12 ms·
For all of human history, we've been making music and art. And for almost all of that time, it was done for love of doing, not money. For a few hundred years,
by jedberg 8y ago
For all of human history, we've been making music and art. And for almost all of that time, it was done for love of doing, not money.
For a few hundred years, there was the patronage era, where if you were really good you could get a rich person to feed and clothe and house you while you made art. Or you traveled around giving performances for money or food or clothes or shelter.
Then only in the last 100ish years has it been possible to make art for mass consumption (and mass money), but that's only because of artificial scarcity.
Now that the scarcity is gone, we are back to patronage (see Patreon) and making money from the performance of music, by doing live shows and such.
I think people making money making music was an aberration in history, not "the way it should be".
- RankingMember 8y agoWell put, your description of the history of paid art puts things in a different perspective.
- Pfhreak 8y ago> For all of human history, we've been making music and art. And for almost all of that time, it was done for love of doing, not money. This seems wildly improbable to me? People didn't get paid for art until a few hundred years ago? Are you suggesting artisans weren't a thing? That all the art produced globally outside of the past few hundred years was done just for love of doing?
- skookumchuck 8y agoI've never heard of artisans getting wealthy before the 20th century.
- Pfhreak 8y ago"Wealthy" is a different goalpost than "doing art/music for money". But even then, artisans in antiquity definitely reached middle classes. (And it's plausible to assume that at least a few individuals were wealthier or converted their artisanship into a bigger merchant operation.)
- usrusr 8y agoSure, but isn't wealthy the undertone that goes into all these laments that music does not pay anymore? (the original doesn't seems much like a lament though, I read it more like a counter to those laments) The whole "Let your creative juices flow, somehow gain access to recording equipment and distribution, have a hit record, be made for life", that's mostly over it seems. But it hasn't been with us for that long to begin with. Except for those brief few decades of industrial recording, getting paid for music has always been hard. Depending on economical overall productivity (excess food for entertainment specialists), maybe some or even a relatively high number of musicians would get paid, but hardly ever (or more likely "never"?) so much that their incomes would be envied by productive middle class, including artisans in decorative fields. Remember that before recording (well, before printed scores), music was entirely transient, whereas the products of artisans would routinely be investments in intergenerational status.
- anigbrowl 8y agoWedgewood pottery. Charles Dickens.
- ken 8y agoNot even Antonio Stradivari?
- mrj 8y agoPeople got paid, but there wasn't a way to reproduce art for basically nothing but sell it as if it was the original. That radically changed the economics of music for a period, which could be seen as a distortion and not the way things should be. OP is now lamenting (right or wrong) that system is gone, only the live performance really still exists as a money maker.
- Animats 8y agoRight. The OP's lament is heard from other musicians of his age. Being In A Band used to be a Big Deal. Fame, fortune, groupies. Then came lower cost equipment, Myspace, and streaming. At peak there were several million bands on Myspace.
- jedberg 8y ago> Are you suggesting artisans weren't a thing? Historically, anyone who made something by hand was an artisan, so the hammer maker and the sword maker. I suppose you could consider that art, but when I say I art I'm talking music, paining, sculpture, etc. Things that only have aesthetic use, not functional use. And I don't believe there are any examples of people making aesthetic works as their only source of income before recent times, other than through patronage. I've only studied art history briefly though, someone who has studied it more could probably chime in here.
- Pfhreak 8y agoGrecian pots are covered in paintings. Greek and roman sculpture was considered one of the highest forms of art by Pliny. Pliny said this of Peiraikos: It is well to add an account of the artists who won fame with the brush in painting smaller pictures. Amongst them was Peiraikos. In mastery of his art but few take rank above him, yet by his choice of a path he has perhaps marred his own success, for he followed a humble line, winning however the highest glory that it had to bring. He painted barbers' shops, cobblers' stalls, asses, eatables and similar subjects, earning for himself the name of rhyparographos [painter of dirt/low things]. In these subjects he could give consummate pleasure, selling them for more than other artists received for their large pictures. Polygnotus? Apollodorus? Zeuxis and Parrhasius? That's drawing just from Greek history.
- marshray 8y agoYeah I bet the 300+ year history of Ancient Greece has several examples of famous artists being well paid.
