7 ms·
Why don't gazzilionaires start their own countries?
All of thee guys don't have to work anymore.. Bill, Steve, Larry, Sergey and Mark.
They have the funds and contacts to do it..
So why has no-one tried to start a small country?
- jbverschoor 16y agoOfcourse, it should have a really nice tld..
- TamDenholm 16y ago.gaz?
- spindritf 16y agoMaybe they're content with their influence over existing countries?
- marchdown 16y agoStill strange how they don't systematically work to further their influence and improve community. There is place for non-violent restructuring of corrupt governments from the inside.
- locopati 16y agoWhy would they want to reduce corruption when it serves them so well?
- marchdown 16y agoBecause corrupt system is ineffective system. If they have enough influence to control the system through and through, enough resources fine-tune it to serve their ends, enough involvement to subvert it, why would they put up with ineffectiveness in their system. In a way, all rulers face this battle, and tyrants seem to have easier time with it than elected leaders.
- sad_hacker 16y agoThere are no undiscovered or unclaimed islands to start a new country. Existing countries are protecting their sovereignty and territorial integrity... in theory you can "build" a new country... an island, 22 km/14 miles from the border (territorial waters). Probably it's expensive. There are many micronations: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_micronations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_micronations Why gazzilionaires haven't started one - I don't know, probably their life is good enough to enjoy it in countries that already exist. If anyone wants to start a new country and has budget - let me know. In the beginning we can make money by selling domain names, if ICAAN approves us. So we need to pick a good name for our country to get a decent domain name and make shitloads of money.
- sad_hacker 16y agoWe can also become a nation of internet freedom... we can get loads of investments from people who want to move server parks to our territory to be protected from other governments and evil censors.
- ojilles 16y agoSounds like Cryptonomicon :)
- arethuza 16y agoOr Daemon & Freedom
- flexd 16y agoCould in theory lay down your own fibre to several major countries and have a underwater datacenter somewhere, taking advantage of cool water for cooling? Lots of cool engineering could be done to keep it going. Power would be a issue but it could be solved. Would be kind of cool. And since it's offshore nothing can be done right? They could cut of the internet connections, but that would have to be solved by multiple secret lines to different countries/areas and possibly via satellites? I'm just theorycrafting here :D
- 16y ago
- baguasquirrel 16y agoMaybe they don't think politics is fun?
- jasonkester 16y agoThey have: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principality_of_Sealand http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principality_of_Sealand It's not a very good idea.
- rdl 16y agoThe Sealand people weren't rich; they were middle-class pirate radio people who were just trying to do commercial radio in the 60s. (I lived there for 2 years 2000-2002, and the general condition of the place was fairly poor at the start and at the end)
- MurkyPast 16y agoWait, you lived in/on Sealand? I'd love to know how you ended up living there.
- rdl 16y agohttp://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.07/haven.html http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.07/haven.html I don't know if I can say "I was on the cover of Wired" correctly, since it was an aerial shot of Sealand out of proportion on a globe, with 7 of us standing on the helideck; I'm probably about 4 pixels.
- allenbrunson 16y agoholy cow, you must be Ryan Lackey. Apparently you aren't doing Blue Iraq anymore?
- rdl 16y agoYes. Yes, I'm working on an actual technology startup now vs. defense contracting. It is difficult to quantify how happy I am to not be in Iraq/Afghanistan/Kuwait/etc. anymore (or, for that matter, living on a 10k sf 60 year old disintegrating concrete platform). I am in Thailand and Bali for the rest of 2010 SCUBA diving, but after that will move back to the US to be near customers.
