9 ms·
Majority of health apps on Android tested shared personal health data
- blastbeat 8y ago> Clinicians should be conscious about the choices they make in relation to their app use and, when recommending apps to consumers, explain the potential for loss of personal privacy as part of informed consent. That's for me the most important point of that study. It's no good if you avoid data kraken where you can, and meanwhile your physician unwittingly distributes your sensitive data via the latest health app.
- 0xDEFC0DE 8y agoMy only critique of this is that clinicians in the US may be under large organizational umbrellas and may be strongly encouraged (forced?) to go through apps chosen by the org, and so they aren't really making any conscious choices. (TBF the paper authors are affiliated with Sydney, Toronto, and California Universities so those healthcare systems are likely different)
- c048 8y agoIf it's free, you are the product.
- bspammer 8y agoMost open-source software being the exception
- hamburglar1 8y agoif you contribute, you are in a way the product still
- organsnyder 8y agoWouldn't that make you the manufacturer?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- swebs 8y agoExcept for the 5/24 apps that didn't share user data.
- birksherty 8y agoWrong. You can buy a product and still be a product.
- rorykoehler 8y agoIn Singapore the health insurance companies have programs to get people to wear health trackers for a discount and people are oblivious as to why this may not be the best idea/ alignment of interests.
- blastbeat 8y agoSame trend here in Germany.
- mrtksn 8y agoThis, of course, brings in the devices that shake the trackers just right[0], to scam the companies(I remember reading about it being a thing in the USA). I would guess that if this gets mainstream, insurance companies may purchase user data from other apps to cross-check users lifestyle and deny claims where the user appears to be jogging on the insurance app but sleeping according to the totally free and fun sleep tracking app. [0] Phone rockers, like that: https://shopee.sg/Phone-Steps-Tracking-Rocker-i.7049223.951158722 https://shopee.sg/Phone-Steps-Tracking-Rocker-i.7049223.9511...
- robjan 8y agoTbh, the insurance representatives even tell you which fitness trackers are best for gaming the system. Mine said to buy an Xiaomi as it adds an extra 20% and costs a lot less.
- mrtksn 8y ago:) Of course my dystopian scenario holds only if these trackers were taken seriously. Maybe at this stage, it’s just a way to promote a discount.
- stirfrykitty 8y agoI also cannot help but see the dystopian outcome here, especially in a profit-driven system. "Sir, we see your REM sleep is not being fully entered into most nights. Our system has indicated that you buy caffeine and pizzas multiple days a week. This will be reported." "Sir, we are denying your life insurance application because our insurance "partners" have determined you are a risk we cannot afford." Etc., etc. I will never willingly wear a tracker that reports health data. I will never willingly be chipped. Nothing of that sort. I always tell people to pay cash for their peccadilloes. Never use "loyalty" cards, as the info is sold to all manner of companies, including insurance companies. Banks sell "anonymized" data about your buying habits as well. And no one seems to be anything other than completely and utterly apathetic...
- blub 8y agoAnd this is why laws like the GDPR are needed: "Journalists recently revealed that Australia’s most popular medical appointment booking app, HealthEngine, routinely shared 100s of users’ private medical information to personal injury law firms as part of a referral partnership contract.1 Although the company claimed this was only done with users’ consent, these practices were not included in the privacy policy but in a separate “collection notice,” and there was no opportunity for users to opt-out if they wished to use the application (app)." Too bad most of the worst offenders are in the US or other countries with non-existing privacy laws.
- marcinzm 8y agoThe US has HIPAA which while not perfect would cover any medical data sharing and does have decently sized fines behind it.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The US has HIPAA which while not perfect would cover any medical data sharing and does have decently sized fines behind it. Because HealthEngine looks like it has business relationships with providers, it would probably be covered by HIPAA through provider BAAs in the US. But if it only had a business relationship with the consumer, ala Google Duplex, and handled medical bookings on the consumer's behalf that would not be the case. So even though the specific case would enjoy covered by HIPAA in the US, it is illustrative of a problem HIPAA may not be adequate to address. HIPAA may actually be dangerous here, because what lay awareness of it exists seems to see it as protecting health data generally, when it only protects health data held by certain entities, and consumer-facing entities that don't have a business relationship with your health provider or insurer aren't covered, and there are plenty of them trying to vacuum up health data.
- chicob 8y agoI also wonder how drugstores manage all the patients' data. For my part, I pay in cash, and never give personally identifiable information unless strictly necessary.
- smt88 8y agoDoesn't help if they have your prescription saved in a database
- marcinzm 8y agoIn the US a drugstore's information falls under HIPAA which isn't perfect but does force some compliance at risk of large fines. HIPAA basically doesn't allow identified information to be shared except specifically related to treating or paying for your illness. Unlike a fly by night app a drugstore has a physical presence which means that tracking them down to fine is easier.
- gumby 8y agoLook up prescription surveillance, prescription drug monitoring programs, and the companies that sell prescription data to see how “private” your private prescription info is.