- ken 8y agoThis sounds like an artificial distinction, drawn there only to make the point you want to make. A hammer isn't art, because a hammer is functional, and a decorative handle on it is part of that non-art. A wall isn't art, because a wall is functional, yet a fresco painted on it is art?
- pmoriarty 8y ago
- RugnirViking 8y agoFor most of human history, MONEY wasn't a thing. And yet we still have cave paintings as well as clear evidence that tribepeople and pre-agricultaral societies made music, art, poetry and more. Consider that this time could have been spent building shelter, or hunting for food. We make art because we enjoy it
- Pfhreak 8y agoYou misunderstand my point. I never said we do art only for money. I specifically objected to the idea that artists have only been able to do art for the money for the past few hundred years. Sumeria had coinage thousands of years before common era. So money has definitely been a thing for more than a few hundred years.
- adrian_b 8y agoThey did not have coinage, but they already had prices and also professional musicians (besides other non-producing professionals which appeared there for the first time, i.e. judges, medical doctors, accountants and prostitutes) (obviously, chiefs and priests existed much time before written history). Initially the prices were expressed as weights of precious metals. The coins, which allowed simpler payments, without the use of weighing scales, appeared thousands of years later after the prices, probably in Lydia in the first millennium BC.
- Theodores 8y agoYes. There is this question of 'what is art'? and we can assume that old cave paintings are 'art' but is it really? Is that just us assuming this is 'art'? Art as we know it really is a capitalist contrivance. Sure the communists had art too but do native people outside of regular capitalism have 'art'? In Canada they tried to get an art exhibition together of native people's art. It didn't really happen. They tried teaching them how to make art but they didn't get it. This was not because the native folk were primitive and backward, far from it. They had plenty of beautiful things they made as part of their daily existence. However, they did not see the world mediated through images and capitalism. They weren't worshipping icons either. Before capitalism as we know it took over the church had all the power and art was invariably made on some Bible oriented theme. Nobody painted scenes of rural peasant life, it was always the baby Jesus. I am sure that everyone puts some art into what they do. Writing code is an art. The medium just isn't brown pots or watercolours. Code is a creative medium though. Music is an interesting one as we all grew up at a time when we partied for fun. The guy sorting out the music was just contributing to it. Then we grow up and meet musician friends. And yes, all of them are out to make money, it isn't just about the music any more. It probably had more to do with sex first time around so even then it wasn't entirely just about the music. This is why music is not at all useful for revolutionary or activist causes. There aren't many John Lennon's in the world willing to stay in bed for peace. Sometimes I hear of musicians I listened to many aeons ago and wonder when it is they will get a proper job. Years ago it was about the music, now it is about paying for the kids to go to private schools. Most of what we know of as art because it commands price tags is 'art business'. This is just a game and the likes of Damien Hirst know how it is played.
- empath75 8y agoI don’t know of anyone who has made any worthwhile music who did it to make money. You’d be an idiot to do it for the money, even in the golden age of music labels. The vast majority of musicians made nothing and a few got super wealthy. You had to practice for years, putting aside any other career in order for a small chance to get discovered. Now once you’re discovered and you have a career, you might continue to do it for the money, but nobody starts there and by then you’re already a talented musician, having done most of the hard work of learning to make music with no real financial incentive at all. Now people can work on music part time for years as a hobby and just throw it out there and if it’s good people will find it and maybe they’ll get asked to do a gig here and there and that might be enough for them.
- jedberg 8y agoYou think Brittany Spears made music because she loves music? Or the Backstreet Boys? Or pretty much any K-Pop band these days? They're all out there because a record person wanted to sell personas.
- saberience 8y agoThat's a pretty cynical attitude you have there. You should try listening to all of the acapella recordings of Brittany Spears, or all of the videos of her singing and performing as a child. As a child who was forced to play piano (and other instruments), in my opinion, you cannot force a child to become a "Brittany Spears," they have to want it too, or they will never perform and work hard enough to make it. Brittany Spears, whatever you think of her, clearly loves singing and performing. The fact that you have this attitude either shows you have zero understanding of human nature or just are a very negative and cynical person. Either way, it's a sucky attitude.
