7 ms·
Taking a look at the Rotten Tomatoes “Top 100 Films of All Time” list [1], I’m not exactly sure why it’s a model to be replicated. It’s extremely obvious that “
by keiferski 8y ago
Taking a look at the Rotten Tomatoes “Top 100 Films of All Time” list [1], I’m not exactly sure why it’s a model to be replicated. It’s extremely obvious that “top” means “popular and/or most advertised.”
[1] https://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/bestofrt/ https://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/bestofrt/
- guelo 8y agoWhat a weird list with few selections between 1970 and 2015.
- anextomp 8y agoTheir "adjusted score" means that films with more ratings are rated higher. Older films have far fewer ratings by critics, same with smaller films.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- misnome 8y agoYes, Alien being missing is an odd sign, especially as it has 99%. (IIRC it used to be the only 100% film, until some critic posted a new review saying it hadn’t aged well)
- icebraining 8y agoAlien is there (position 56).
- misnome 8y agoDang it I both scanned and searched the page, and safari browser said no text results.
- rjtavares 8y agoRT's model prioritizes consensus in quality instead of brilliance. Using RT for a best of list will give you good safe movies instead of outstanding ones. I'd say it's a good model for news.
- cat199 8y ago... except that most of the news that actually matters is 'outstanding' rather than 'good and safe'
- rjtavares 8y agoActually, most of your news consumption should be of the 'good and safe' variety. That is an absolutely necessary requirement for you to properly evaluate 'oustanding and unsafe' news.
- ddebernardy 8y agoIf I'm not mistaking, parent was meaning major investigative journalism efforts and high profile scoops, like the Snowden revelations, the Panama Papers, etc.
- rjtavares 8y agoI count those as "outstanding and unsafe" (as they happened).
- ddebernardy 8y agoIf that's the yardstick, one could just as well open the NYT, the WP, the WSJ, or [your favorite reputable newspaper] and call it a day -- no RT clone needed.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoA large percentage of the population doesn't consider NYT, WP, WSJ reputable. They are all extremely biased by their politics. I can't even name a single news source that I'd call reputable and that I trust. That's why I like reading multiple sources on the subject plus comments on Reddit/HN.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dagw 8y agoIt’s extremely obvious that “top” means “popular and/or most advertised.” In RTs case, "Top" means films no one dislikes it and everybody thought it was at the very least OK. The "problem" with genuinely great films is that they can often be divisive and challenging and generate a lot of strong opinions in both directions, and thus they'll never rate as well on RT.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoWhich is totally fine, as long as it's understood that way. Nothing wrong with a 'consensus'-type rating.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agoI think that's exactly the case the OP has: there's no lack of divisive news at the moment. It's a calm, balanced, quality journalism that's we all are missing.
- beat 8y agoI don't think there's any lack of calm, balanced, quality journalism. Rather, there's a lot of politicized rejection of calm, balanced, quality news. You don't have to look too far to find people who think AP (much less BBC or Al Jazeera) is part of some conspiracy or another. As Cobert (I think) said, "Facts have a known liberal bias".
- michaelt 8y agoLooking at the RT top 100 list, 76 films are from 2010 or later, 6 from 2000-2009, and 18 from earlier. Were films a lot more divisive before 2010?
- anextomp 8y agoThis is because films with more ratings are rated higher. Older films have far fewer ratings by critics, same with smaller films. Add on the fact that each critic's review is distilled to a positive/negative boolean value, and it's clear to see why RT's best films is really just a list of films they are confident you'll like.
- ekianjo 8y agoindeed most recent movies have a better rating compared to movies 20 years ago or more, on average.
- tzs 8y agoThere are still some oddities. "How to Train Your Dragon" (2010), 99% with 206 reviews does not make the list, but many older movies, with lower scores and lower number of reviews do. E.g., "The Wizard of Oz" (1939), 98% with 111 reviews, and "It Happened One Night" (1934), 98% with 56 reviews, and "Casablanca" (1942), 97% with 79 reviews, and "Alien" (1979), 97% with 115 reviews. It looks like the older a film is, the fewer reviews it needs backing its score to make the list. It's also possible that the age of the review is taken into account, so that a modern review looking back on a film counts more than an older review, because that would probably be more relevant to someone today deciding what older movies to watch. For example, take "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly" (1966). It wasn't very well received by critics in 1966. Now, though, it's at 97% on RT, and is regular included in lists of top films (it used to be on the RT top 100, but looks like it has been pushed off).
- darkpuma 8y agoAbove all else, RT needs their ranking to be perceived as legitimate. The general public knows there are a handful of old movies that should certainly be in any legitimate Top-100 list. Casablanca, Citizen Kane, The Wizard of Oz, etc. These are movies recognized by the general public as movies that are considered masterpieces. If those movies were not in the list, then the general public would not consider the list legitimate. I'm talking about people who've never seen any of those movies, but are aware of their reputations and will dismiss any Top-100 list that doesn't include those movies. So the consequence of that is clear. If you are tasked with creating a Top-100 movie list, you better tune whatever algorithm you use to include those movies. You'll butcher your beautiful algorithm to ensure those handful of classic movies always rank high. You might go so far as to put those movies in a special list and inject them arbitrarily into your Top-100 list, circumventing the normal ranking algorithm, because having those particular movies in the Top-100 is a design requirement. It's more important that those movies be in the list than it is for your ranking algorithm be fair and unbiased.
- muzani 8y agoRT is optimized to filter out bad movies (hence the name). The system doesn't work well for "best movies", but does great at telling me what movies shouldn't be watched on a date.
