7 ms·
Selling a new small phone is a market problem for Apple. The form factor inherently makes it less expensive to manufacture. Bigger screens cost more etc. Which
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
Selling a new small phone is a market problem for Apple.
The form factor inherently makes it less expensive to manufacture. Bigger screens cost more etc. Which creates a pricing problem for them.
If they price it like a small phone (i.e. lower price) they cannibalize sales of larger phones with higher total margins, and lose money. If they price it with the same total margin as the larger phones, it'd still be the lowest priced current generation phone in their lineup, but would then compare very poorly on price to similar spec Android phones, which makes their brand look overpriced (as opposed to premium).
About the only way it would make sense is to make it a premium product. Give it the fastest available processor etc. so it can justify a premium price despite the size. But that's a difficult engineering problem. A faster processor uses more power and generates more heat, but smaller phones have less room for a big battery and less surface area to dissipate heat. And finding a solution for that is extra hard because what it needs is an advantage relative to larger phones, but if you improve performance per watt or battery density in general then the same improvement can go into the larger phone too and you still have no relative advantage.
- baxtr 8y agoSo why is there an iPad mini then? Mac mini? Your argument is completely on the marketing side of things, but maybe it’s an production issue? Apple is spending large capital expenditures each year, no one exactly know why, but probably they buy all the tooling in the factories. Another form factor will cost them money to produce.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> So why is there an iPad mini then? Mac mini? The iPad mini is neither the smallest nor least expensive current iOS device. The Mac mini starts at $800 and the entire Mac desktop line seems to be something Apple has discontinued caring about because they make all their money from iPhones now. > Your argument is completely on the marketing side of things, but maybe it’s an production issue? Apple is spending large capital expenditures each year, no one exactly know why, but probably they buy all the tooling in the factories. Another form factor will cost them money to produce. This does cost money, but if there is demand for the product (which isn't just diverted from your other products) then you make it back. And if it was a major factor, would they have existing products like the iPad mini?
- baxtr 8y agoThe short answer is: I don't know. I just wanted to broaden the discussion. I think it is much more complex than just pricing Regarding your last point: You are assuming that they're manufacturing the iPad mini on their own tooling like the iPhones. Who knows if that's true. The scale of iPad production is much lower so it might make no sense to buy the machinery.
- simonh 8y agoIt's lower yes, but still pretty high. Apple sells about twice as many iPads as they do Macs. In fact they sell more iPads than any individual manufacturer sells laptops.
- ryacko 8y agoI just wish they would sell an iPod touch with cellular.
- RubberbandSoul 8y agoThat's a dangerous strategy considering that an iPhone is the "window" to their ecosystem: App store, Apple Pay, the iOS UX experience, etc. I know many people who love Apple's ecosystem but who won't pay through the nose for a "premium" phone that's way overpowered for their needs.
- simonh 8y agoThen frankly they're not in the Apple target demographic. I know that sucks, but the iPhone is a gateway for customers who are willing to pay a premium for Apple products. The real danger for Apple would be compromising with a budget model at the entry level. It would kill their value proposition on the whole rest of their line. The closest they get is previous-year models and refurbs.
- TimTheTinker 8y ago> Then frankly they're not in the Apple target demographic. I think you’re forgetting about the significant market for used Apple products. There are many people, myself included, who live on used MacBooks, iPhones, iPads, AppleTV, Airport Express, etc., and are perfectly content. I’m typing this out on an iPhone SE that I bought used, and that was the most I’ve ever paid for a phone. My wife is still content with a 5S, and I frankly never notice the difference when I borrow her phone. Apple (perhaps begrudgingly) cares about us because the used market helps keep the demand high for their new and shiny products.
- RubberbandSoul 8y agoI think they run a real risk of diminishing returns. To use a car analogy; first they were the BMW of phones, then the Ferrari and maybe soon the Bugatti. Along the way consumers will start to tap out and leave Apple's ecosystem altogether. Maybe that's already set in motion, people are keeping their phones for much longer so it will take a while for the effects to be noticeable.