- jedberg 8y agoShe's a talented singer, but they forced her to change her range higher to fit the "cute little girl" package. So while she may enjoy music, she changed her music to make more money. And now she's changed it back and it's better, but she's already successful so she can take risks now.
- TheRealDunkirk 8y agoYou're right, of course. Unfortunately, this applies to a lot more fields than just music performance, and society is really going to struggle to sort out living in the post-scarcity economy. Also, the-once revolutionary "long tail" now makes choice so individualistic, and effectively arbitrary, that it's hard to capitalize on any particular genre or act.
- criddell 8y agoSales of recorded music are way down but every other part of the music industry has grown. If this is the pattern that other fields follow, then we're all going to be rich! Has there ever been a better time to be a musician than now?
- bsder 8y ago> For all of human history, we've been making music and art. And for almost all of that time, it was done for love of doing, not money. I would challenge you almost precisely the opposite. The vast majority of the "great art" was in fact done for money. For example, walk through the Parthenon and its museum, most of the art was commissioned. Look at the wall murals of Pompeii--again, done for hire. I can go on and on and on. Art not done for hire is almost exclusively a very new thing brought about by industrialization giving us enough surplus that people have enough spare time to specialize in something other than their job.
- Hoasi 8y agoRight on.
- microtherion 8y agoPretty sure the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel was not done as a volunteer graffiti job either.
- carpo 8y agoIt wasn't all through patronage though. I just finished listening to a biography of Leonardo da Vinci, and he was taught in a workshop, essentially as an apprentice. They would do independent commissions for people - portraits, statues etc. It's true that the great artists would get patronage once they were great, but it seemed that there were a bunch of these workshops with apprentices that copied the master's paintings, worked on commissions with them etc. Just thinking about it now as I write, and the Patronage is like the "made-it" moment where an artist gets rich, but I bet there were a multitude of apprentices that toiled away in workshops just making money for food.
- jedberg 8y agoIsn't a bespoke commission just an act of patronage though? If I hire you to make something for me, I'm your patron. I guess the main difference is that back then, you would sell the work and then make it. Nowadays, you make the work and then hope to sell it over and over again.
- barbecue_sauce 8y agoWell, I guess you could say that's a form of patronage, but "arts patronage" as a concept is more of a general sponsorship of an artist in the hope that they will produce significant works (and maybe have some influence over their production), rather than a transactional relationship where you are paying for a specific piece.
- carpo 8y agoPatronage seemed like a more formal thing though. They lived with the patron who would provide them a workshop, food and money. Their early days in a workshop seemed more like an employee at a business, not much different than today. The owner would have to go and find work and tap his network to find people who needed his businesses wares. He would hire employees, and they would complete jobs under his supervision. When Leonardo da Vinci was 14 and working at a workshop he was an employee of the workshop owner. It took him a long time to get a patron. He even sent letters to rich people trying to get their patronage by saying what he could do (and just like today, there was a bit of "fake it till you make" in those letters too :)
- turc1656 8y agoAbsolutely agree. The creation of technology that allowed people to scale their work is the key. With a single song/album that was sold in stored as well as being able to be played via FM radio and television, a single person could be known throughout the country (or even worldwide). That was never possible before. Prior to that, you always had to basically perform in person, which is a labor-intensive process and therefore pricier than just paying for the album and having it forever (and could also re-sell it). The number of people who could afford live performances historically is far less. To add another point on top of yours - something else to consider is that music used to be considered free. Or stated another way - without ownership. Society was the owner historically. I'm not knowledgeable enough to know the reason why this was the cause, but I've heard it talked about by historians in documentaries. I suspect it has to do with what you said - that wealthy people funded their artistic endeavors and society as a whole owned the result. Or that they weren't bankrolled by a rich person but instead collected money from passers-by on the streets as they performed. This also speaks directly to the concept of "traditionals" with no known authors.
- marssaxman 8y agoWe're seeing a return to this model in DJing, where the boundaries between performance and playback have largely disintegrated, and the difference between "making new music which repeats familiar refrains" and "pasting together bits of existing recordings to make a new piece of music" has completely dissolved. There's a complex body of compromises with copyright law which is allowing this to happen, but what's essentially going on is that everyone is silently agreeing not to get too wound up about it and we're going back to a model where music is a shared, linguistic experience, and music makers copy, echo, reframe, and reply to each other in a giant collective conversation. It's a much more interesting, relaxed experience than the hard-edged, scarcity-driven model of specific recordings with specific ownership that prevailed through the end of the 20th century.
