3 ms·
He was just a quiet man who had tried to do the right thing in the face of an inferno. And maybe that is enough. Speaking as a former firefighter, I would say
by mindcrime 8y ago
He was just a quiet man who had tried to do the right thing in the face of an inferno. And maybe that is enough.
Speaking as a former firefighter, I would say "Yes. Yes, that is enough."
As far as I'm concerned, anybody who runs towards a fire in an attempt to help others, when everyone else is running away, is a hero. Doesn't matter if you're "officially" a firefighter, or anything else. If you display the behavior, the willingness to sacrifice, the bravery, of a firefighter, then you are one of the brotherhood. And if you pay the ultimate sacrifice in the process, you are a hero to be cherished, whether you saved 10 people, or none.
And before anybody says it... yes, I know the old saw about "not becoming another casualty, and one more person to be rescued" as well as anyone. I used to teach that stuff. But at the end of the day, while we might not want civilians or untrained/unequipped people running into fires, you still have to respect and honor the courage of the people who are willing to do that.
- paulddraper 8y agoThe article does point out that "Nothing in the official record suggests his motivation." But agreed on all points.
- roel_v 8y agoThat's not what this story is about though (admittedly IM sometime not so HO). It's about how seemingly small mistakes end up shaping an entirely made version of history, even at a time when clickbait listicles and Russian troll farms didn't control public discourse yet. If some immaterial detail like this was so grossly wrong, what else is wrong? Is there no way to trust anything we read? What is the value of decades of archives of websites and newspapers when nobody has any incentive to correct or maintain any of it? Is it time to start building a 'web of trust' for information 'chunks', as the original PGP set out to do in the 90's for people? Should we just acknowledge that we've lost the battle on 'finding the Truth'? Those are more material questions that whether or not this one guy saved 0 or 10 people 20 years ago, and whether that warrants a motorcycle tribute ride to be named after him.
- mindcrime 8y agoThat's not what this story is about though (admittedly IM sometime not so HO). I would agree that that's not all the story is about. It just happens the be the part that touched a nerve for me. Otherwise, I don't disagree with you. I think there are a lot of open questions about understanding the nature of "truth" on the web these days. Is it time to start building a 'web of trust' for information 'chunks', as the original PGP set out to do in the 90's for people? Good question. Skeptics will say that this approach has been proven to not work. I might counter that we just haven't figured out how to get the details right yet.
- roel_v 8y ago"I would agree that that's not all the story is about. It just happens the be the part that touched a nerve for me." Fair enough, I guess we agree then :)
- kgwxd 8y ago"If some immaterial detail like this was so grossly wrong, what else is wrong?" Most likely everything. That is why any information that isn't reproducible should be considered just a story, nothing more. There might be some value to take away from it, but nothing much better than what you can get from fiction. I don't get how anyone that has played Telephone can take history seriously, there's just no chance of getting an accurate version. Even news from yesterday, with recorded audio and video, doesn't capture enough to get important details right.
- Dylan16807 8y ago"Don't even try to know" is a pretty bad mindset to apply to every event that has ever happened.
- bostik 8y agoWell, there are three truths. 1. What really happened. 2. How the people involved remember it. 3. How it gets recorded. The potential for gross distortion between steps is a fact, but that doesn't necessarily mean everything you read or hear is false. And indeed, details are the first thing to get twisted. It's usually (or, "often enough") the major themes that survive. Assuming that everything is a lie means you're paranoid. Assuming that everybody lies means you're sensible. How truth survives through that is left as an exercise for the reader.