4 ms·
I wonder what happens the first time that there's a credible link to someone dying as a results of Wikileaks leaking a document. It depends on who is doing the
by joe_the_user 16y ago
I wonder what happens the first time that there's a credible link to someone dying as a results of Wikileaks leaking a document.
It depends on who is doing the crediting, I suspect.
To ask the opposite loaded-question, [rhetoric]"what will happen the first time there's a credible link to someone's life being saved by a Wikileaks release?" (Perhaps someone being released from Guantanamo Bay when they wouldn't have otherwise been? What if Wikileaks catches child-molestors in high places?)[/rhetoric]
Back honest discussion... it's pretty hard to pin blame Wikileaks for any given event, though. If our supposedly democratic government has decided that secrecy will be standard operating procedure for law enforcement, that government still has the main job of protecting it's secret operatives. Wikileaks isn't a spy agency, they just take information that's there. Any good intelligence operation compartmentalizes information on a need-to-know basis. So if names of some operator are flying around, someone has screwed up long before Wikileaks appears on the scene. The good way of protecting the classified information is keeping it within an intelligence agency. Should free-speech be hobbled for those situations where the secret-keepers screw-up?
Further, it doesn't seem coincidental to me that the main justification for government secrecy is stopping victimless crimes and intervening in foreign conflicts. How many people have been killed as a result of this? (countless) What are people going to do about this?
- lionhearted 16y ago> To ask the opposite loaded-question, [rhetoric]"what will happen the first time there's a credible link to someone's life being saved by a Wikileaks release?" (Perhaps someone being released from Guantanamo Bay when they wouldn't have otherwise been? What if Wikileaks catches child-molestors in high places?)[/rhetoric] This is where discretion comes into play. If they caught a child molestor, that'd absolutely be the kind of thing you should leak - a crime. Leaking war videos to show people the real impact of a war - probably okay. Leaking war plans and war logistics info - a heck of a lot more questionable. Leaking anti-nuclear proliferation, leaking informants trying to protect dissidents - totally, straightup wrong. Discretion. They just demonstrated they don't have very much. Why the hell would they release that Chinese informant info? That's crazy. That's nuts. That's against their own frigging goal of more openness in the world. They want publicity, and don't have a sense of judgment. Leak crimes. Absolutely, yes! That's a public service. But don't frigging leak info that obstructs obviously good causes and accomplishes nothing. > Should free-speech be hobbled for those situations where the secret-keepers screw-up? Free speech has limits. Risking getting objectively good guys killed - like the Chinese politburo agent - is probably over that line. Can you see any good reason to leak that info besides getting celebrity and attention? Let me ask you Joe - do you think leaking that was bad? I do. I don't see any good it accomplishes for the potential damage it does.
- joe_the_user 16y agoThis is where discretion comes into play. You're sort-of talking to the air here. I am not Wikileaks and no one on this forum is wikileaks. If we have a world-wide free flow of information, we'll have people releasing stuff. Wikileaks claims to release everything with the minimal redacting possible but necessary. If they did more redacting, the actual leaker could well go elsewhere. Are they responsible enough? That's not really the question. The question is, should they be stopped? Democratic society pretty much involves the assumption that while most people are responsible, a minority is irresponsible and that the cost of forcing everyone to be responsible ("benevolent" dictatorship) isn't worth the benefit. That's because any dictatorship gives the bad people who happen to get on top a much free-er run than democracy. And free speech is an important of the democratic equation. Lots of the speech is stupid and even irresponsible. But it keeps those on top honest. That is the democratic "equation": less efficiency in exchange for avoiding the "big bad" of despotism. But if it makes you feel better ... I hereby urge everyone in the world to be more responsible and discreet and only do good things. Are you satisfied?
- qq66 16y agoThe Internet has made the potential power of a small number of irresponsible individuals much higher than it ever has been. Previously, only terrorists had such a high awareness/number ratio.
- joe_the_user 16y agoThe "power" of Wikileaks rests on the perceived need of the US government to govern secretly. I would question the need for a massive security state with a vast flow of secret information within it. Further, if the such a state is threaten whenever a flow of secrets are exposed, it says more about the fragility of such a system than the power of those who might reveal its secrets.
- _djo_ 16y agoConfidentiality has always been a necessary element of diplomacy. There is nothing inherently sinister about that. So far I have seen very little in the released cables that can legitimately be said was in the public interest.