- jdietrich 8y ago>I think people making money making music was an aberration in history, not "the way it should be". Absolute nonsense. We have evidence of professional musicians dating back to at least ancient Egypt. Plato complained in his writings about popular musicians holding unruly concerts. The invention of recorded music was a disaster for professional musicians, because it rendered most of them unemployed. People of the past had far more limited access to music, but they weren't stupid or undiscerning - they wanted to hear the best possible music and were willing to pay for it. Busking is probably as old as currency and remains a perfectly reasonable way of making a living. If you owned a bar or tavern, having the best music in town was a huge competitive advantage that you would be more than willing to pay for. Dancehalls had bands, circuses had bands, theatres had bands. The Ottoman Empire had military marching bands in at least the 13th century.
- philipov 8y agoThat's exactly what he said. People made money for -performing- music, and performing artists still make money for doing that.
- koolba 8y agoNot exactly. Before recorded music, a live band (or one man show!) was the only game in town. It was either that or silence. Everywhere that wanted to fill that silence had to hire musicians.
- philipov 8y agoIt was not "that" or silence. You're not considering that learning to play a musical instrument was itself more common. Performing music was a community activity people used to entertain themselves; the hiring of musicians was for the wealthy aristocracy.
- koolba 8y agoMaybe hire is the wrong idea. I meant more generally, “provide a venue for...”.
- magduf 8y agoIt's because of the artificial scarcity caused by the copyright laws. Now, with cheap digital distribution, that's changed a lot, even though you can't (legally) copy music and pass it around in most places. So it's going back to performances being the place for musicians to make money: the recorded music is how they advertise mostly, and then they make their real money by getting out on the road and performing in front of big crowds.
- onion2k 8y agoThe Romans in 500BC were buying decorative scupltures for their villas, medieval artists made gold jewellry for cash, renaissance painters employed entire studios of artists to churn out hundreds of paintings a year under a famous artist's 'brand'. I think the commercialization of art has been going on for at least a couple of thousand years.
- xkcd-sucks 8y agoIf you're interested the non consumption-oriented music tradition, you'll do well to check out the Clifftop ["old-time music"] Festival [0]. Basically it is a music festival in which the music is made by the attendees, and there are no formally booked or scheduled artists (kind of). A few things that surprised me (I was totally naive going in, just giving a ride to a friend en route to somewhere else): - Old time music has become a little bit of a punk scene. It seems like the young people interested in making music socially are "crust punks", because it's rowdy and free and made for acoustic instruments/voice. "Old people"and "hillbillies" make up the other half of the stereotype categories. The dynamic is interesting because you have old-school christian cultists and dreadlocked/pierced crust kids teaching each other tunes, and (almost) nobody finds any reason for conflict. - I still have songs stuck in my head that I have not heard recorded or played for years and years. Many oral tradition songs are really fucking good, presumably only the most "viral" ones survived. Many of these songs do not have a recording that sounds "right", the only time it sounds the way it crystallizes in a place and time. [0] http://www.wvculture.org/stringband/ http://www.wvculture.org/stringband/
- selimthegrim 8y agoWill now have image of crust punk playing Old Dan Tucker firmly burned into my mind
- pmoriarty 8y agoI'd like to find something like this for electronic music.
- anigbrowl 8y agoThis argument crops up on every discussion of this topic. Why is it always people who work in the arts always told their work isn't worthy of payment except when delivered under certain conditions? If you don't think artists should be paid, then neither should programmers.
- jjeaff 8y agoSaying there isn't a market for something is not the same as saying they aren't worthy of being paid.
- anigbrowl 8y agoThere obviously is a market for songwriting and composition, but anger over excessive copyright (eg Disney style life+90) has drastically undermined all copyright. It's throwing the baby out with the bathwater, and is justified (above and in other comments below) on the idea that music lacks utility.