- cyxxon 8y agoO, definitely. Anecdote, but count me among these people. I had 4 or 5 iPhones, and 1 Android phone sometime in the middle (before my 6s). I am currently on the Xs, but if Apple keeps this pricing strategy I will not buy another iPhone again. Outside the US it is really hard to justify with the added tax and "export fee" on top. I just hope it will be ok for 3 years.
- hrktb 8y ago> The form factor inherently makes it less expensive to manufacture. Bigger screens cost more etc. Which creates a pricing problem for them. In this perspective it's interesting how their current "lower tier" phone, the Xr, is priced lower than the Xs for instance, but got the bigger screen and better battery. It gives them an opening for marketing smaller phones as more niche models with eventually more engineering going towards keeping it small with the same or better specs than the bigger phones.
- dewey 8y ago> In this perspective it's interesting how their current "lower tier" phone, the Xr, is priced lower than the Xs for instance, but got the bigger screen and better battery. But it's about the price not the actual "size", the Xs has a OLED screen vs the LED screen of the Xr which is way more expensive.
- hrktb 8y agoWe are in agreement I think, I see that material differentiation as another way to get over the hurdle of having a smaller device priced high enough to offer a comfortable margin. I'm totally fine with Apple coming up with a set of ways to prevent a phone from being perceived as cheap, while keeping a smaller form factor.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoIt's not a cost problem but a positioning problem. I just bought a Nokia 7 plus which is about the same size of an iphone 6 plus for 295 Euros. Big does not have to be expensive. And it's an 8 core phone. It's plenty fast. I'm pretty sure Apple is doing fine in terms of cost. The real problem for Apple is differentiating their more expensive phones when the most significant thing for end users is the screen size and the camera. Take one of those away and there's not much left to charge for. Their current model is based on artificially inflated prices for big screens. For whatever reason there's a segment of users that happily hand over the cash for what is an overpriced phone. However, it lost them the entry segment; which is why they keep bringing back the 5S/SE formfactor. Without this, they bleed users even as revenue goes up because of the increased ASP. If they get the bigger 6/7/8 formfactor to the same price, they are cannibalizing their high end range because the difference between that and their premium XR range is mostly not that big. Worse, you can't really tell them apart easily because they have the same design. This is made worse by people using iphone covers. Status and vanity are big reasons for owning an iphone but when they all look the same, you might as well get the cheaper one.
- josteink 8y ago> About the only way it would make sense is to make it a premium product. What’s the problem with that? In my mind that’s exactly what the iPhone SE is: a premium phone in a small form factor. That’s exactly what I want. That’s literally the only thing I want in my next phone. Nothing Apple currently offers interests me at all. Every option they have, even the “small” options, are way too big. Some people seem to mistake the iPhone SE as some sort of cheap option for those who can’t afford a “real” iPhone (thinking about market segments as opposed to use-case), but that’s absolutely ass backwards. We want the best, and we want it comfortably in our hand.
- emsy 8y ago>Selling a new small phone is a market problem for Apple. I'd argue that Apple making product decisions for mainly financial reasons is a recent problem. My memory could betray me though.
- throwawaymath 8y agoI disagree. Fundamentally, every company makes product decisions primarily for financial reasons. Apple has been focused on finances for most of its existence as an entity. If it appears they have become more focused on financial success recently, I would argue that's more likely due to market saturation than it is to any categorical change in their priorities. EDIT: Changed and removed some wording to make the tone less condescending. Sorry about that.
- bunderbunder 8y ago> If it appears they have become more focused on financial success recently, that's more likely due to market saturation than it is to any categorical change in their priorities. One could also cast it as an entirely predictable consequence of replacing a CEO who came up as a product person with one who came up as an operations person. Apple's no stranger to saturating markets. They used to grow past that point, in part, by expanding into new markets that were peripherally related to the ones they already dominated in, and becoming a dominant player at those as well. They were remarkably good at it, too, with very few major missteps. They don't seem to be so good at that game anymore,though, so they're falling back on the top leadership's top skill: Expanding margins.
- emsy 8y agoThis is a rather condescending reply, and I hope next time you try to understand what I wrote before trying to lecture me.
