3 ms·
> I think in fact a lot of people do want them to do this. I, the engineer, do not want them to do this. Before Google and Apple, I didn't have this problem. I
by echelon 8y ago
> I think in fact a lot of people do want them to do this.
I, the engineer, do not want them to do this. Before Google and Apple, I didn't have this problem. I didn't have to pay their tax or march to their beat.
You might argue that it's their platform and that's the cost for us to pay. But it wasn't always this way! These companies leveraged their advantages to steal eyeballs away from an open web and lock them in their own platform.
They could have spent money making the open web work better on mobile. Or designing a portable app framework and runtime for all devices. But we know why they didn't and what the outcome has been.
I want them to pay back the negative externalities they've leveraged onto us.
- craftyguy 8y ago> I, the engineer, do not want them to do this Eh, you are but one person, amongst billions. There's a good chance that what you don't want != what others want.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThat's the problem with targeting the lowest common denominator. Since that LCD is mindless consumption, that's what the ecosystem evolves to. If you have stuff to actually do, you're increasingly out of luck.
- hug 8y ago> Before Google and Apple, I didn't have this problem. I didn't have to pay their tax or march to their beat. You still don't! You don't have the play by their rules, and you can still target everyone who has a non-Google or non-Apple phone, which as a target market is appreciably no one, much as it was before Google and Apple entered the phone market. You can target them if they have phones produced by your hated manufacturers anyway by making your app a webapp instead of a native app. You don't want to do those things, and that's fine, but you're yearning to go back to a time that never existed.
- Spoom 8y agoFWIW you can target Google phones outside Google Play too. You just need to tell the user to enable some settings and download an APK.
- scarface74 8y agoWhat could possibly go wrong.... https://fox5sandiego.com/2019/01/17/fortnite-security-flaw-exposed-80-million-accounts/ https://fox5sandiego.com/2019/01/17/fortnite-security-flaw-e...
- echelon 8y ago> back to a time that never existed Personal PCs were just this back in the 90's and 00's. Microsoft tried to create a walled garden, but it failed due to the world wide web. Google and Apple saw how Microsoft failed and decided that the app store would be a first class citizen on day one and that the mobile web [1] would be an afterthought. They learned from Microsoft's mistake and used their positions to make app stores the new status quo. It could have easily gone a different way, but I understand how the business interests got us to where we are. [1] the mobile web wouldn't have been nice without more money and research poured into it. The web stack could have been supplemented or a new one could have been developed. These companies obviously had other priorities than to pay for something that netted them nothing, but individual developers wound out worse for it.
- kyralis 8y agoActually, you've got that history a little backward. The original iPhone had no App Store and had only web apps; that was the promoted way to develop for the platform. It was only after the phone's release and the mad clamor from developers to be allowed to develop native applications that an SDK was released and the App Store created.
- echelon 8y agoMy mistake. Thank you for correcting me.
- scarface74 8y agoWell, at the same time users had to deal with adware, viruses, etc. Your needs as a developer don’t trump users needs. They could have spent money making the open web work better on mobile. Or designing a portable app framework and runtime for all devices. But we know why they didn't and what the outcome has been. And write once run everywhere worked so well with Java applets.
- yegle 8y agoAFAIKT, Google indeed pushes Progressive Web Apps pretty hard.
- ucaetano 8y ago> I, the engineer, do not want them to do this. You don't matter, consumers matter. > Before Google and Apple, I didn't have this problem. And you didn't have distribution either. > But it wasn't always this way! Indeed, there wasn't even distribution. Do you actually remember what was shipping mobile software back in 2005? > I want them to pay back the negative externalities they've leveraged onto us. Again, you as an engineer don't matter, only as a consumer. And consumers have never had so many options and at such low prices.
- hrayr 8y agoI don't entirely disagree with you, but what do we call the web if not distribution?
- ucaetano 8y agoThe web didn't disappear, quite the opposite. Now you have the web AND the in-device app stores. Even more choice.
- echelon 8y agoBut they're not equal citizens on mobile devices. Web often feels sluggish on mobile, and it doesn't have the same access to device and hardware APIs, nor does it allow low-level control of concurrency and allocation. (I don't want to get off topic about HTML/JS. It does a lot of jobs well.) There could have been an open, cross-platform native app stack if Apple and Google and a consortium of other companies had joined forces and made it so. There's no technical reason preventing this. The economic incentives got us to where we are. Devices should be easy to target. There should be the option to use multiple app stores right off the bat, and you shouldn't have to bundle to get access to Gmail. Or even better - point your browser at gmail.com and get the native app installed on your mobile device. Distributed updates from gmail.com sans app store. The OS would still control permissions and guard against malicious apps. The world wide web era was truly unique and special, and it's a shame the same principles didn't carry into the mobile world.
- ddingus 8y agoPlease, you engineer, do your best to make the app usable from a browser. I dislike apps. Sometimes they make sense. Fine. Often, they do not, or offer less functionality than PC or web does. If you need payment, make that easy, same. Cancel easy too. Just because that is nice, and we all could use nice. You like nice, I like nice. Let us be nice. If you need profanity, whatever, I get it. Let's be adults. I don't like the gate keepers and do not trust them. I do not expect you to trust me, nor you me. Clean, open, portable web for both of us as much as can be managed. I support you, you support me, us. I can be a user on linux, android, iOS, Windows, BSD, whatever I can get on the web. Sometimes dependent stuff is needed for the job. I get it. Please try to avoid that stuff, and I will try and run more relevant systems. :D I really do avoid apps, really do try and be a good user, really do prefer web and really do run a bunch of OSes. We both are rare. I do advocacy every chance I get. Maybe you can too. Stick together in a figurative sense. My development is small, embedded systems and or specific purpose programs. Enough to get the engineer speaking here. Hopefully, you are a user enough to do similar things.
- drdaeman 8y agoI happen to prefer the exactly opposite - I don't want to run the browser (or a browser-wrapper), I want app to be native. <rant>Websites lack solid, consistent and platform-native look-and-feel. They are always limited, they aren't integrated with the operating system (i.e. task switcher), they are slow on almost anything (because modern web browsers are ugly giant behemoths. I've recently built myself a very beefy machine (16-core CPU, 128GiB RAM) and even now _sometimes_ sites are still choppy. On mobile, lots of sites are performing poorly.</rant>
- hombre_fatal 8y agoPerhaps the best features about the web, though, are the share-centric nature of being able to pass around a link, the control we have over the client, and the distribution of apps and info that's least encumbered by gatekeepers. For example, let's go all the way to the other end of the spectrum where the web as we know it didn't take off and everything was siloed into native apps that you had to download from the App Store before trying something new. That seems pretty grim to me. I think we're in a sweet spot and lucky to have both.