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoYou're right -- I think the reason this is so contentious is that the market for recorded music didn't collapse, to the degree it did, due to lack of demand; it collapsed due to the marginal cost of reproduction dropping to effectively nothing. I'm not making a moral argument here, lest market libertarians prepare to jump -- I'm not saying the market as it existed should have been propped up artificially. I'm just making the observation that "there is no market for recorded music" is a very different statement than "there is no market for horse-drawn carriages." People are listening to recorded music as much as ever, by some measures more so; we just don't expect to have to pay more than ten bucks a month for All The Music.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoSpotify could pay far more for each stream than it does. But it chooses not to, and the money mysteriously disappears into the bank accounts of the management team, assorted investors and Spotify's owners - which include the major record companies. The arts publishing/management/distribution businesses have always been about relentlessly screwing value out of creators, usually by leveraging differences in political and corporate power to intimidate and bully creators into "voluntarily" signing over their income in return for access to various walled-garden markets. Streaming media have really taken it to a new level.
- wwweston 8y agoSure, music will always exist as a human form of expression. It's just more likely to exist in the same way your hobby projects compete with your full time job. Lots exist as concept only. Some are half-finished but never ship. Maybe some of them get done. What could you have done if people payed you to do what you cared about? Patronage is... a thing. Better than nothing. But obviously a weaker form of economic systematizing than a model where you pay to listen to a performance or a recording. I mean, if you're designing a system function, do you want it to reliably tie outputs to inputs, or optionally tie outputs to inputs? And yes, the economics matter, even considering the "love" factor. Paying for things supports the enterprise that goes into providing them. Diluting or disconnecting payment from the music is another way of saying "in order to make music, you should be spending time doing things that aren't making music." And the problem with that is that Time is the primary ingredient that goes into making music. More time goes into making music that's "better" by any number of reward functions in listeners. You can cheat that rule a little bit at the margins with better tools or inherent talent more than a standard deviation or two above the mean, but the significance of those terms in the equation is generally less than capital-T time. Which means diluting/disconnecting payment either limits the output of people who don't have outside resources, or limits the quality of the music produced.
- chii 8y ago> do you want it to reliably tie outputs to inputs, or optionally tie outputs to inputs? if the input to music is money, i argue that the output is poor quality music. > Paying for things supports the enterprise that goes into providing them and thereby changing the goal of the enterprise from producing music, to producing money from music. Look at modern pop music today? They are pretty terrible at best. And yet, the money keeps flowing in! Nobody is saying that artists don't get paid - they get paid by selling their music in some form, and performing their music. But because the motivations for them doing music ins't due to money, the product end up being a labour of love - a true expression of art. I think patronage achieves the same goals, where as a mass market music business model doesn't get the same result because the goals of a mass market music business is to saturate, and to make sure that their audience is huge (so you end up with pop music).
- Fricken 8y agoFor most of human history nobody made money doing anything. Capitalism is an an abberation in history, not "the way it should be".
- throwaway8879 8y agoIn fact, I would say there is no "the way it should be". Capitalism seems to have a net positive effect on the majority of the planet. Let's stick with it.
- Fricken 8y agoCapitalism is destroying the planet. That's hardly a net positive. In fact it's the worst thing possible. There is nothing humans are even theoretically capable of that is worse.
- ovao 8y ago> There is nothing humans are even theoretically capable of that is worse [than capitalism]. A bartender once made me an Old Fashioned without muddling the sugar. Are you certain that’s not worse?
- selectodude 8y agoWhat is the suggested alternative to a market economy? Command economies aren't what I would consider better for the globe. Energy intensity per unit of labor is almost universally lower in market economies than it is in command economies.
- throwaway8879 8y agoThere is no alternative unless we magically have free energy. The only way out of this is to colonize the solar system, galaxy. At that point the Earth's status as a habitable planet will hardly matter.
- Fricken 8y agoA market economy would be fine if it's impact on the ecology was priced in.