- 16y ago
- iwr 16y agoFor one, there are almost(?) no unclaimed patches of land available. If you look at a political map of the Pacific, most of it is locked up between the EEZ of various states and micro-states. http://www.spc.int/aquaculture/images/stories/dfatpacific%202.gif http://www.spc.int/aquaculture/images/stories/dfatpacific%20... Most of these countries are also very poor (Africa levels) and heavy recipients of foreign aid. So politically, they are corrupt and inaccessible. So the best bet is to build an oil-rig styled structure or a large ocean-going ship. However, both options go into the hundreds of millions to the billions; a super-rich individual is naturally mobile, so he doesn't need a fixed patch of land that he politically rules. That said, you may be interested in this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasteading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasteading
- philk 16y agoA number of reasons: 1) Starting their own country wouldn't offer them much they don't already have. 2) There's no unclaimed land. That means you either need to build your own land (which is really expensive) or take it off someone else, which probably makes you a criminal around the world and might ruin your life already. 3) Once you've got the land, you've got to defend it, and mercs[1] + military hardware gets expensive really fast. 4) Even then, the nasty things you'd have to do to establish a country and get it recognized around the world will probably cripple your commercial activities. 5) They don't necessarily have much ability for governing/retaining power. [1] No-one is going to die for Gatestan out of patriotism.
- sad_hacker 16y agoI doubt you need to defend it right away... if you get more powerful - yes, why should anyone want to attack your micronation? They rather do it in diplomatical way so other countries don't recognize your sovereignty.
- arethuza 16y agoAn American billionaire or (billionaires) sitting on a completely undefended island somewhere... Don't you think that would be a magnet to just about every terrorist organization in the world? Not to mention if it is anywhere near East Africa I would image a few boat loads of real pirates turning up pretty quickly - even in a lot of what would look like safer neighborhoods I would expect you would start getting a lot of attention from organized crime and other very scary people.
- salvadors 16y agoActually there is still some unclaimed land: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marie_Byrd_Land http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marie_Byrd_Land I'm sure at least one of these guys might enjoy the challenge of making it hospitable :)
- Tichy 16y agoInteresting. I'd wage a guess that making it hospitable would at least be easier than colonizing Mars.
- jbverschoor 16y agoOk.. But they could just buy out a small country, but that would mean no clean start. Or they could build something in the ocean Is military really necessary??
- HeyLaughingBoy 16y agoOf course military is necessary. Once you have something, someone is going to want to take it from you.Or have thousands of years of history taught us nothing?
- peterlada 16y agoUmm, Switzerland??? Significant portion of gold deposits, highest standard of living, etc. Nobody seems to want it though. Their "army" is a few thousand tops. Their vehicle is a Mercedes Benz G Class, seesh.
- arethuza 16y agoWhat a truly awful example. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_Switzerland http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_Switzerland "The armed forces consist of 134,886 people on active duty" The Swiss have a centuries long reputation for being pretty tough - (that's why the Pope chose to have Swiss Guards). Military service is mandatory. "Switzerland has one of the highest militia gun ownership rates in the world." They are probably the only country in the world that has blast and fallout shelters for rather more than 100% of its population. And have you actually seen the landscape of Switzerland - it's the European version of Afghanistan.
- nickpinkston 16y agoYea, there's a reason the Nazi's never tried invading... Today, every able male has an an assault rifle and is required to maintain their marksmanship - which is a national past-time with +200m ranges in most towns. There are hidden underground airfields, people trained/armed to blow up tunnels at a moments notice. Add to that crazy terrain, weather, a homogeneous/close-knit population, a distributes governance structure, etc. - you get the one of the most defendable country's EVER!
- numair 16y agoDon't confuse the skills/intellect/resources necessary to be a successful platform developer with the skills/intellect/resources necessary to be a successful platform operator/provider.
- mooism2 16y agoWhy would they want to?
- rubidium 16y agoexactly. Despite all the discussion about the difficulties of founding a country, the biggest reason is there is no motivating factor big enough to do so. They have a society, people and places in which they have been successful. Why leave that?
- dageshi 16y agoI think rich people found a better alternative years ago. They're called yachts.
- petervandijck 16y agoNo, the better alternative is called lobbying.
- robryan 16y agoAh this is one of those things I've always thought would be a great idea in theory. Would be interesting to see if you could get a poor but large country to sell a large chunk of uninhabited land. I don't think military is required, if you can afford the land your contacts probably put you in a better situation than many poor nations.
