3 ms·
A. Do you have any references/evidence saying that this is the legal doctrine being used? B. Civil Forfeiture is indeed evil and dubious. IF it were expanded a
by joe_the_user 16y ago
A. Do you have any references/evidence saying that this is the legal doctrine being used?
B. Civil Forfeiture is indeed evil and dubious. IF it were expanded and applied to everything to which one could imagine, we would indeed be living in dictatorship. It's kind of a bleeding whole in rule-of-law, one that hasn't been expanded too much recently - I could only wildly speculate that they hadn't wanted negative attention for it. In any case, this is a good reason to be against it.
- pasbesoin 16y agoPerhaps I've been the victim of hyperbole, but I've read and heard of numerous instances where asset seizure has been and is used to fund a significant portion of the seizing authority's budget. If that doesn't have the potential for "conflict of interest" written all over it, I don't know what does.
- tptacek 16y agoYou realize of course that you're only going to hear about the asset forfeiture cases where the process is abused. The rest of the cases --- which vastly outnumber the abuses --- are boring. Moreover, virtually every abuse case I've read about has occurred on a local (sometimes even municipal) level. Have you read a lot about federal law enforcement abusing asset forfeiture procedures?
- tptacek 16y agoIf you read the story, look at the landing page ICE set up on the seized domains, and then Google the two US Code references on that page, you'll see they were both civil forfeiture statutes. You write as if your understanding of asset forfeiture was "the government can simply take whatever it wants whenever it wants". That isn't the case at all. It's called "civil" forfeiture because the government is suing for the property. There's a court case and everything. It is, essentially, the exact opposite of what the article we're commenting on claims it is.
- hga 16y agoNo, the government is suing the property: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture#United_States Yes, you read that correctly. As in USA v. $124,700: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USA_v._$124,700 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USA_v._$124,700 Follow the "jurisdiction in rem" link for more about how this ... unique doctrine developed: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jurisdiction_in_rem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jurisdiction_in_rem
- tptacek 16y agoAnd the first example of the doctrine provided on the Wikipedia page dates to (drum roll) 1828.
- joe_the_user 16y agoYou write as if your understanding of asset forfeiture was "the government can simply take whatever it wants whenever it wants". That isn't the case at all. It's called "civil" forfeiture because the government is suing for the property. Taking "whatever they can get away with" is quite different from "whatever they want". Whether authorized by a judge or not, a procedure involving "take first then you've got to sue us", is a violation of the basic rule of law - the requirement to face your accuser before any property can be taken. This goes back to the constitution and even the Magna Carta. I mean, There was no service or trial in the situation described. Judge-authorization for lawless act is just a dodge Otherwise, we'll go the system of "Judge Dred" ("Judge, Jury and executioner") http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judge_Dredd http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judge_Dredd
- tptacek 16y agoThis seems kind of silly to me. On approximately the same evidentiary standard, any law enforcement order could achieve a warrant for arrest and directly deprive the operators of these sites of their liberties. Here, all they lost was their domain name. I'm not interested in an argument about civil forfeiture, not least because we probably already agree more than we disagree (but nobody will know that because now the Magna Carta has been invoked and there's not enough oxygen left in the capsule for both of us). I'm just saying, this isn't some crazy new censorship regime dreamed up by the RIAA and the DHS. This is absolutely part of Customs' charter.