10 ms·
ST:DS9 was originally shot on film like ST:TNG, but the market performance of the TNG remaster makes it very unlikely that DS9 will receive the same treatment.
by CharlesW 8y ago
ST:DS9 was originally shot on film like ST:TNG, but the market performance of the TNG remaster makes it very unlikely that DS9 will receive the same treatment.
"Essentially, for the HD release of Star Trek, all people had to do was scan each episode. For The Next Generation, they would have to scan all those original pieces of film and then edit together each episode again, themselves. It’s more difficult, more expensive, and much more time-consuming.
"Unfortunately, it wasn’t actually worth it. Sales of the extravagant TNG remaster—original retail price $118 for just season one—failed to reach CBS and Paramount’s expectations. A similar process would have to be done for both DS9 and Voyager—and would actually be even harder."
https://io9.gizmodo.com/the-detailed-depressing-reason-deep-space-nine-and-voy-1791962332 https://io9.gizmodo.com/the-detailed-depressing-reason-deep-...
- nerpderp82 8y agoBut you could take the raw footage and the edited video and recreate the edit lists (which they should still have btw). Or just scan each film frame, then match the video to film frame by frame and re-assemble the list of frames. All software done by one person. No creativity or judgement needed.
- jjeaff 8y agoSend out a call for volunteers. I guarantee you, you'd have a group of fans with the know how to do it. And they would do it for free.
- rbanffy 8y agoAnd if the technology doesn't exist, they'll probably invent it too. This is Star Trek we are talking about. Their fans are dead serious.
- jjeaff 8y agoYa, I can't think of any show with such a long lasting, rabid fan base. Just look at that recent "fan film" that CBS tried to sue over. Production quality was off the charts for a fan film.
- rbanffy 8y agoAxanar was pretty impressive, but I love what the Star Trek continues crew did. The love and respect they showed to the original material was very impressive.
- kitsunesoba 8y agoIt’s pretty crazy. If the franchise were somehow freed from copyright control I have no doubt that several near-studio-quality fan productions would pop up in no time at all. People love their Trek.
- isostatic 8y agoSo was the budget, hence the court case.
- noir_lord 8y agoWe are, we also tend to skew more towards the technology end of the spectrum than the average TV show fans.
- logfromblammo 8y ago~Just run the colorquads through the main optical processor, then reverse the polarity, compress the lightstream in the warp field, and blit the output texels through the main deflector dish. That creates a virtual lightfield holo-display, using the starfield as the light source, with practically infinite resolution. Then all you need to do is point an image recorder at it, and downsample back to 1080p at 60Hz.~
- mrexroad 8y agoDon’t forget to account for the temporal variance created by high levels of tachyon emissions.
- fredsanford 8y agoYou missed a TNG buzzword... Dilithium Crystals. :P
- nerpderp82 8y agoBut the parent used the reflector dish, any good hack always utilizes the RD.
- sandworm101 8y agoThe fans will come, but there are limits to how far even they will go to create a product that will be owned and sold by someone else. Having toiled to edit together the HD version, id be screaming mad to see it sold for 100+ per season. If it was made by fans it should be sold at cost.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoFWIW, they failed to recoup their investment in TNG's remaster, selling at 100+ per season. By definition, that arguably means it was sold below cost. (I bought individual TNG remaster seasons as they came out specifically to support the remaster effort.)
- sandworm101 8y agoNo. It means they charged too much. The fans were priced out of the market and, probably, acquired copies elsewhere.
- twoodfin 8y agoThe Blu-Ray sales can’t be the real story. Surely they expected the long term value to come from the significantly added appeal of HD content for streaming services. IAE, I can understand the reasons something upscaled is all we’re ever likely to see of DS9 or Voyager. Primarily that as soon as CGI became the dominant effects technology, the frequency of use went way up, and all those scenes would require non-trivial reconstruction.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoI am sure the TNG remaster will eventually be worthwhile to CBS, due to streaming, re-releases, etc. It's an asset they will monetize for decades to come. But studios do not think long-term like that, and are unlikely to attempt it again if they don't think they'll make their money back for twenty years. As I noted in another comment, many of the effects artists from DS9 and Voyager have their original meshes and scene files, and some have posted insanely high resolution files on their blogs. It would be a frustrating effort to gather all of this, but arguably, CBS already owns the works in question, so compensation for retrieving these would be minimal probably, and the quality of the work done for the series was more than adequate if re-rendered in HD.
- reaperducer 8y agoI guarantee you, you'd have a group of fans with the know how to do it. And they would do it for free. The problem is they'd devolve into various camps bickering about the "right" way to do it, creating their own mini standards bodies, and forming a massive internal bureaucracy of tribalism. It seems the more passionate a group of people is about something, the more convinced they are that they know the right way to do things.
- xfitm3 8y agoYou just described a prior workplace.
- isostatic 8y agoThe bulk of the work is cleaning up each of the scans, re-framing the picture, balancing the color, and making sure the correct takes are used, rather than simply applying an EDL. It's possible ML could help with a lot of that, but the budget just isn't there. While it was shot on film, the effects weren't, each has to be created again, not just the external scenes like the Defiant shooting something, but scenes like Odo morphing Here's a comparison picture of the DVD vs film quality though https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/rlppv8gs4mvpp2mgz9ju.jpg https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/rlppv8gs4m...
- ghostly_s 8y agoWow. The film looks so good. This upsampling, on the other hand, is to my eyes so subtle of an improvement to almost be imperceptible.
