5 ms·
I actually have a different concern then "screen time" which is just "play space". High density living in cities is dreadful for providing enough outdoors / fr
by XorNot 8y ago
I actually have a different concern then "screen time" which is just "play space".
High density living in cities is dreadful for providing enough outdoors / free activity space for kids to be kids - too much noise (or a risk of them making too much noise), too much communal property they shouldn't damage or can't work on.
Growing up, I have memories of my dad building things around the house (including our cubby house), having a sandpit etc. How do you do any of that in an apartment in the city? How do you even have reasonable transit distances to places you can do those things?
- anovikov 8y agoWell people in all of the free world have been largely living in cities for 2-3 generations now, what's new here?
- crawshaw 8y agoThere is a city playground 3 minutes walk from my apartment with a sandpit, swings, and climbing structures. Almost always, there is another kid there for mine to play with. We go every day it is warm enough. This is not unusual in Manhattan. Pick any apartment and walk five minutes in every direction. You'll find a playground. In the winter we take the subway 20 minutes to a large indoor complex with better equipment and hundreds of other children. They are not quiet! Of all the places we go, his favorite is the subway, where he gets to say Hi! and Bye! to lots of people. I dread the loneliness of the burbs.
- pushpop 8y agoDepends where you go. Some cities are very social while others are not. Equally some suburbs are social and others are not.
- ryanworl 8y agoWhere I used to live on 78th St near the East River there is a park called John Jay Park. It is behind two different schools. There would be literally hundreds of children playing daily in that park when the weather was nice, and usually a smaller number when it wasn’t as nice, but still hardly ever zero during reasonable “kids playing outside hours”. Ages were between kids that could barely walk there with parents or nannies all the way to young teens. I’m sure many other cities are not like this, but in neighborhoods where people with children in NYC actually live (like the UES) there are plenty of parks and people to fill them.
- exelius 8y agoNew York (Manhattan in particular) is unique among American urban areas in this way. A big part of the way American cities grow is the interplay between the quality of the various local school districts.
- bobthepanda 8y agoNew York is considered an “average” school district. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/04/29/upshot/money-race-and-success-how-your-school-district-compares.html?mtrref=www.google.com https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/04/29/upshot/money-... Quite frankly it’s a miracle that the school district works at all. Having experienced it, school choice does not scale to a million plus kids.
- criddell 8y agoPick your 'burb carefully and you are fine. Mine has a community sports league for just about anything you can think of. Swimming, soccer, baseball, lacrosse, touch football, cross country, etc... There are four different community swimming pools, miles and miles of hiking trails, and sidewalks everywhere for bikes and dog walking. Courts for tennis and basketball. There are kids everywhere. It isn't unusual for the doorbell to ring with a kid wanting to know if your kid can come out to play. One neighbor kid used to ring our bell to ask if he could go in our backyard to play with our dog. On days like hallowe'en, people block the roads off and kids run wild. There are elementary schools and middle schools spread throughout the neighborhood. Kids can walk or bike to school, although lots of busy parents still drive their kids.
- shhehebehdh 8y agoBuilding permanent fixtures is right out if you don’t have a yard, this is true. However the urban environment offers a lot of other beneficial things that kids in the suburbs rarely experience (as one who grew up there): regular interaction with people from different racial and socioeconomic backgrounds, lots of walking and use of shared transportation resources, and a shot at earlier independence, since you don’t have to drive to get where you’re going. Also, we do have parks, they just aren’t as big as the ones in the burbs. On the other hand, I take my kids to the park far more often than I was taken as a child, since it’s less than a five minute walk away. Anyway, it’s fine to worry but personally I’d try to hold off until there’s some empirical evidence that there is a problem. If there is (“study shows kids raised in city are maladjusted” — after controlling for all other variables), I’m not aware of it.
- moorhosj 8y agoPeople have been living in cities for centuries. Along with people, they tend to have the highest density of places like libraries, parks and museums. Those all seem like great places for kids to learn and explore. Also, not everyone in a city lives in an apartment. Condos and single-family-homes typically include an outdoor space.
- dredmorbius 8y agoMost people have not lived in cities until the past decade, globally, or past few decades in selected industrialised countries. Globally, the figure is about 55%, passing the midpoint in the 2010s. The US became 50% urban in the 1920s. For England and Wales, the 1890s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization#/media/File%3AHistorical_global_urban_-_rural_population_trends.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization#/media/File%3AHis... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization
- throwaway287391 8y agoI grew up in the burbs and found it absolutely "dreadful" as far as being able to do things outside without a car. Now that I live in a city, I often think about how much happier and freer I would've felt as a child growing up in one. (I had similar feelings when I actually was a kid and watched cartoons like "Hey Arnold!" set in cities. I was so jealous of those kids.) As a 12 year old in a city you can walk to a park or get on the metro/bus and visit some friends or go see a movie etc. In the burbs if your parents aren't home or are otherwise unwilling to drive you somewhere you're basically stuck at home counting the days until you turn 16.
- protomyth 8y agoAs a 12 year old in a city you can walk to a park or get on the metro/bus and visit some friends or go see a movie etc. If some "concerned citizen" doesn't report the 12 year old to child protective services. Looking at how children are pushed into so much fear it is no wonder how many of them escape into the virtual.
