3 ms·
It's strange how my perception of Google and its software has changed over the years. When Android was first released I've put it to the same category with Ope
by bayindirh 8y ago
It's strange how my perception of Google and its software has changed over the years.
When Android was first released I've put it to the same category with Open Firmware & Debian. Now when I see Fuchsia, I reflexively categorize as a pseudo-open source software, where you can see the code but cannot do anything useful on the long run, because it's designed to be downloadable but unusable for casual/research purposes.
Maybe "we put out the source for you to see and start to limit its free use when it matures enough" model gets tiring for me.
- pjmlp 8y agoIt was more than clear that the FOSS for all wasn't sustainable long term, hence why we are slowly getting back to the freeware days. Google just used good marketing to convince MS-haters that they were different.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y ago> It was more than clear that the FOSS for all wasn't sustainable long term, hence why we are slowly getting back to the freeware days. Someone should tell RedHat. And Debian. And, y'know, Linux. I'm sure Linus will be devastated to hear that the last couple of decades have just been a fluke.
- bayindirh 8y agoMaybe, on a smaller scale, we shall call OpenVPN, PuTTY, FileZilla, Zip and Tar users too. They will be upset. We need to be prepared. /s
- pjmlp 8y agoIndeed, that is why Red-Hat gave up on selling distributions for desktop GNU/Linux, and is now part of IBM, selling support contracts to enteprises. How many business are making money selling Debian based software? And how many business critical software stacks are still based on GPL, without any kind of dual license of some sort?
- bayindirh 8y agoRed Hat always sold support for their enterprise level software. A RH representative told me that they "get community software, get it to enterprise level, and sell its support. The code is always open". They also sold their technologies as services. They've never sold code or distributions per se. Their business model allowed them to develop KVM and OpenShift. Debian gave birth to the biggest number of derivative distros. They're the biggest and most mature base. Even Ubuntu is a Debian derivative. While there are no enterprise software that I know (my domain doesn't overlap with "enterprise software"), I'm aware that some of the heavy hitters in the software world have their killer features based on open source software or algorithms (Photoshop's content aware fill comes to my mind which is based on resynthesizer of GIMP).
- pjmlp 8y ago> They've never sold code or distributions per se. I guess those Red-Hat boxes at my parents basement are a piece of imagination. > Debian gave birth to the biggest number of derivative distros. They're the biggest and most mature base. Even Ubuntu is a Debian derivative. Great, and how much money do they earn from it?
- bayindirh 8y ago> I guess those Red-Hat boxes at my parents' basement are a piece of imagination. No, they are not, but Linux distros were never small (except Slackware & Gentoo), so many of us were unable to download them (with 56kbps modems). We bought the complete CD sets, which were essentially repositories on CDs. I had SUSE 6.0 box set. A generation has abused university networks to download ISO files and write them to discs. That's why most universities had local repositories for a considerable amount of time. Many still have. The place I work hosts country-wide official repositories of most Linux distributions. > Great, and how much money do they earn from it? Why not ask to the non-profits which govern the money and assets of the Debian and other projects? The page is here [0]. Looks like Google is also a donor in SPI which hosts Debian, PostgreSQL, Arduino/ArduPilot, Arch, etc. BTW, most Debian and open source developers don't do it for the money. They build the software for fun and use their skills in their day-job to do their work. Also, there are many developers paid to work on open source code and implement the required features. Glibc's developer is (was?) an RH employee for example. Intel pays developers to implement their open source network and graphics drivers. AMD's both open and closed source driver teams (yes there are two, isolated teams) are on AMD's payroll. Open Source software is sustainable. You pay for knowledge and the effort, not the code. [0]: https://www.debian.org/donations https://www.debian.org/donations
- kokey 8y agoFor the desktop/UI that end users use, for reasons I don't understand, seems to work better if it's maintained by a large commercial enterprise. That's why Windows works, Android works, Ubuntu worked a bit and obviously MacOS and iOS. I see Fuchsia as a good compromise here, it's going to have more free and open layers than MacOS on top of Darwin has. It's going to avoid a lot of the security issues Windows had and even the Debian/Ubuntu OSes and can probably be closer to MacOS/iOS in that way. It's certainly going to be a lot more open than Windows. However, in the end, it will also allow Google, hardware and graphics library makers to have more proprietary parts that they control the vision on around the end user experience. It can certainly be the Windows alternative we need and hopefully Microsoft will realise that open sourcing Windows and allowing forks will be the best way for the OS to survive.
- mda 8y agoHow is it unusable for research purposes, it seems it can be compiled and run by anyone?
- bayindirh 8y agoFor how long? Fuchsia is in its infancy now. A little prototype. with its stable API and other features, it smells like a "hardware-vendor friendly" (or vendor-first or oriented) platform. It may replace Android, maybe Linux in Google's own data centers. Then, we'll have another platform like OpenSolaris. Open, but not. The primary reason I like Linux is its transparency, openness, freedoms it provides and the resulting flexibility, and I'd hate to see these freedoms are eradicated with a so-called Open platform controlled by another mega-corporation called Google.
- gtirloni 8y agoThe biggest problem with OpenSolaris was proprietary blobs required to build it. Do you know if Fuchsia has any of those? If it doesn't, then just fork it.
- bayindirh 8y agoWhat I'm trying to say it, it'll probably end like AOSP. Downloadable, buildable, but useless without vendor or closed source add-ons/drivers. Forking is always easy, maintaining is hard. Also, we're not sure whether things will be made harder by Google when things get mature.
- gwilkes 8y agoI think useless is going a bit far, isn't Fire OS a fully maintained fork? I believe there are some maintained forks in China as well but I know less about those
- bayindirh 8y agoYeah, useless a bit too far to generalize, you're right. But, in the end, it will won't be usable by general public or software hackers (in its original definition). I don't have any Android devices, and I don't follow its forks, derivatives or general state too closely. If you have the money and the means, you can always make a fork of an open source software and make it work for you. To be more accurate, maybe I can say it won't be very useful for the general public, but big companies can do whatever they want since they have the money and the man-hours.
- eloisant 8y agoIt's interesting to see that when Android was released, it was fully Open Source. But over the years they moved all the apps to closed-source, one after the other, even some core elements (play services). Pretty soon it will be no more open source than iOS (the kernel is open source, yay!)
- mav3rick 8y agoAll of the framework is still open source.
- raxxorrax 8y agoI am sure the kernel has extended ad support with every 5th memory access. Exactly the same feelings toward the new OS. Not that there are too much alternatives. But if I could chose to get Debian on my phone bundled with a crappy phone app that looks like it was developed in the last century, I would immediately pick it.