- zokier 16y agoThere was a reality based movie about a British millionaire trying to take over a small African country. Somebody probably could tell the details about that. But I think that nobody runs their own country because it just sucks. And they all have already had far greater power and leverage via their companies than what they could imagine getting via own country. But it's still strange that the gazillionares do not use their money on larger projects. Well, Google does all kind of interesting stuff. One thing I have thought would be cool would be building a completely new internet infrastructure to US, bringing 100Mbps speeds to every house and taking a huge step towards IPv6.
- hitonagashi 16y agoThe Dogs of War by Frederick Forsyth I assume...I've got and read the book, but not seen the film.
- randallsquared 16y agoThere was a reality based movie about a British millionaire trying to take over a small African country. Somebody probably could tell the details about that. Interestingly, it was more recently used as inspiration for another attempted takeover, and Margaret Thatcher's son ended up being involved on some level. _The Wonga Coup_ was a fascinating account of this. Apparently they're making a movie of that, to come full circle.
- zokier 16y agoActually, it was the movie I was thinking of: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0783498/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0783498/ Full circle completed?
- randallsquared 16y agoFull circle completed? More like a spiral: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0876570/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0876570/ The movie I was talking about is apparently not yet released, though on the same subject. Hm.
- arethuza 16y agoGo to Mars - cheaper, easier and probably far more rewarding. So say you do really want to do it - even with say $100 billion will that really buy you enough land, infrastructure and pay everyone you need to have a fully functioning independent country until it becomes self supporting? I don't think you could set up a self supporting first world equivalent country for $100 billion even if you did have some decent land available (and there is none spare at the moment). What about the government and legal system - is it going to be a full democracy? If not then expect to be pretty unpopular in the international community and if it is then why bother - who says the public will support your policies in your new country? If it isn't then expect some expensive, not particularly loyal and fairly heavy handed security forces who will probably instigate a coup d'etat within six months of the country being founded. All the billionaires you mention have got there by being very smart - setting up their own country would be about the stupidest thing you could do.
- eru 16y agoAre you talking about establishing a thriving colony on Mars, or just a visit?
- weavejester 16y agoCheaper?
- arethuza 16y ago
- AlecDonut 16y agoIn a gazzilionaire-country there would be no true wealth - just numbers!
- peterlada 16y agoInstead of that they could just support seceding California -Oregon-Washington from the union. They all live here anyway. It'd have about 50% of the economy and 99% of the innovation. No more bailing out the falling empire.
- patrickk 16y agoA wacky, somewhat related prediction that didn't come true: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123051100709638419.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123051100709638419.html (scroll to the end for an infographic)
- patrickgzill 16y agoThey could call it .. COW-Town ...
- s3graham 16y agoI think the standard proposal is "United States of Canada".
- peterlada 16y agoT is negative, but the concept of nation states is obsolete. It will be very apparent in 20-30 years. I'd not invest my wealth in nostalgia.
- mike_esspe 16y agoLately, i often hear this prediction. What is the source of this optimism?
- ebaysucks 16y agoThe evolution of communications vs military technology. The world is becoming more interconnected and subject to shocks. Reputation systems will thus have to become increasingly efficient. A statist legal system is a monopolistic claim on managing reputation, but its inadequacy will become too costly to maintain. Competitive solutions for reputation management will arise - the semantic web. Law by force will be gradually replaced by law by reputations. If the tacit acceptance of the legal system fades away, so does the power of the state.
- rdgb2 16y agoI don't see the 'tacit acceptance of the legal system' fading away because of the internet. That sounds very 1996. There will always be a 'state' of some kind, in the sense of a monopoly on the forces of coercion. Your life can become as virtual as you like, but there will always be physical police who can knock on your door. In general though, the state will fade from relevance as you say -- but not to the point of 'obsolescence'.
