7 ms·
Why big tech should fear Europe
- dmitriid 8y ago> Europe could soon pass new digital copyright laws. If they mean Article 13, that law benefits big companies, and big companies only. A good overview: - https://juliareda.eu/2019/02/eu-copyright-final-text/ https://juliareda.eu/2019/02/eu-copyright-final-text/ - https://juliareda.eu/2019/02/article-13-worse/ https://juliareda.eu/2019/02/article-13-worse/
- pascalxus 8y ago"Should a court ever find their licensing or filtering efforts not fierce enough, sites are directly liable for infringements as if they had committed them themselves. This massive threat will lead platforms to over-comply with these rules to stay on the safe side, further worsening the impact on our freedom of speech." And, lets not forget, This is an enormous liability ripe for legal abuse.
- calgoo 8y agoThis will be abused by governments and people who dont want something published. For example, here in Spain one of the past presidents wanted to make an anti-meme law as everyone was making fun of him[1]. Luckily we laughed, and he was replaced, but the kind of thing WILL happen now that they have a tool. [1] https://www.rt.com/news/366642-spain-meme-ban-backlash/ https://www.rt.com/news/366642-spain-meme-ban-backlash/ Edit: spelling
- ApolloFortyNine 8y agoWhat's scary about this to me is any implementation of ContentID will be based in some sort of score way, determining the likelyhood that something is infringing. These scores would be completely arbitrary, but you should be able to imagine the outcry if it became public that Google set the score for removal to 1000, but if they had set it 5000 would have blocked 5 times more copyrighted material. The public/politicians wouldn't understand these numbers are both made up (and so any difference between them is really meaningless), and would lead to more blocking of legal material.
- jimmy1 8y ago> Why big tech should fear Europe Big Tech decides regulations are too costly, leaves Europe completely European bureaucrats: suprised_pikachu.jpg But seriously, If this does happen I am sure the tech talent can rebuild what left, and that might be better overall for general prosperity, or it might not be, and the crippling cost of compliance shutters new growth. I guess we will soon enough figure out either way.
- mk89 8y ago> Big Tech decides regulations are too costly, leaves Europe completely That will never be the case as long as Europe has a functioning economy. Look at countries like China -> everyone (Google, Microsoft, Facebook...) wants to get in, although the price to pay is really high. These fines only affect small/medium sized companies that don't have a strong business in Europe, so it doesn't make any sense for them to get fined.
- sbacic 8y agoThat's absolutely true. However, there is one thing that isn't mentioned nearly enough - not all European countries (markets?) get the same levels of service. For example, there is still no iTunes store in my country or Amazon Prime delivery. I can't even sell apps on the Google Play store because my country is not supported. And those are just the examples I can think of off the top of my head.
- anoncake 8y agoThe issue here is too little regulation. The EU really needs to outlaw discriminating against its member states.
- sbacic 8y agoI'm not sure if you can do that - what you're essentially suggesting is that the EU forces companies to provide their services in certain EU members, whether it makes sense for them or not.
- buboard 8y agoNext up: the EU legislates 4% growth
- devoply 8y agoEurope should kick out or properly tax all the tech giants operating in its borders. It should also figure out a way to foster local competition for all that large tech companies. I wonder what would happen if they poured a couple of hundred billion dollars into a facebook competitor. Facebook's network effects are legion but their technology is trivial to copy.
- luckydata 8y agoWhy would Europe finance its own version of a cultural cancer? Investing in business tech would make TONS more sense.
- oaiey 8y agoHave not we done that in the past :)
- elorant 8y agoWho on earth would raise 200bn in capital? The public sector can't finance private institutions because it's against the EU laws. As a matter of fact a lot of local governments have been fined for supporting big corporations with public funding. Other than that, VC funding isn't as strong as it is in US and I doubt they give more than 30-40bn in total funds in a year.
- Hamuko 8y ago>The public sector can't finance private institutions because it's against the EU laws. This isn't actually true.
- bobcostas55 8y ago>It should also figure out a way to foster local competition for all that large tech companies. This would require a radical, top-to-bottom reorganization of the entire European political structure. Not gonna happen.
- kzrdude 8y agoIf antitrust legislation was being used properly in us and Europe, we'd have more choice instead of the Facebook cluster of services
- Proven 8y agoThat's funny. Unless you rely on the government to steal for you (green fraud, subsidies, etc) there's no point in trying to do anything in the EU (if you can choose).
- sbacic 8y agoI think Europe is dead set on legislating itself into digital irrelevancy. Instead of focusing on the obvious question (why is there not a single European company in the top 15 internet companies?) they're obsessed with finding ways to tax US internet giants as much as they can, in any way they can, without giving a damn about the collateral damage they are causing to their own small businesses in the process. What should _really_ concern the powers that be is that Europe has become a place to sell things, not make them.
- Hamuko 8y ago>I think Europe is dead set on legislating itself into digital irrelevancy. Just because the EU passed privacy regulations?
- ApolloFortyNine 8y agoI'm almost 100% sure he's referencing Articles 11 and 13.
- sbacic 8y agoNo, that's (arguably - but I'd say yes) one of the rare good ideas. It's stuff like the VAT directive and the new Copyright directive that are the problems. The Copyright directive in particular - we Europeans often found some comfort in the fact that corporate lobbies don't have nearly as much power in the EU as they do in the US. Sadly, if that directive passes, we won't even have that.
- mpweiher 8y ago> ways to tax US internet giants as much as they can Er, no. Just to tax them at all. US companies have been completely dodging paying taxes in Europe (effective tax rates of <1% on billions of profits).
- sbacic 8y agoKeep in mind that US companies are selling things in Europe. They're not making them. The cost to create those things are borne somewhere else - so it definitely makes sense to shift profits - otherwise you'd end up in a situation where all those expenses aren't really tax exempt.
- hashberry 8y agoGDPR compliance is expensive to implement correctly. It's more about data regulation than privacy. It hurts small startup firms who don't have the resources or time, and rewards large companies that do.
- Hamuko 8y ago>GDPR compliance is expensive to implement correctly It's really not unless your business model involves selling data.
- noir_lord 8y agoBasically this. We don't sell data, We make things which we sell to people. GDPR was a pain in that it was work we didn't previously have to do but it wasn't hard to comply with. FWIW I'm completely in favour of it as well, it's about damn time.
- dmitriid 8y agoNot expensive at all. It was and is much more expensive for the big companies and established players. Only use the data that you need, and you’re 90% GDPR compliant. The other 10% is making sure that you can delete data. If your startup relies on sending private data to hundreds of ad agencies and trackers, for example, it’s a good thing your startup struggles.
- throwaway_9168 8y agoBig tech has nothing to fear at all. Europe is waging an all out war on companies/entrepreneurship of every size. Big tech will probably face massive losses. On the other hand, a bootstrapped company/MicroISV or whatever you want to call it these days will not face any loss, because it would have been legislated out of even being born. So big tech will probably be secretly cheering on the greater chance of establishing monopoly.