- throwaway287391 8y agoI could be wrong, but my impression is that those CPS calls are a chiefly suburban phenomenon.
- wcunning 8y agoThe original story of that was a 12 year old being allowed to ride the New York subway by himself. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenore_Skenazy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenore_Skenazy
- throwaway287391 8y agoFrom your link, (1) it was a 9 year old, and (2) I don't see anything about CPS calls or any similar panic. > Skenazy's April 1, 2008 column in The New York Sun, "Why I Let My 9-Year-Old Ride the Subway Alone," described her making the controversial decision to let her son take the New York City Subway home alone, which was completed without incident.
- jimktrains2 8y ago> High density living in cities is dreadful for providing enough outdoors / free activity space for kids to be kids This is simply so untrue, that's it's laughable. High density, urban spaces have by-and-lqege more opportunities and places for kids than the hellhole that is the exurbs and most of the post war suburbs.
- bunderbunder 8y agoMy city, Chicago, is packed with playgrounds. There are four within a ten minute walk of my house. If we want to go further afield, there are also several larger parks with a bit more room to run around. Some of the community gardens set aside space for kids to play in the dirt, and the Park District is starting to get in on the "natural playscapes" thing. Our apartment building has its own patio space, a reasonably large butterfly garden, and some gardening plots in the back yard. We've set aside one of the garden plots for the kids to do whatever they want in (last summer's cherry tomato harvest was a sight to see), and turned another into a sandbox. We spend lots and lots of time outside in those sorts of communal spaces. For my part, I feel sorry for kids living in these intensively inward-facing suburban environments where there are no sidewalks or community spaces, and kids are dependent on adults with cars to help them get together with their friends.
- pulisse 8y ago> Growing up, I have memories of my dad building things around the house (including our cubby house), having a sandpit etc. How do you do any of that in an apartment in the city? How do you even have reasonable transit distances to places you can do those things? I walk across the street to the municipal park, where there's not only a playground, but also open outdoor spaces that people use for (to cite things I've observed this weekend) picnics, childrens' birthday parties, pickup sports, martial arts classes, playing frisbee with dogs, and general horsing around. There are smaller parks with playgrounds every 3 blocks or so in my part of town. People raised in a stereotypical American suburb (as I was) tend not to grow up with common spaces that people use for individual purposes. It can be easy to end up equating space that's useful with space that one has exclusive use of, and so assume that city dwellers must be deprived.
- astura 8y agoThis is insane... High density living provides a whole childhood of activities, both formal and informal. I grew up in a midsized city, when I was a kid I could walk, bus, or ride my bike literally anywhere I wanted to go without really any notable restrictions, including parks with sandpits. My parents kept a draw full of bus schedules. The best part is there were literally kids everywhere, so you were never lonely even if you left the house alone. We'd organize pick-up games of soccer or baseball or kickball, etc. I even went ice skating by myself. Sometimes I'd just walk outside during the summer just to see which of the "neighborhood kids" were out. I'd spend hours just exploring the city on foot or bike, so much so that I'd come home with sore legs. All snow storms were followed by sledding in the park. I spent very little time with my parents. When we got older it was mall and movies, record stores, arcades. We also had a back yard, shared between six families. Sometimes my parents would even send me on errands for them. I had an after school job starting at 16 and I'd never be able to if I had to be driven there, my dad was always home, but without a car. I'd take the bus there. I was rarely home, it was amazing. Compare that to the suburbs or rural areas where the only way to get anywhere is a parent driving a kid somewhere. Sounds stifling. My parents would never shuffle me around everywhere. (In fact, I didn't even care for it as an adult, sometimes I just wanted to go for a walk! But leaving required a car, no sidewalks, traffic much too fast for a bike)
- throwaway287391 8y agoWow, thanks for sharing your actual experience. When I made my sibling comment (about being jealous of city kids as a burbs kid) I admittedly thought it was probably at least a bit of a "grass is greener" thing, but "great" to have confirmation that the burbs really are as relatively bad as I thought. :|
- DrScump 8y agoI could walk, bus, or ride my bike literally anywhere ... Compare that to the suburbs or rural areas I'm perplexed at why someone would think that urban biking is safer than suburban biking.
- dagw 8y agoCompare that to the suburbs I grew up in the suburbs. All my friends where within walking or biking distance, as was the local library. There was a small forest less than 5 minutes walk from our house we could explore, as well a nice sledding hill. There was a small field at the end of the road that had a couple of soccer goals. The 'big city' was ~30 minutes away by bus. When I got a bit older they even opened a mall within 20 minute bike ride of where we lived. Basically whether a place is "good for kids" is entirely orthogonal to if its urban or suburban.
- dagw 8y agoI recently moved with my family from 'high density' living in the city to the suburbs and the truth is that the city actually had more outdoors / free activity space for kids, than where I'm currently at. There where at least 3 playground within easy walking distance of our apartment in the city, a school yard with outdoor basketball courts kids could play on after hours, plus a large city park/botanical garden with huge open spaces a 5 minute bus ride/ 20 minute walk away.