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agoIt has artefacts. If you look at some near similar defined geometrys, they stay unmoving for split seconds. Siscos upper head collapses in on himself, when he moves..
- isostatic 8y agoI think I saw that on the DVDs themselves, or at least on netflix. I suspect the source material was heavily compressed
- aidenn0 8y agoThat's an incredible difference. Obviously NTSC was going to lose a lot of color detail, but it also lost quite a bit of vibrancy. In particular the warm highlight lighting from offscreen to the right is barely visible in the DVD version, but on the film version it really pops; look at his sleeve, the shadow cast by his hand, and the contrast of the bottle with the background. The value contrast is similar but the color contrast is greatly muted. [edit] On second thought, considering the shirts that Jake wore on the show, it's probably better for the world that we don't have the higher vibrancy film version.,,
- mseiko 8y agoIf I understand correctly, you would still have to overlay text, voice over, sound, music, etc. That's still a lot of work.
- 3JPLW 8y agoAnd even worse is special effects.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agoThey should crowdsource that work- start operation Turktrek. (Sorry i couldnt resist).
- philwelch 8y agoIf it's an issue of fixed upfront costs, they can literally do a kickstarter and it will get funded.
- behringer 8y agoI doubt paramounts hurting for money. Imagine they want to do a kickstarter and it's only 800 for the series.
- ianai 8y agoNot a bad idea for a franchise like Star Trek. Basically judge whether market demand is high enough by asking for the whole production price upfront. Wouldn’t work for most media, but would for a known product.
- IntelMiner 8y agoIt'd probably get thrown out by the lawyers for various nebulous (though valid) reasons "What if we go over budget?" "Does this mean they 'own' any rights to the remaster?"
- ianai 8y agoIsn’t that answered by the nature of kickstarter? If your lawyers aren’t offering solutions to implement your idea get new lawyers.
- johannes1234321 8y agoThe lawyers have to protect the shareholders, else the executives picking the lawyers are being kicked out.
- gdubs 8y agoWasn’t worth commercially, but as a fan I’m really happy they did it.
- muterad_murilax 8y ago> they would have to scan all those original pieces of film and then edit together each episode again, themselves. Once they have manually scanned all those pieces, surely they can let machine learning edit together each episode again?
- vowelless 8y agoHow would you go about doing that?
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoI’m guessing by using image recognition of the original digital / DVD releases against the newly scanned hi-def video?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- isostatic 8y agoYou'd have to match the framing and position, and clean up the frame. Then try to color balance (when the original information isn't there), If you get ML to do that, congratulations, you'll make a fortune in the production industry.
- vernie 8y agoI think you overestimate how difficult that is and how much it's worth.
- isostatic 8y agoI've never done it myself, basing it on the cost of the machines that professionals do, and the cost of employing people to do it (both do it and make the judgement calls), you're probably looking at $200k for feature film quality. If you're aiming for network TV quality you can probably do an episode for $5k though. Of course that's from scratch. The trouble is that using the original video as your source will have lost a lot of data, and that means making a lot of judgement calls about what the scene is meant to be doing, so you're not much nearer.
- mbell 8y agoA bigger part of the issue with these remasters tends to be the conversion to 16x9 which most people expect with HD. Even if you have the 'missing' out of shot data on the origin film there are often problems where set equipment, cameramen, etc are just out of the shot so it requires manual digital touch up to fix. It also can require re-rendering any CGI. When I saw the submission title I was actually hoping re-creating the out of shot image data is what the ML was being used to do.
- pushpop 8y agoThe remastered TNG box sets kept the same 4:3 aspect ratio as the original standard definition. Some TV networks have aired a 16:9 version of TNG (as well as an upscaled Voyager and DS9) but they just zoomed and cropped. There wasn't anything smart going on.
- danso 8y agoI wonder if it would be worth it for long tail revenues from streaming? I can’t imagine the HD widescreen remaster of The Wire selling lots of new DVDs (it was completed in late 2014 [0]), but it made the show a lot more appealing for continued rewatching over the years. 0: https://davidsimon.com/the-wire-hd-with-videos/ https://davidsimon.com/the-wire-hd-with-videos/
- stronglikedan 8y ago> original retail price $118 for just season one Well, there's your problem right there. Expecting three figures for a single season of anything is just pure madness.
- mjevans 8y agoI think my shock price is roughly in the ballpark of 15 to 20 USD per season, and a maximum of roughly 100 USD total for an entire show. Yes, this means if a show lasted more than 5 to 7 seasons I expect a discount on the remastered version!
- devoply 8y agoI want an online version that will exist for at least 10 more years preferably 20 for $100 with the DVD copy, sold by one of the giants with the budget to sustain that.
- vondur 8y agoThis. I bought the first trial disk for Star Trek TNG, which had a couple of episodes that had been redone in HD. They looked great, but when I saw the price for each season, I ended up not purchasing them.
- ravenstine 8y agoThat and remastered(or so I thought... I think they're in 4:3 aspect) episodes being available on Netflix makes it really hard to justify paying at all for discs.
- Bluestrike2 8y agoThe show was originally shot for 4:3, that didn't change when it was remastered. Thank goodness. It was very impressive remaster, as shown in various comparisons: http://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/observations/tng-r-changes.htm http://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/observations/tng-r-changes...
- 8y ago
- etaerc 8y agoAlso, this kind of stuff of course can only be profitable in the long tail. So what means failed to reach any expectations? If it gets a reasonable price it will probably constantly sell in low amounts for 10+ years.
- npsimons 8y ago> original retail price $118 for just season one Where, precisely, did that number come from? It doesn't happen to include marketing, does it?