 3 years of debate about the law not a single person or organisation has brought up people putting content from other platforms on FB as something that this supposedly addresses. In fact, it's all about the music industry wanting higher licensing payments from YouTube: At least as much per play as e.g. Apple Music pays. They call the fact that they're not getting that today the "value gap" – THAT'S the undisputed reason/justification for this law (just google the term). (Facebook, by the way, also has a content filter: https://www.facebook.com/help/publisher/330407020882707 https://www.facebook.com/help/publisher/330407020882707)
- pbhjpbhj 8y ago>and thus content creators lose a lot of views and money // I think this sort of reasoning is largely fallacious. Just because people view your stuff doesn't mean that if you're successful in locking it down that they'll then pay to view it. I feel the media companies know this and that's one reason they demand ever increasing copyright terms - to avoid older content eating in to current profits.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoJust to add: Just because people view your stuff for free doesn't mean that won't entice them to pay for it later, or that they haven't already paid for it.
- apexalpha 8y agoThis isn't even about paying. People viewing videos you made on Youtube is already lost revenue, since none of the ads FB shows go to you. They only go to the person who stole your videos. And be definition this can be seen as a loss since the viewing itself is the revenue generator.
- Natanael_L 8y agoThis isn't even true with the copyright claim system, where the claimant gets all profits from youtube even if their content was only featured for 5 seconds in a 30 minute video.
- koonsolo 8y agoBecause politicians are stupid. If you look at the pros and cons of this law, Europe has nothing to gain. Not for the people, not for the companies. This is a law that works to mainly serve the big copyright holders, and in a second degree, impacts the big tech multinationals (=read US companies) less than the smaller ones. It makes no sense at all. Especially since all member states will have their own law. "Does our filter comply with Belgium law? Also with Luxemburg? And what about Slovenia?". It's a big farce, that can only be approved by total morons that don't even bother to listen to people who actually know what they're talking about.
- ABCLAW 8y agoThis isn't a law that serves multinationals; quite the opposite. The proportionality requirement in the text of Art. 13 is more onerous to larger corporations. If you're a tiny blog with a banner ad or two, you're not getting slapped off the internet for having a comments field, because it isn't proportional to require cost and complexity increases of multiple orders of magnitude to police your comments section. Unless someone comes up with Compliance.ly & Co. which does the work for you at a price-point that is reasonable, in which case we've just opened up a new industry which hopefully results in Content ID going the way of the Dodo. After some litigation occurs in which the boundaries of proportionality are set, we'll be in a better position to analyze the impact of this law.
- fhrow4484 8y agoWhen reading comments like this it feels like: there's no ambitious startup in Europe to become one of the large companies. Because now a startup has less than 3 years to add this content filtering, which provided as a service or not, is going to cost €€€. Do you think Spotify would be able to grow if it was created on March 27 2019 instead of 2008? A successful Content filtering as a service (compliance.ly & co. In your example), assuming it gets adopted by all major websites, seems like it would shift the problem to an even bigger gatekeeper than YouTube, how is this a good thing?
- ABCLAW 8y ago
- majewsky 8y ago> Why are [European politicians] so concerned with copyright protections? It's election year. Since the big publishers are all for the reform, any politicians opposing it must fear for bad press.
- mcv 8y agoBig publishers aren't the only ones who can generate bad press. We need to make sure that nobody who voted for this gets re-elected.
- tzs 8y agoIt might have something to do with their concern for privacy protections. Strengthening privacy protection makes the most popular model for sites to pay for content creation and operating costs--selling information about their visitors to advertisers--much less effective. Maybe as part of that they want to make it more viable for sites to switch to a direct selling of content model?
- mrep 8y agoThis is what I think it is. News websites want to turn to paywalls now that GDPR is going to decimate targeted advertising once the lawsuits start coming down but to do that, they need to 1: prevent any free news websites from linking to their pay-walled website and paraphrasing/quoting the whole thing (most people won't pay for the original news source when they can read practically the same thing from a free website). Article 11 prevents this without compensation to the original source. 2: prevent any single user who has access to the pay-walled website from posting the entire article onto websites like hacker news and reddit which I see happen all the time (that and outline/archive links). Article 13 prevents this with automated filters that if fail, the news website can just sue the website and get compensated that way.
- gutnor 8y agoIt does not matter where the content is produced, it is where it is consumed and Europe is a content consumption powerhouse. This law intent is to prevent unlicensed content to be available to European consumer. That will probably mostly work, with the usual caveat and unintended consequences we all know about, here on HN.
- fnord123 8y ago>Why are they so concerned with copyright protections? Is the way this legislation got through because of nasty lobbying? What if it was brought in to stem the tide of American tech companies destroying more European businesses by hiding taxes and dodging copyrights. >Europe isn't exactly a content powerhouse. Europe has plenty of 'content powerhouse' companies. They just don't wear their nationality on their chest when they sell to the US.
- Natanael_L 8y agoThey can have the best intentions in the world, but shooting yourself in the foot is never a good idea even if the intention is to kill the insect nest below your feet.
- C14L 8y agoThe causality goes the other way, I believe We are no content powerhouse precisely because we are so concerned about all these bureaucratic things. Instead of just distributing better content more efficiently, we prefer to make it illegal to be better than the status quo. Can't speak for all of Europe, but Internet-related legislation here in Germany has been a disaster since the mid-1990s.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoWhich is especially interesting. Germany has probably the most investment in tech, and it has a very small movie industry, a nearly non-existent music industry, and hardly any internationally known writers. Germany also probably has the strongest tech industry in Europe. Or at least as strong as France and the UK, it seems.
- eloisant 8y agoIt's easier for copyright owners in Europe to pain themselves to politicians as small and weak, needing protection from laws to avoid being eaten by the US giants
- gabbygab 8y agoThat may or may not be true, but Europe is more of a content powerhouse than a internet/tech powerhouse. Their content is a bigger money maker than their tech. So it is in their interest to punish tech and protect tech. It's also why China has such lax IP laws. They are more of a manufacturing powerhouse than an IP powerhouse ( for now at least ) so they have little to gain with stringent IP laws. When their IP portfolio increases, you can bet that their government would be all about IP protection. And going back even further, we had some of the laxest IP laws in the western world during the 1800s because we had so little IP to protect. Which allowed our businesses to take a ton of IP from IP-rich britain and europe. It's greed and selfishness.
- scotty79 8y agoThis whole stupidity started when google refused to pay european newspapers for their articles showing up in google news. Google could have stopped all this be immediately kicking off all european newspapers from every google service they have and reinstating them only after they fill out and submit the form that they allow google to use their stuff without any pay. Instead google only threatened to do this and european newspapers thought they have some power. The only power they have is making and breaking european politicians, hence current mess.
- thirdsun 8y ago> Google could have stopped all this be immediately kicking off all european newspapers from every google service they have and reinstating them only after they fill out and submit the form that they allow google to use their stuff without any pay. They did exactly that when germany introduced the "Leistungsschutzrecht", which was pushed and lobbied for by all major german publishers. Needless to say they all agreed to offer their snippets for free when Google present them with their options.
- scotty79 8y agoI can't then imagine why on earth they think google or facebook will start paying them now.