- clairity 8y agoart and music do require skill, and people will pay for good art/music no matter the availability. take pop music (of all sorts) for example. the money that pours into it is puzzling if you consider the music on its own merits. the melodies are catchy and the lyrics too, but no one really considers it high art. any barroom crooner could sing and play it. (in fact singing is probably the most accessible and widely distributed art form. we're all born with the instrument and a little practice is all that's needed for passable entertainment.) so why do pop stars make so much money? it's simply not scarcity that drives the price. it's fashion, or culture, or whatever you prefer to call it. it's the need to forget our troubles. it's our secret hopes and dreams routed through a channel for bonding with our fellow man. that's what we're paying for. and we'll likely always pay for it. but whether the marketing machine of yesteryear can continue to maintain a stranglehold on access and taste is really the open question.
- tomcam 8y ago> no one really considers it high art. any barroom crooner could sing and play it Um, no. I say this as a holder of season tickets to the opera and as a trained operatic tenor myself. Many, many pop singers are incredibly good and far outstrip the skills of most barroom singers I have experienced.
- mamon 8y agoIt's not that pop singers aren't talented. It's just that pop music as a genre is pretty much boring, and the artists that appear every season, or every "America's got talent" edition, they all are easily forgettable. You could switch covers and sell Selena Gomez album as Ariana Grande album and noone would even notice the difference. Pop music is a commodity, and as any commodity it's pricing/value is basically a race to bottom.
- tomcam 8y agoThat’s not the point GP made. Selena Gomez and Ariana Grande have roughly similar genres but Ariana is a musical titan who can famously sing in any style she chooses.
- nannePOPI 8y agothis argument against IP is really good
- jellicle 8y agoPlenty of people are making money in music, just not artists.
- antocv 8y agoPlenty of people are making money in software especially from free and open source, just not the developers.
- pmoriarty 8y ago"I think people making money making music was an aberration in history, not "the way it should be"." I don't want to put words in your mouth, but are you saying you think we should go back to the way musicians used to be treated in the past? That's a rather reactionary position. Historically, women in most societies were treated very poorly, often treated like property, and you could say that women being treated with respect is an "abberation in history". But so what? That doesn't mean we have to go back to when women were treated like crap just because that's the way they've mostly been treated before. Slavery was the norm in many societies for thousands of years, and you could similarly say the lack of slavery is an aberration in history. That doesn't mean it's a good idea to bring back slavery. If you want to argue that making money off of making music is wrong, you have to make a stronger case for that position than simply saying that's not the way it was in the past.
- Stratoscope 8y ago> I don't want to put words in your mouth... Then don't.
- Stratoscope 8y agoI apologize for my previous comment being rather terse. I should have taken the time to write a more reasoned reply. I was responding to this: > I don't want to put words in your mouth, but are you saying you think we should go back to the way musicians used to be treated in the past? > That's a rather reactionary position. That was just the start... > Historically, women in most societies were treated very poorly... > Slavery was the norm in many societies for thousands of years... And these had what to do with the original comment? Then the coup de grâce: > If you want to argue that... This is the very definition of putting words in someone's mouth! And it's not a nice thing to do.
- catach 8y agoAsking if a consequence is intended is different from asserting that a consequence is intended.
- arvinsim 8y ago
- wslh 8y ago> I think people making money making music was an aberration in history, not "the way it should be". I assume you apply the same thinking to software, or movies, which also create artificial scarcity. It is just that movies and software are a new thing. Do you?
- InclinedPlane 8y agoI think there's somewhat of a leap of logic in there. The idea that the transition to the present era is due to the end of artificial scarcity is questionable considering how many confounding variables there are. Look at the graph of real median income vs. per capita gdp or productivity, income has been flat even while the economy grows. And this somewhat understates the problem because the economy today is different than what it was back in the 1970s. A huge segment of the working class is being pinched, economically, and they have less money to spend than they might otherwise. It shouldn't be shocking that people are spending less on things like music when they can do so. That doesn't necessarily mean that they wouldn't spend plenty if their earnings were in line with pre 1980 historical norms, however.
- kosei 8y agoI'd be curious to know also how many people are still being paid for their work as artists through movies, TV, video games, etc. I bet it is also a significantly larger percentage of the population than a few hundred years ago.