- throwawaymath 8y agoI apologize for the condescension, it wasn't intended. Thank you for letting me know; I've edited the comment.
- chrisseaton 8y agoWhy does it have to be cheaper or have more expensive components? If people value the smaller form factor as they say why aren’t they willing to pay the same as or even more than a larger phone to get it?
- azeotropic 8y agoExactly; it just requires some psychological trickery -- advertising the small form factor as a premium item. MacBook Airs and MacBook Pros are a reasonable analogy.
- ashelmire 8y agoNobody likes to feel like a fool. Paying $1000 bucks for a phone when you can get a similar phone from a competitor for $100 makes you feel like a fool.
- chrisseaton 8y agoIf it’s the product you want and the price is worth it to you then why feel a fool? If the similar phone did what you want then you’d buy that instead. The extra $900 is either worth it for the missing feature or not. Nobody’s a fool in this situation.
- ashelmire 8y agoPaying $900 for it to be an iPhone over android for the average user would be foolish. The icon and ios aren’t worth the money.
- CloudNetworking 8y agoEven for the average user the differences are not the icon and ios. It's the consequences of the icon and ios (better marketplace, safer phone, arguably more stable and more durable, etc)
- dagw 8y agoI'm an Android fan, so I'd love to know your source for $100 Android phones that can match (or even come close to) a $1000 iPhone in specs and build quality. I will order 3 this afternoon.
- rsp1984 8y agoExactly. Or a bit more succinct: High-volume, low-margin (as with the iPhone SE) is neither a viable growth strategy for Apple (the volumes would have to be huge and it would erode the brand -- way too risky), nor a viable complementary offering (as it would cannibalize other products).
- bradleyjg 8y ago> About the only way it would make sense is to make it a premium product Interesting analysis. What about if they embraced the luxury brand aspect and instead of making it a premium product via the fastest available processor (etc) they made the back of the phone out of sterling silver or something?
- mediocrejoker 8y agoIf it still has the latest specs in the small form factor, I for one don't really care how they justify it to the marketing dept.
- gambiting 8y ago>>> The form factor inherently makes it less expensive to manufacture. Bigger screens cost more etc. Which creates a pricing problem for them. I'm not sure I agree with this at all. Traditionally smaller laptops cost more than larger ones, even for an identical or inferior spec(with the assumption that making them smaller takes more engineering to cram everything in). Don't see why this logic wouldn't apply here.
- kenips 8y agoApple is close to solving the market problem with XR being a success. The next interaction of the XS line can offer a smaller version without cannibalizing mainstream iPhones, just like the current iPad line up.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoIs it a success? https://9to5mac.com/2019/01/09/iphone-xr-usage-overtakes-xs/ https://9to5mac.com/2019/01/09/iphone-xr-usage-overtakes-xs/ I can't pull up mixpanel trends right now for some reason, but looking at this graph doesn't lead me to believe the XR is very successful.
- microcolonel 8y ago> but smaller phones have less room for a big battery The nice thing about the SE form factor is that it is enough thicker than the 6 and later form factor to offset much of the battery concern. If they made an SE form factor phone with an OLED display (thinner), kept it precisely as thick overall, and shifted even more of the circuitry to the chin and forehead of the phone, then they could get a pretty big battery in there, and as a bonus, the OLED would generally be more efficient as well.
- scurvy 8y agoUnfortunately that compact strategy doesn't work in the market, just ask Sony. Sony has been making compact phones with flagship specs for years without much success. The phones are great, too (good feel, more than powerful enough, great battery life, minimal android mods, etc). But they just don't sell. Everyone wants the latest and biggest Samsung. Sony hasn't been able to carve out a profitable niche here. I have a Sony compact and people are constantly asking me questions about it with intrigue then shrug their shoulders and go back to their giant phones. The main knock against Sony phones is the camera quality, which they intentionally nerf in order to not damage their DSLR business.
- CydeWeys 8y agoSony doesn't really have a DSLR business these days. They're all in on mirrorless on the high end and compact point-and-shoots on the low end. I feel like Apple might be able to succeed here where Sony has failed, because of their moat around the Apple ecosystem.