- icebraining 8y agoThat's just a particular choice of how to filter and rank 100 movies, not representative of the site as a whole.
- nukeop 8y agoRT has been a joke ever since they rated a Marvel movie as the greatest achievement of cinematography in history.
- ceejayoz 8y agoWhen did they do that?
- ambulancechaser 8y agohttps://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/bestofrt/ https://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/bestofrt/ "Top 100 Movies of All Time" 1. Black Panther
- ceejayoz 8y agoThere doesn't seem to be any indication in the "Adjusted Scores" popup that it's based on cinematography.
- nukeop 8y agoDon't play passive-aggressive, you know very well what I meant.
- ceejayoz 8y agoI really don't. RT's value prop has never been "a good score indicates a technically/artistically good film". It's just "how'd the critics we track like the movie?" If it's over 80%, I can reasonably assume I'll enjoy it. If it's below 30%, I should probably figure out if it fits my particular "critically panned but I'd love it" quirks before shelling out $15 for a theater outing.
- goto11 8y agoRotten Tomatoes does not rate anything. They aggregate reviews.
- dmortin 8y agoNote that this list is based on the tomato score which doesn't directly refers to the movie quality, it simply says if the movie is worth seeing. There is also a rating which is usually hidden by default (click the more info link on a film's page). If you check that then you see, for example, that the number 1 Black Panther's rating is 8.26, while number 2 Lady Bird has a rating of 8.74, so it's a better rated movie. There should be a top list based on ratings too. Maybe there is somewhere.
- Izkata 8y ago> Note that this list is based on the tomato score It's not, it even shows that score on the list. #1 is scored 97% while #2 is 99%. What would be better is a top list based on audience score, not critic score.
- conception 8y agoSo IMDB?
- skinnymuch 8y agoThere’s IMDB. And it’s very arguable to say that’s better.
- Kiro 8y agoA group of my friends who are real film enthusiasts bashed IMDB top 250 in a similar way so they decided to create their own top 250. They had a big spreadsheet, argued and discussed for a long time. The result? Pretty much exactly the same as IMDB top 250.
- skinnymuch 8y agoReally? Their results ended up being close to IMDB? I’ve done similar lists with enthusiast friends. Ours was different enough. There’a no Shawshank Redemption anywhere close to the top, etc.
- Kiro 8y agoYeah, it was ironic. Can I see your list somewhere?
- skinnymuch 8y agoI’m trying to remember which service it was on. On second thought looking over IMDB top movies. The list probably is sort of similar. It really is hard to get a conesensus for top movies. Sure my own personal list as a media geek will be different. But no one else is really going to agree with my esoteric specific films. IMDB does have some films that stick out in the top of their list though. Star Wars being so high, LOTR being so high, Inception, Seven, Green Mile, Gladiator. No matter though you’re right that consensus is hard to get. And most of the films that I listed as out of place are part of fanboy beloved franchises or headed by fanboy beloved directors.
- goto11 8y agoIt is important to understand what RT actually are rating here. It is not an aggregate of reviewers selections of best movies ever. Neither is it some aggregate of how much reviewers liked a certain movie. RT is more like a list of the movies which a lot of critics rated but fewest critics disliked. So you get popular and uncontroversial. These are good choices for movies to show on airplanes. It is actually an interesting rating, as long as you understand what is being rated.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> So you get popular and uncontroversial. I agree with you, but I don't know if that's the right way to describe them. Looking in the top 10 I can see, to name a few, Moonlight, BlacKkKlansman and Get Out, all items that SHOULD be discussed. I think these also include movies that have a social message that critics agree need to be discussed.
- goto11 8y agoBy "uncontroversial" I mean there is broad agreement among critics that this movie is worth watching. This does not necessarily mean the subject matter of the movie is uncontroversial.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoAh, ok. In that cause I gotcha. I just didn't want it to sound like these films were somehow safe when it came to subject matter.
- goto11 8y agoNo, they are just safe enough to not offend critics.
- owldimoon 8y agoWhich is a line that changes over time, I might add! It's interesting to think about how each movie on that list got there in a way that's relative to the era it was produced in. You could choose a cutoff, sort by date, and have a pretty neat timeline of what's considered "safe".
- Circuits 8y agoI would have to agree. I have never taken RT evaluations seriously which is one of the reasons I was so disappointed to hear they would be involved in the project.
- beat 8y agoFully half that list is movies from the 20th century, going back as far as 1920. I think it's a flawed list in many ways (especially the lack of non-English language films, missing masterpieces like Tarkovsky's Stalker), but it doesn't seem to be driven by mere popularity or advertisement.
- goto11 8y agoPopularity and marketing is a factor to the extent that lesser known movies will not get enough reviews to count. Note that some movies gets ranked lower despite having a higher percentage. E.g Citizen Kane has 100% but is ranked several steps below Black Panther which has 97%. This is due to Panther having more reviews so the confidence is higher.
- beat 8y agoWell, we tend to review what's new, not something from decades ago. Different process. It's unsurprising that there are more software-countable reviews of contemporary movies. Black Panther, to use the example some are protesting here, is a perfect storm of recent (max accessible reviews), critically acclaimed, and wildly successful commercially. I think it's more telling that recent Star Wars movies like The Last Jedi are on the list, but A New Hope and The Empire Strikes Back (which are more important imho) are not. This is one reason I like the standard set by the Cocaine and Rhinestones country music podcast. He won't talk about 21st century music because we don't have enough distance to tell what's truly great from what's merely popular at this point. A couple of decades of reflection really separates the great from the trendy.