- dwd 8y agoNot so much aberration but a gradual corporatisation and then collapse of the industry of "recorded music". To a large extent the performance side of music has remained unchanged. For a period it may have become subservient to the recording side where artists "toured" an album, but a lot of what went on was due to artists patronage from the respective recording rights holders.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoRegarding the scarcity thing: I still listen to the same music, but for free. YT, downloaded a while back etc etc.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoYou could apply this argument to almost literally anything that people do or have done for money. It's a bad argument. It ignores the fact that humans progress by division of talent and labour. You wouldn't apply it to physicists, engineers, medical specialists, lawyers, politicians [1], financial experts, sports, or software developers. So why is it fine to apply it to an art? The predictable outcome is that you'll get mediocre unsatisfying art that leaves everyone involved feeling like something vital is missing - which is more or less where we are now. In fact it takes many more years of study and experience to become a competent, productive musician, artist, novelist, or other creative worker, than it does to become a software developer. The arts are a profession, not a hobby. Just because most people can have a go doesn't mean it makes sense to run them on an amateur basis - any more than it does to run software development in the same way. [1] The one category it probably should apply to.
- Ace17 8y ago> It's a bad argument. It ignores the fact that humans progress by division of talent and labour. I suspect the "bad" argument is actually compatible with division of talent and labour. Could you explain the link between this division and income? > You wouldn't apply it to physicists, engineers, medical specialists, lawyers, politicians [1], financial experts, sports, or software developers. > So why is it fine to apply it to an art? Because history shows us that "some" art gets done, even when no money is directly involved. And actually, it's the same for physicists, engineers, sports, software developers - not sure about lawyers, policitans, or financial experts. Now we have to ask ourselves: for all these domains, what's an acceptable amount for "some"?
- buro9 8y agoI worked in the music industry for a decade and contributed to research to determine the value of music. Everything I learned said one thing: The value was high when scarcity was controlled, and scarcity was mostly controlled by distributors and those involved in distributing art would make the most money - not the artist. That the artist, and even the record label, make any money is a mere side effect and overspill of the money made by controlling distribution. I think jedberg is right on this, the more I saw and learned the more I too believed that the natural model for art and music was patronage. Distribution (be it limited by production of physical media, or controlled by tech companies now) is an entirely artificial construct... where physical media at least was plausibly scarce, the digital is not.
- buro9 8y agoAlso the best way to summarise the research and the distribution angle was: The avg value a consumer expresses for: * listening on a radio in medium or high quality is near zero * downloading a track in medium quality is near zero. * buying an CD album in high quality is 75p per track. * buying a CD single in high quality is 25 per track. * buying sheet music in an abstract quality is £3 per track. * buying a midi file to use as a ring-tone in lowest quality for portion of the track is close to £12 per track. The fidelity and quality were not a major influence on the value... but the distribution and how controlled or locked-down the distribution and means of playback for the end consumer of the music had a direct impact on the value. The ring-tone was DRM'd (badly) at the time, which meant it was not trivial to put your own music on there but yet people would pay £1 for barely 20 seconds of a barely recognisable midi file. The more you can lock down the distribution and control the means to access the media, the more you can push the price up. Or as I think it... if Apple hadn't come along and artificially held the value of music at the price it did by controlling distribution, the sooner we would have reached another age of patronage. I still believe that Apple, and now Spotify, are merely holding back the inevitable and they haven't stopped it but will get very rich in the interim.
- snowwrestler 8y agoI think it's incomplete to characterize the state of the industry today without discussing how those consumer perceptions of value were intentionally created. If you worked in the music industry for 10 years then your experience almost completely post-dates these efforts. Starting even well before Napster, investors and technology companies saw the opportunity to change the allocation of value from artists and producers, to distribution. To be clear, that was not the allocation 30+ years ago. Record stores and radio stations did not make immensely more money than the labels and artists. Tech companies and investors worked aggressively to "commoditize their complement"--that is, depress the value of art on their platforms, so that they could reallocate consumer spending to their products and services. "Buy a computer and Internet connection and you can have all the music and movies you want for free" was explicitly advertised by technology companies--see for example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xAxtxPAUcwQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xAxtxPAUcwQ I think this historical perspective is crucial for understanding how we got to today. Music files are small, so the music industry was attacked first. The large size of video files kept them safe for long enough for visual artists and producers to understand what was happening and counteract. That is why you see producer-owned distribution channels for video today (Hulu, HBO Go, Disney+, etc), but not label-owned distribution channels for music. This is why Netflix, Amazon, and now Apple have had to get into original video content. They were not able to beat the movie and TV producers before the producers could figure out the technology themselves.
