3 ms·
You write as if your understanding of asset forfeiture was "the government can simply take whatever it wants whenever it wants". That isn't the case at all. It'
by joe_the_user 16y ago
You write as if your understanding of asset forfeiture was "the government can simply take whatever it wants whenever it wants". That isn't the case at all. It's called "civil" forfeiture because the government is suing for the property.
Taking "whatever they can get away with" is quite different from "whatever they want".
Whether authorized by a judge or not, a procedure involving "take first then you've got to sue us", is a violation of the basic rule of law - the requirement to face your accuser before any property can be taken. This goes back to the constitution and even the Magna Carta.
I mean, There was no service or trial in the situation described. Judge-authorization for lawless act is just a dodge Otherwise, we'll go the system of "Judge Dred" ("Judge, Jury and
executioner") http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judge_Dredd http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judge_Dredd
- tptacek 16y agoThis seems kind of silly to me. On approximately the same evidentiary standard, any law enforcement order could achieve a warrant for arrest and directly deprive the operators of these sites of their liberties. Here, all they lost was their domain name. I'm not interested in an argument about civil forfeiture, not least because we probably already agree more than we disagree (but nobody will know that because now the Magna Carta has been invoked and there's not enough oxygen left in the capsule for both of us). I'm just saying, this isn't some crazy new censorship regime dreamed up by the RIAA and the DHS. This is absolutely part of Customs' charter.
- joe_the_user 16y agoOn approximately the same evidentiary standard, any law enforcement order could achieve a warrant for arrest and directly deprive the operators of these sites of their liberties. Here, all they lost was their domain name. Again, I think your "how badly do they get hurt" standard is wrong-headed. Democracy isn't really about limiting how much authorities do to people. It's limiting how easily and privately authorities can do things. Yes, it is about making thing hard for the authorities because when it somewhat hard to act against people, authorities are more reluctant to act. IE, the difference between seizure and arrest is if you arrest these people, you've committed yourself to going through the process of proving them guilty. If a cop writes a ticket, they have to show up in court to defend the valid of the ticket. If the cop just takes money, they aren't committed to their action. If the various website were engaging in counterfeiting or whatever, the actual job of these agencies is to find the people and arrest them. Shutting off a site will only slow things down slightly - but it does give a far-too-convenient tool to authorities It is important for democracy that guilty people be proven guilty. A lesser standard will likely still get lots of guilty people but will open the door to despotism as well. I know it stands in the way of blood-lust for the guilty but thems the break - unless you've found a way to achieve a guaranteed-enlighten-despotism (it always sounded good in the past but never worked out).
- hga 16y agoSee my other comment in this thread. It's "all right" because it's the property being sued, i.e. the domain name itself, not the holder of the domain name (yes, you read that correctly). That's how they get away without due process for the holder, it's irrelevant since they're officially a 3rd party. I'm sure the domain name was properly impressed by the judge's warrant when it surrendered to the US Marshals or whomever.
- tptacek 16y agoIt's simply not correct to assert that the property owner has no due process rights. You obviously don't approve of the specific process accorded to property owners, but words mean things.