- riffraff 16y agohow is evolution of military technology slower than evolutions in communication? I mean, what scale exists to measure that? And how does it cause nation-states to be obsolete, if something we have many proofs that improving communication means allow nation-states to become larger.
- 16y ago
- wladimir 16y agoI'm sure this will come as soon as 'real' countries start to fall apart, and the age of city-states will begin...
- hootmon 16y agoThe primary expense of any government is security, both local and national. Police and Military. Protect the property of the individual. Why should Bill and his buddies pay for an army when we do it for them? Taxes should be based on value received, which means that those with the most property get the most value, so they should pay the highest taxes, but in our country the opposite is in practice. We working stiffs, with very little property, pay the lion;s share of the police and military budget. ,
- rdl 16y agoFundamentally, I think because the super-rich have great quality of life and freedom in most countries. They do tend to emigrate out of bad places (Russia, etc.) where they made their fortunes and move to places like the US and UK where they can comfortably enjoy them. If you have $10b in assets, paying 20-30% taxes on your annual investment income ($500mm to $1b/yr capital gains, so maybe a few hundred million in taxes) in exchange for first-world quality of life is quite worthwhile. You can always use offshore vehicles to defer recognizing gains, too. Once you're already wealthy, there is a lot less reason to care about taxes on income.
- mseebach 16y agoIf your citizenship allows it, you can even just place your investments and the income from it in a tax haven and only pay taxes on the money you bring into the country to consume (which won't work with US citizenships since they claim taxes on your worldwide income). Even your house can (probably) be owned by an overseas holding company. If you keep travelling, it's even easier. As I understand it, if you're a non-dom in Britain (ie. not a British citizen, but residenced there), they don't care about income earned outside the country (your investment holding company in the Bahamas) and any money you spend outside of Britain.
- yuxt 16y agoThis utopian concept has been exaggerated by Ayn Rand in "Atlas Shrugged" when many successful entrepreneurs has moved away to start their own country.
- dantheman 16y agoActually in Atlas Shrugged, the men of the mind go on strike. They do not start their own country, they remove themselves to a safe place, a hiding spot of it you will, and wait for the crash so that can come back and rebuild society correctly from first principles. The goal was never to create their own country, it was to correct what is wrong with the US.
- ebaysucks 16y agoPeter Thiel has funded The Seasteading Institute by Patri Friedman. Their goal is not to start a country, but to allow anybody to do so.
- patrickgzill 16y agoDairy farmers farm cows. Hog farmers farm pigs. Billionaires farm people. Why would an active farmer, want to move away from his farm?
- PostOnce 16y agoRe-read this comment. Let it sink in. People read comments and keep scrolling, they're all just comments. Sometimes you have to stop and reflect when actual wisdom is conveyed. Large customer bases, people. Build them. Zuckerberg, Chad Hurley, Sergey Brin & Larry Page, these people all have customers bases that number in the hundreds of millions or billions. You get to be a billionaire by marketing to billions of people.
- rbonvall 16y agoIt has always been the other way around: people try to own countries in order to have a gazzilionaire-like lifestyle.
- Apreche 16y agoIt's easier to just incorporate a town. This has been done many times before, such as Celebration, FL.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- duffbeer703 16y agoThere are actually some proposals out there to build extra-national trade cities in Africa to encourage Western-style development, minus the intense corruption of African governments.
- jackfoxy 16y agoBecause it would make them a target of vilification. It's much wiser to put a big chunk of your assets into a charitable trust and talk about raising taxes on the rich. That opens doors simply being rich does not.
- mjgoins 16y agoThis is what rich white men in Europe already did. It was called Imperialism.
- nickpinkston 16y agoPaul Romer has a similar idea called "Charter Cities" which would be independent areas in existing countries. Good TED talk on it: http://www.ted.com/talks/paul_romer.html http://www.ted.com/talks/paul_romer.html
- sabj 16y agoAs soon as I am a gazillionaire, I will do this. It will be my opportunity to test out all the theories I have learned in my political science studies.