6 ms·
I'm always amused by the indignation expressed by people when some nation other than their own is shown to be using their resources to to exert international in
by taneq 8y ago
I'm always amused by the indignation expressed by people when some nation other than their own is shown to be using their resources to to exert international influence. The British Empire did. The USSR did. The United States does. Of course China does too.
- mc32 8y agoRight but not all reflect the same principles. If you want to jump on the China principles bandwagon that’s your right, but you have to realize the principles allow for different outcomes, some more or less universal or inclusive or exclusive. Put another way, would you propose the US (or Europe) adopt Chinese styled principles and use their influence to project them? Would that be a good thing?
- tremon 8y agoThe British' principles gave us the Kashmir/Pakistani conflict, and (coupled with France and various other European nations) numerous civil wars across Africa. The US' principles gave us decades of corruption and drug trade in South America. The USSR's principles gave us the iron curtain, and the Afghan and Czechen rebellions. I'm sure there's nuances all around, but let's not pretend the previous perpetrators were a shining beacon of morality.
- mc32 8y agoIt’s the potential the principles offer, the language they engender. Without these principles some ideas remain infertil.
- defertoreptar 8y agoAnd what, we shouldn't care because of that?
- happytoexplain 8y agoI can't even begin to relate to this point of view. Why does everything have to be side-taking, where nobody is allowed to be accused of anything if somebody else, now or in the past, has committed even just the same genre of crime? And why the smug "amused" line? To me, it's all terribly demoralizing.
- DCKing 8y agoContrarian viewpoints (i.e. "this is actually different", "this is actually not surprising") are very popular on Hacker News and upvote based internet fora. Many times they are actually low value, especially when they are not even particularly responding to a surprise in the original article, but to a surprise the poster initially had or an expected surprise the general audience should have. You can have a discussion on whether this is a good thing or not, but being smug about how "we knew better all along" is very low value. The best comments I feel shouldn't be about the type of response you should have to the article, it should be about the contents of the article. Yet comments like these trigger something in people to upvote it anyway.
- coldtea 8y ago>I can't even begin to relate to this point of view. Why does everything have to be side-taking, where nobody is allowed to be accused of anything if somebody else, now or in the past, has committed even just the same genre of crime? Because when you criticize one side, you are side-taking. And everything you say or write is used to justify global politics (and is primed to do just that). There's no "impartiality" when you single out one side to criticize. Either put it in context, or make a statement criticizing all parties doing the same. It's not really difficult to study and learn about things, and put them in perspective, instead of singling out a party as some unique "evil". And it is doubly insulting to countries and peoples who have suffered your version of doing the same thing to see you point out others and demand their heads for it. It's adding hypocrisy to injury. >To me, it's all terribly demoralizing. To me people making accusations only for others, and neglecting their side's serious complicity in the same thing, is not only terribly demoralizing, not only hypocritical, but also strategic. The 60s anti-culture movement could simultaneously criticize USSR, the Prague invasion, etc AND Uncle Sam and Vietnam. Not just in their media, even in a single song oftentimes. Now it's 1000 articles criticizing one side as uniquely evil with not even a whisper of own actions, and 10 giving the internal perspective. Not exactly balanced (talking about foreign politics here. In internal politics, I guess it's more like "Hurray for the democrats/republicans establishment ideas, down with Trump" what passes for criticism of both democrat/republicans and Trump). (And anybody attempting to correct that is hit with the thought-stopping accusation of "whataboutism")
- kuzehanka 8y agoThe Confucius Institute program trains its agents to engage in whataboutism exactly like this when China's expansionism or other questionable practices are called into question. Seeing this favoured Chinese propaganda tactic as the topmost comment on an intelligent discussion forum is terrifying. I'm not accusing parent of being related, but this line of argument is clearly a fallacy and doesn't at all detract from the issues being raised. The endstate of this whataboutism is a reduction to the absurd, like 'the Germans ran ethnic concentration camps, so why can't we?'[1] [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-45474279 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-45474279 https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2018/12/10/commentary/world-commentary/new-zealand-grapples-chinas-influence-intimidation/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2018/12/10/commentary/w... https://www.reddit.com/r/China/comments/7vc4jh/the_funny_thing_about_whataboutism/ https://www.reddit.com/r/China/comments/7vc4jh/the_funny_thi... http://theconversation.com/why-the-nsw-government-is-reviewing-its-confucius-classrooms-program-96783 http://theconversation.com/why-the-nsw-government-is-reviewi...
