4 ms·

Just wait until they eventually are greeted with a notice "Sorry, we've blocked all users from Europe due to the new copyright reform" on every major social med

Just wait until they eventually are greeted with a notice "Sorry, we've blocked all users from Europe due to the new copyright reform" on every major social media site/app.

phatfish 8y ago
I though this was supposed to happen after the GDPR was made law... still waiting.
- bashwizard 8y ago
  I didn't. I expected to be greeted with "We care about your privacy" and then have to opt in or not being able to access the content. I was right.
  - phatfish 8y ago
    Fair enough. Although I remember plenty of comments on HN about how Facebook et al. would be blocking EU users because it would be too expensive for them to comply with GDPR. One or two US based newspaper websites were all I noticed blocking access because of compliance reasons. I expect a similar impact due to Article 13.
    - kaitnieks 8y ago
      The big ones will be fine. They are already using filters. It's all the forums and such that have no way to implement the technology that the upcoming directive calls for, and they will have no choice but to block EU. Regarding news sites - usually it's the comments section that's the user created content, so I guess they could simply remove that for EU visitors, or, if that feels like a hassle, just block EU.
    - mann1x 8y ago
      Almost all US regional newspaper websites are blocking access from EU. Many other US sites as well but luckily most of them they just don't care to comply or enable geo fencing.
  - kaybe 8y ago
    I still see far too many sites which want me to opt out of 100+ trackers individually. I usually just leave. Thanks for hindering my procrastination habits I guess.
- philpem 8y ago
  There are an absolute mountain of US sites which block European IP addresses to avoid GDPR. Mostly news outlets. I've never seen so many 451 Unavailable For Legal Reasons errors in my life! Still others present a "subscription required" page if you connect from Europe, but display the content if you access them from the US (or through archive.is).
- Xelbair 8y ago
  It happened for few sites - mostly smaller American news sites, and strangely enough - cooking sites.
tutanchamun 8y ago
They should also show a picture of the one responsible for it: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dm9jfQ7XoAA4E5B.jpg:large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dm9jfQ7XoAA4E5B.jpg:large or even better, the animated original: https://twitter.com/Senficon/status/1040140221164281856 https://twitter.com/Senficon/status/1040140221164281856 Sadly neither will happen. The major social media sites and apps were too silent this time around. Back in 2012 when ACTA was voted on there was much more activity. Since Youtube and Facebook etc. already have filter mechanisms in place they probably want to profit from it by selling it as a SAAS to smaller companies that don't have the resources to implement their own filtering.

Just wait until they eventually are greeted with a notice "Sorry, we've blocked all users from Europe due to the new copyright reform" on every major social media site/app.

phatfish 8y ago

I though this was supposed to happen after the GDPR was made law... still waiting.

bashwizard 8y ago
I didn't. I expected to be greeted with "We care about your privacy" and then have to opt in or not being able to access the content. I was right.
- phatfish 8y ago
  Fair enough. Although I remember plenty of comments on HN about how Facebook et al. would be blocking EU users because it would be too expensive for them to comply with GDPR. One or two US based newspaper websites were all I noticed blocking access because of compliance reasons. I expect a similar impact due to Article 13.
  - kaitnieks 8y ago
    The big ones will be fine. They are already using filters. It's all the forums and such that have no way to implement the technology that the upcoming directive calls for, and they will have no choice but to block EU. Regarding news sites - usually it's the comments section that's the user created content, so I guess they could simply remove that for EU visitors, or, if that feels like a hassle, just block EU.
  - mann1x 8y ago
    Almost all US regional newspaper websites are blocking access from EU. Many other US sites as well but luckily most of them they just don't care to comply or enable geo fencing.
- kaybe 8y ago
  I still see far too many sites which want me to opt out of 100+ trackers individually. I usually just leave. Thanks for hindering my procrastination habits I guess.
philpem 8y ago
There are an absolute mountain of US sites which block European IP addresses to avoid GDPR. Mostly news outlets. I've never seen so many 451 Unavailable For Legal Reasons errors in my life! Still others present a "subscription required" page if you connect from Europe, but display the content if you access them from the US (or through archive.is).
Xelbair 8y ago
It happened for few sites - mostly smaller American news sites, and strangely enough - cooking sites.

tutanchamun 8y ago

They should also show a picture of the one responsible for it: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dm9jfQ7XoAA4E5B.jpg:large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dm9jfQ7XoAA4E5B.jpg:large or even better, the animated original: https://twitter.com/Senficon/status/1040140221164281856 https://twitter.com/Senficon/status/1040140221164281856 Sadly neither will happen. The major social media sites and apps were too silent this time around. Back in 2012 when ACTA was voted on there was much more activity. Since Youtube and Facebook etc. already have filter mechanisms in place they probably want to profit from it by selling it as a SAAS to smaller companies that don't have the resources to implement their own filtering.