- 3xblah 8y agoThe emergence of "music industry" has probably resulted in higher quantity of music but also more lower quality music. Touring is not easy work. It stands to reason that "love of doing" is still a primary motivation.
- Proven 8y agoWhy shouldn’t it be? If people or companies are affluent enough to sponsor artists, it should be easier than ever because in addition to the historicall “exclusive” sponsorship we have a variety of means including crowdsourcing and event-based sponsorship. Related to the two decade old socialist nonsense that information (MP3, ISOs, etc) wants to be free, I agree with the article’s expectation that musicians will tend to record less and perform more because if there’s no way to make money from it, why bother (assuming you’re a pro musician)
- pyb 8y agoI disagree very strongly. For most of human history, the arts existed for a huge part in the service of religion, and therefore were instruments of power and wealth.
- snowwrestler 8y agoIt's gross to say that making a living by creating art that people love is an "aberration." It's not like recorded music is unpopular--it's more popular than ever. But for some reason, now people are bad for expecting to make money creating it? To be clear, there is still scarcity: new music you like is scarce. That is universally true; new music doesn't just appear, it has to be made, and until it is made, you can't get it. That is the definition of scarcity: "the state of being in short supply." Music in general is not scarce, but some music is more popular than others. Shouldn't a normally functioning economy account for that? New recorded music from Daft Punk is in short supply; it is scarce. Are the members of Daft Punk an "aberration" (definition: an unwelcome deviation from normal) for wanting to be compensated for reducing that scarcity? How is that different from a new video game being released? For all of human history, we've been making and playing games. Is it an "aberration" for people who make video games to want to get compensated for reducing the scarcity of new games? If we want to play the "doing it for love" game, then let's be clear that you, and anyone else, is welcome to make music for free, play it for free, record and release it for free. There is nothing stopping people from doing it for "the love"; in fact it is easier than ever to make music for free. But it is IMO abusive to then say, well doing it for free is the only acceptable norm, just because they like to do it. I like to work with computers, but guess what: I also get paid do it. I bet you do too! Why is that normal for you and me, but an aberration for musicians? Usually when people talk about "scarcity being gone" they mean that digital files can be copied and distributed with almost no marginal cost. Well guess what: so can financial instruments. Should we stop charging for Apple stock just because Apple can create new stock at the click of a button? Why do supposedly digitally-savvy folks get so hung up on the fact that music comes on digital files? Lots of things come on digital files, like your direct deposit salary payments. Does that mean money is not scarce anymore?
- kntoukakis 8y agoI think this is historically inaccurate and tbh it's also a bit dangerous to think that, making money from your art is wrong because this wasn't always the case. There’s nothing wrong with making money from your art. People weren’t making money from art in the past centuries because until a recent time in history there was no market for it or for almost anything else, and also no property rights. The only market there was after the fall of the Roman Empire and until the end of feudalism, was church commissioning some art and construction. Also, I don't understand the argument about artificial scarcity. Original art has inherent scarcity, and this is the foundation of the art market. And a digital album that can be copied by anyone with a tape recorder, CD drive or computer didn't prevent bands from making serious money, even in an environment of abundance. Finally, markets are not that easy. There is a market for art as there is a market for SaaS, or services. And most SaaS companies fail, just like most consulting agencies and most artists that don't become commercially successful. Artists choose to seek patronage in order to minimise risk, and we are lucky that contrary to the past, they can do so without giving up their rights to opportunity, as it used to be the case.
- coldtea 8y ago>I think people making money making music was an aberration in history, not "the way it should be". Whether that is "the way it should be" or not, depends on what we want it to be as a society. Not to whether some technology helps it or not. Untraceable murder could be very easy tomorrow with some new technology, but we'd still not want it to happen. So the part that "artificial scarcity" helped musicians make money off of their art, is a historical and technological accident. But whether artists should be able to make money off of their art (scarcity be damned) is an ethical and "what kind of society we want" question. We shouldn't abandon our "oughts" at the first sign of some technology working against them.
- ionwake 8y agoThis is great insightful comment, thank you.