- IntelAMDVia 8y agoTo be clear, the Confucius Institute is aimed at teaching students in its hosted nation certain propaganda. Products of the domestic China censored education system also use a lot of whataboutism. The bigger problem is the fact this submission was censored from the front page as soon as it started to gain traction. Sam Altman's China strategy would appear to include censorship of Hacker News.
- dang 8y agoThe submission was flagged by users. Moderators downweighted it the way we downweight all sensationalist flamewar articles (if we didn't, they would always be all the top stories on HN). But it is the user flags that buried it. Articles and sites like this one are off topic for Hacker News. We're looking for articles that gratify intellectual curiosity, not ones that gin up flamewars, let alone nationalistic flamewars. Submissions to Hacker News need to be much, much more substantive than this—most of all on divisive topics. This is obviously a single-agenda, highly politicized site; we ban all of those, regardless of their politics. We also ban accounts that only use HN to promote their own site (https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=subsonico https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=subsonico). Indeed, on second look, it's clear that this account and this site have simply been spamming HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18381256 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18381256, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17834767 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17834767. We should have caught that a long time ago. (Edit: and even the current article turns out to be blogspam from another source.) We don't moderate stories about China differently than any others. HN moderation standards are consistent to the point of tedium. There is inconsistency in practice, but only because of the quantity of material that appears here—way more than we could ever hope to read or even see. Users with strong opinions are quick to convince themselves that they see bias, because the stronger your feelings on a topic, and especially the more you dislike something, the more this affects what you notice. Plenty of stories critical of things in China spend plenty of time on HN's front page (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19493033 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19493033 has spent most of today on the front page). If you've noticed those at all, I'm sure they didn't attract as much of your attention as this one getting flagged. Readers with opposite views to yours feel equally certain that HN is heavily biased against China—and frankly, based on the stories that appear here, they have a better case for their claim than you do. "Sam Altman's China strategy", whatever that is, has nothing to do with HN. Our sole "strategy" is to maintain an internet message board that doesn't choke to death on its fumes while burning to death from its flames. That is already a feeble enough hope that we have no bandwidth for anything else. Edit: having just taken a look at your comment history, I'm dismayed to see that this account has also have been using HN exclusively for nationalistic and political battle. As I'm sure you know, this is not allowed on HN and we ban accounts that do it. Worse, you appear to have done it numerous times before. When people create accounts to break HN's guidelines like that, we eventually ban their main account as well. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and use HN as intended from now on, we'd appreciate it.
- coldtea 8y agoExactly. Ever since WWII the US had sponsored all kinds of media, funded opposition parties (of whole dictators, guerrilla armies, and so on), wined, dined and bribed foreign journalists, politicians etc to spread the stories they liked, runs thousands of cover publications, organizations, "NGOs", and media, including the more transparent ones, like "Radio Free Europe", and so on. Others are doing it too? Cry me a river... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIA_influence_on_public_opinion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIA_influence_on_public_opinio... http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article28610.htm http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article28610.htm https://www.aim.org/special-report/how-obamas-cia-manipulated-the-media/ https://www.aim.org/special-report/how-obamas-cia-manipulate... https://arretsurinfo.ch/newly-declassified-documents-show-that-cia-worked-closely-with-owners-and-journalists-with-many-of-the-largest-media-outlets/ https://arretsurinfo.ch/newly-declassified-documents-show-th... https://www.wired.com/2011/09/cia-pitches-hollywood/ https://www.wired.com/2011/09/cia-pitches-hollywood/ https://www.corbettreport.com/how-the-cia-plants-news-stories-in-the-media/ https://www.corbettreport.com/how-the-cia-plants-news-storie...
- peter_retief 8y agoI hope we have moved on from slavery and colonization. Lets not encourage its return